[Halifax] Elmwood Hotel (5189 South) | 28 M | 9 fl | U/C


Dmajackson

Moderator
[Halifax] 5189 South Street | 20 m | 6 fl | Proposed

There is a public open house scheduled for June 8th, 2016 @ 7pm @ The Westin to discuss the proposal for a mixed-use building at 5185-89 South Street (NW corner at Barrington). It will house 8'000 sq ft of ground floor commercial and 42 residential units above.

The only information available right now is at http://principaldevelopments.com/
 
There is a public open house scheduled for June 8th, 2016 @ 7pm @ The Westin to discuss the proposal for a mixed-use building at 5185-89 South Street (NW corner at Barrington). It will house 8'000 sq ft of ground floor commercial and 42 residential units above.

The only information available right now is at http://principaldevelopments.com/

That is really, really disappointing! 5189 South is that beautiful yellow Victorian across from Cornwallis Park. To have it redeveloped would be bad enough, but to have it redeveloped with what looks like a pretty uninspired piece of architecture is painful.
 
That is really, really disappointing! 5189 South is that beautiful yellow Victorian across from Cornwallis Park. To have it redeveloped would be bad enough, but to have it redeveloped with what looks like a pretty uninspired piece of architecture is painful.

I wouldn't call it beautiful. Have you walked past it lately? It would take a lot of money to bring it back from the student slum it's become. That being said, that is not at all an attractive proposal for such a prominent corner.
 
I wouldn't call it beautiful. Have you walked past it lately? It would take a lot of money to bring it back from the student slum it's become. That being said, that is not at all an attractive proposal for such a prominent corner.

I'm honestly sick of these "it's run down, so oh well" arguments. I have no empathy for developers who want to rip down the scanty remaining great buildings we have lest from earlier eras and erect their garbage. I guarantee almost any developer, in any city besides Halifax, would be interested in restoring this building. This shit does not happen anymore in other cities.

In any case, I've not just walked past in lately, I've been in it. Have some friends who moved our last year. It's in need of major renovation, but it's not falling apart or anything. There is no reason at all it can't be restored, except for laziness and/or cheapness, neither of which are acceptable in an urban property developer.

I don't know what's wrong with our development community, but they're more eager to fire up the wrecking ball than any collection of developers I've ever encountered in this country. This is just crap.
 
Last edited:
Gotta say I'm getting pretty disappointed in my hometown. Yet another situation where a unique 19th century building will be torn down to facilitate another low-quality generic structure. This old building is significant in this area and one of the few of its type remaining. It really adds a nice backdrop for the-park-with-no-name, and really contributes to the character of that area of Barrington, which was once a very prominent part of the city and has managed to retain some pretty nice structures from the mid-late 1800s. Errr... I should say: "had managed to maintain until recently".

I almost can't believe they are planning to knock this one down, except for the fact that this is getting to be commonplace here, so actually I'm starting to expect it - almost becoming numb to it. ...And of course the city will have nothing to say about it - kinda pathetic, really.

Living my entire life here, I've always thought that Halifax is behind the times, and yet again this remains true as we are still treating our heritage stock the same way that we did in the 1960s and 70s, while other places have recognized their value and have made some effort to preserve such structures.

Sigh, what a bunch of morons we have running things here...

Iu6WexL.jpg


dQJd4fk.jpg


https://www.halifax.ca/council/agendasc/documents/150324ca1131.pdf
 
I almost can't believe they are planning to knock this one down, except for the fact that this is getting to be commonplace here, so actually I'm starting to expect it - almost becoming numb to it. ...And of course the city will have nothing to say about it - kinda pathetic, really.

Living my entire life here, I've always thought that Halifax is behind the times, and yet again this remains true as we are still treating our heritage stock the same way that we did in the 1960s and 70s, while other places have recognized their value and have made some effort to preserve such structures.

That's exactly correct. I can't believe how retrograde we are on this. And it's getting worse, not better.

The Barrington South HCD should be in effect eventually (Waye Mason thinks Sept/Oct) but if they applies to demolish before that, the as-of-right demolition will be grandfathered and that'll be that.

Pathetic.
 
I wouldn't call it beautiful. Have you walked past it lately? It would take a lot of money to bring it back from the student slum it's become. That being said, that is not at all an attractive proposal for such a prominent corner.

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder... I would not hesitate to call it beautiful were it painted. I'd also add it's of a type that is becoming less common.... not many left with the verandas - most of the Victorian housing stock it the type pushed up close to the sidewalk with very little domestic outdoor space in front (saving for the rear)... it's a very different approach to urbanism.

