(snip)
Without context these buildings could be placed anywhere in a larger city in the world and be interchangeable.
Where is this similar overuse of wood in other contexts? Were the design actually more in line with current fads, I think the response here would be generally positive.
I had had some wine and was a bit over the top. I was motivated by the derisive comments directed at those supporting the building's design. Fighting fire with fire is naturally pointless.
But seriously, we aren't all equally intelligent. That's just how it is.![]()
My opinion still stands however, that the building is a misunderstood work of art. I don't see how adding more glass is the answer when we are already inundated by that material here.
Here you go:
Would've been better to phrase it like this - it has the same effect.
Regardless, apology half-accepted. Sorry if I myself came across as hostile.
At the risk of sounding like a broken record:
A) Doesn't have to be all-glass. Stone/concrete (at least in vertical columns) or very large windows, simply to complement the oversaturation of wood, would work too.
B) If you want to think the design is a work of art, that's your choice - it's a free country, after all. But please give an actual case for why it's a work of art (or not), like most of us already have. Acting like there's a "timeless elegance" that only you can understand and mocking anybody who doesn't see it... it's a meaningless insult that doesn't add anything to your argument, and it makes you sound like a pretentious art school graduate.
The gallery is primarily for those whose appreciate art. I have already asked, do you attend the gallery on a regular basis, do you genuinely appreciate art? The tone of these criticisms often, but not always, speak of someone who does not. Well guess what, the design and the gallery itself are not for you. Should we dumb down everything just because it is a public expression? No. Some things deserve to punch through the lowest common denominator.
“It may be a bit controversial,” says a [Westbank] representative. “It’s certainly not a feel-good photo. It’s more of a turning point in history, which we’re happy with. I mean, we think it’s something to talk about, something to discuss, and that’s the idea behind art, right? ”
I disagree with this - i like art, but I also like to see it incorporated into peoples lives who normally wouldn't think of themselves as artistic. The VAG should aim high, but at the same time, not to the point of alienating (most?) people.
And remember, this is the internet...
I'd like to think of the gallery being available for everyone. IMO a VAG season pass goes a lot further than canucks seasons tickets.
![]()
A photomontage by Stan Douglas (link). Brought to you by Westbank, who IMO does exceptional work to bringing art to their projects
No. Some things cannot be fully explained, like music, like art. They do not require justification, but rather an eye, an appreciation, a discernment.
You even had to resort to using other cities. Perhaps at that point it's time to realize how wrong you really are.
The worst part is that the original commentary in support of this design referred to First Nations influences in Vancouver. This received some of that underlying racist scoffing that I love on this forum. Oh so you think you can phrase it in certain passive-aggressive way that shields you from repercussions or even a basic sense of self-awareness? Haha. Way to show your cards when it comes to who the real douchebags are.
I feel like the sections above where the glass starts, all kind of blend together. They are all clad in vertical oriented wood planks, all the same width. Even the glass sections below incorporate the same vertical wooden planks. Its too much of the same thing (in my opinion) especially with all the blank walls in the upper portion of the building.
Using wood that was a different width for some sections. Or maybe having some sections with a horizontal orientation might help? Some sort of board and baton, or reverse board and baton sections. Anything to break it up a bit.
Regardless wood is not gonna hold up well over time. I dont see this building aging well. In my opinion.
You got that right !!! (I looked up the building in Baku on Google; now that is elegant!)I'm sorry but this just looks more and more like a stack of discarded cardboard boxes that litter the alleyways of every Hollywood movie.
IMO the uniformity and the vertical lines adds to add to the gravity of the place - it seems imposing because this is a civic institution. But it also adds some incongruity - you normally wouldn't use wood/wood veneer for a large structure like this.
(I looked up the building in Baku on Google; now that is elegant!)
There are many costs and time management issues that go into this project. The biggest issue by far is the fact that it took 2.5 years of experimentation, to figure out how to install the smooth roofing panels, and have them all fit perfectly one into the other, to ensure no cracks, halls or gaps are created in the process. This left a roofing graveyard next to the construction site, which includes all the material part that will not be used in the future construction work.
.....
Despite the many unplanned costs, time and resources spent on roofing materials which won’t be used, and secrecy surrounding the cost of the project, the architectural feat of the building is one of a kind and instills inspiration in the soul.
Maybe the square wooden design is cheaper, but the Baku design is SO much more urbane, so much sleeker, so much more (I hate the words, but) ... "world class".Be careful of what you wish for...
That last part deserves a...
Curved buildings are more expensive. The more curves, the more expense.
At least with the Herzog design, I don't see a lot of unplanned costs depending on the what they ultimately decide for the wood/wood veneer components. A engineered wood skin should be low cost and durable. A re-skin (with a non-wood veneer if desired) should be relatively easy with the vertical components and could be incorporated for rotating temporary installations.