Kenyatta Johnson continues to prove time after time how much of an idiot he is. There is no way this will get approved in City Council. Purposely holding up a projects construction, creating construction jobs, and creating tax dollars, and more jobs upon the developments completion?
Either way I'm sure Kenney would veto this
Who cares?
If he had just proposed something reasonable with in the very permissive zoning envelope the site comes with, none of this would have been a problem.
He proposes something offensive and arouses offensive responses.
What's surprising about all this.
I don't think so. Johnson is using his councilmanic pejorative, that no councilperson is going to upend. Anyone voting against it will be seen as a traitor to a fellow colleague and, more importantly, the longstanding tradition of councilmanic pejorative. Voting against his bill would put the tradition in jeopardy and significantly diminish one of council's most powerful tools. Why would any councilperson want to do that?
There are two separate issues here. I agree with you completely that Blatstein's proposal is a pile of crap and I also hope for an outcome in which he's either required to build something good here or sells the property. But the legislation being proposed is not the way to go about doing that. This legislation sets a horrible precedent and could have a negative impact on development in Philly on the whole. This is exactly the type of thing that zoning code reform was supposed to get rid of. This legislation is essentially giving a council-member the power to completely stop a development he doesn't like. To make matters worse, this is a council-member who has a vested interest in blocking new market-rate developments in his district since that's essentially what he needs to do to maintain power.
I have hope, albeit slight, that some of the new blood on the council might push back. One of our new council members, Allan Domb, was a major developer before joining council after all.
Kenyatta Johnson continues to prove time after time how much of an idiot he is. There is no way this will get approved in City Council. Purposely holding up a projects construction, creating construction jobs, and creating tax dollars, and more jobs upon the developments completion?
Again, why would Kenny poison his relationship with council so early into his term and disrupt this longstanding council tradition? Over a (relatively) trivial development matter? While he's trying to get his soda tax passed and needs votes? Kenney witnessed first hand the toxic relationship with council that doomed Nutter. Why would he want to go down that path?
Johnson's bill will be dealt with in private. Not by a floor vote or a veto.
I'm not quite as cynical as you about this yet. It doesn't happen often, but popular backlashes can and do defeat councilmanic prerogative. The trick is that you have to get the media to make the councilman look like an idiot for introducing it, to the point where all the other councilmen look just as foolish if they allow it to go through anyway. See, councilpeople are sensitive about their image (even if not in the same way you or I might be), and they are aware that if they do enough embarrassing stuff they might eventually face a backlash in their own constituencies.I don't think so. Johnson is using his councilmanic pejorative, that no councilperson is going to upend. Anyone voting against it will be seen as a traitor to a fellow colleague and, more importantly, the longstanding tradition of councilmanic pejorative. Voting against his bill would put the tradition in jeopardy and significantly diminish one of council's most powerful tools. Why would any councilperson want to do that?
If there is a majority in support of Blatstein (and surely he has political connections), Johnson will be pressured in backroom dealings to withdraw the bill to avoid embarrassment and to keep the tradition intact.
Also, how is a one year moratorium going to resolve anything? What incentive does that give either side to compromise and move forward? And how does that help the city's finances? It's just a awful idea and another example of why city council and zoning/development must be kept far away from each other.
Can't be bothered by any of this.
Blatstein essentially wants to build a multistory garage here and need variances (rightly) to do so. Pretends he's going to build some adjacent highrises.
Gets shot down by a moronic councilman.
Who cares?
If he had just proposed something reasonable with in the very permissive zoning envelope the site comes with, none of this would have been a problem.
He proposes something offensive and arouses offensive responses.
What's surprising about all this.
I have heard from a pretty reliable source that this property is now being marketed for sale
I have heard from a pretty reliable source that this property is now being marketed for sale