Canadian skylines of the past


Vancouver probably had the country's 2nd biggest skyline even back then!

Are you thinking that the pre-war skyline rankings went:

1. Toronto
2. Vancouver?

or

1. Montreal
2. Vancouver?

In any case, I think both Toronto and Montreal would have been much more substantial (skyline-wise, but also anything-else-wise) than Vancouver. Vancouver's skyline would have consisted of what you see in that picture plus a few 10 storey gems further east like the Sun Tower and the Dominion Building.

That said, Vancouver was definitely third place if you count skyscraper-based skylines*. Winnipeg made the pre-war LA "mistake" of building many 10-12 storey Beaux arts buildings, but few standout (by height) landmarks.

*Ottawa and Quebec City had interesting non-skyscraper skylines back then.
 
In any case, I think both Toronto and Montreal would have been much more substantial (skyline-wise, but also anything-else-wise) than Vancouver. Vancouver's skyline would have consisted of what you see in that picture plus a few 10 storey gems further east like the Sun Tower and the Dominion Building.

That said, Vancouver was definitely third place if you count skyscraper-based skylines*.

Well, if we are talking about the "pre-war" era, and if we are talking about individual commercial skyscraper heights, then the much-younger and much-smaller Vancouver was actually number one in Canada on a couple of occasions during the early 20th centrury. And by the time the pre-war era ended, Toronto and Montreal had combined to build just four commercial skyscrapers taller than what Vancouver had built.
 
Last edited:
A higher quality picture of the Central Slum via Vintage St. John's. It, with a population density 3x that of London, was bulldozed in the 1950s as the difference between the city's classes flattened upon entry into Canada. Most of these homes had no electricity, running water, or indoor toilets.

sn17jd.jpg


And back when St. John's was aware of its rivers. Picture is from the West End. The Waterford River, one of many hundreds of things in St. John's named for the city of Waterford, Ireland, from which the majority of Townies' ancestors came. These days, the rivers are all walled, many of them completely buried under parking lots and streets.

2na1u1w.jpg
 
Are you thinking that the pre-war skyline rankings went:

1. Toronto
2. Vancouver?

or

1. Montreal
2. Vancouver?

In any case, I think both Toronto and Montreal would have been much more substantial (skyline-wise, but also anything-else-wise) than Vancouver. Vancouver's skyline would have consisted of what you see in that picture plus a few 10 storey gems further east like the Sun Tower and the Dominion Building.

That said, Vancouver was definitely third place if you count skyscraper-based skylines*. Winnipeg made the pre-war LA "mistake" of building many 10-12 storey Beaux arts buildings, but few standout (by height) landmarks.

*Ottawa and Quebec City had interesting non-skyscraper skylines back then.

Surely Winnipeg was in the running at times?
 
All of our cities have wonderful old buildings. Winnipeg doesn't seem to have had as many taller buildings as some other cities but due to slow growth it also didn't witness as much devastation of it's inner city historic buildings and neighbourhoods.
 
All of our cities have wonderful old buildings. Winnipeg doesn't seem to have had as many taller buildings as some other cities but due to slow growth it also didn't witness as much devastation of it's inner city historic buildings and neighbourhoods.

It just seemed to have a lot of fairly tall historic buildings. I mean not skyscrapers, but the exchange seemed to have lots of 8-10 floor things going on.
 


Back
Top