I really don't think it would take a ton of cash to keep it in decent shape. Maybe I'm wrong.

This building is something I'd think would be worth preserving.

I find the blandness of the proposal insulting.
 
The problem with the argument that this should be torn down because it's in rough shape is that such an argument can be used to justify tearing down any building as long as the owner neglects it for a while. This is exactly the pattern that has been happening over and over; a developer buys an old building, lets it deteriorate, then argues that it must be torn down because it is in a deteriorated state. Usually even at that point the buildings are still financially viable. They're just not maximally profitable for developers.

I have heard the claim that Halifax is behind the times a lot but I don't think that usefully explains what is going on. Halifax is not an isolated Amazonian tribe and in fact it was once ahead of the curve in terms of heritage preservation. It is still ahead of many other North American cities in a lot of areas, just not in heritage preservation. Why? Developers profit from the status quo, they have ties to regional council or the councillors don't care, most of the bureaucrats just seem to be counting down to retirement, and the provincial government doesn't understand or care.

The good news is that it's pretty easy to make councillors care about issues. They often win their seats by only a few hundred or thousand votes.
 
The problem with the argument that this should be torn down because it's in rough shape is that such an argument can be used to justify tearing down any building as long as the owner neglects it for a while. This is exactly the pattern that has been happening over and over; a developer buys an old building, lets it deteriorate, then argues that it must be torn down because it is in a deteriorated state. Usually even at that point the buildings are still financially viable. They're just not maximally profitable for developers.

I have heard the claim that Halifax is behind the times a lot but I don't think that usefully explains what is going on. Halifax is not an isolated Amazonian tribe and in fact it was once ahead of the curve in terms of heritage preservation. It is still ahead of many other North American cities in a lot of areas, just not in heritage preservation. Why? Developers profit from the status quo, they have ties to regional council or the councillors don't care, most of the bureaucrats just seem to be counting down to retirement, and the provincial government doesn't understand or care.

The good news is that it's pretty easy to make councillors care about issues. They often win their seats by only a few hundred or thousand votes.

I actually feel like I made the wrong judgement on this one. I walked past it again this afternoon and it's a nice old building, but you're right. I wish developers had incentive from the city to preserve the old character buildings or redevelop such as the Barrington espace has, maintaining the streetscape but improving the conditions of the building.
 
So the existing building is registered heritage, correct?

Nope.

And apparently according to Waye the owner has had a demolition permit since last year. So even the new conservation district can't retroactively undo that. It's toast, unless there's a public outcry that convinces the developer.
 
Last edited:
Ah, ok. Didn't realize a non-registered property would get a "Heritage Inventory Sheet" (although it makes sense to me now)
 
The publication that shall not be named had a colour rendering of this development tonight and it looks pretty good, particularly next to South and Hollis. In the worst case I guess the new buildings won't be too bad. Up until recently, buildings like this would be torn down for essentially suburban developments.

That being said, imagine how much better the Cornwallis Park area would have been had the South Street streetscape been preserved and had the new buildings instead gone in front of the Superstore.

Another point worth considering is that the Victorian apartment unit contains something like 17 units to 42 in the new development. Only a marginal increase in density compared to developing a parking lot.
 
The publication that shall not be named had a colour rendering of this development tonight and it looks pretty good, particularly next to South and Hollis. In the worst case I guess the new buildings won't be too bad. Up until recently, buildings like this would be torn down for essentially suburban developments.

That being said, imagine how much better the Cornwallis Park area would have been had the South Street streetscape been preserved and had the new buildings instead gone in front of the Superstore.

Another point worth considering is that the Victorian apartment unit contains something like 17 units to 42 in the new development. Only a marginal increase in density compared to developing a parking lot.

It would have been difficult to preserve the row houses at the corner of Hollis after that big blaze they suffered years ago. I agree that the parking lot/superstore is a ridiculous waste of space on that corner.
 
That Superstore should've had a Residential component built into it when it was built. It would've been nice to see a tower with a Superstore at the base and underground parking instead of a huge parking lot.
 
That Superstore should've had a Residential component built into it when it was built. It would've been nice to see a tower with a Superstore at the base and underground parking instead of a huge parking lot.

I think the Heritage Trust was too busy trying to save the historic Tilden rent a car stand that was on the lot for years to be able to advocate for such things.
 


Back
Top