The Metro Vancouver Retail Thread


Yeah no one was leasing brand new units for going on multiple years now, Marine Drive had to drop. It has filled in a bit lately.
 
Vancouver’s hip Main Street strip was the only other market to decline. Upper-end rents lost a mere $5 a square foot; bottom-end rents rose by an equal amount.

Lots of shitty little stores in equally shitty little old buildings in that 'hood-having someone else drive a few times in a week & thus getting a good look is really an eye opener
 
Lots of shitty little stores in equally shitty little old buildings in that 'hood-having someone else drive a few times in a week & thus getting a good look is really an eye opener

The only way indie stores can thrive is in affordable older buildings. That's why Main attracts a hipper crowd than Fourth or W. Broadway with their CRU in 4 story condo newbuilds.
 
Retail in Vancouver needs a major overhaul that's for sure. The term "hip" could be applied to something quite temporary. For Main street, the area around Kingsway/Broadway is still nicer with the combination of taller heritage buildings with character, new mid-rise condos with CRUs, and retail that spans multiple blocks. Further south along Main, the area tends to attract less foot traffic, and too long of a stretch to get there on foot from the major bus route (ie. Broadway): does not seem that convenient. Furthermore, the one-storey retail along the stretch is getting old and dull. I would certainly like to see the Mt. Pleasant area densify more with better designed condos/CRUs, and the refurbishment of Kingsgate mall into something on par with or better than Victoria's Uptown Shopping Centre.
 
I highly doubt we're going to get anything like Uptown Mall in Vancouver - there isn't the same level of opportunity here, what with so many malls already in operation. With Uptown, there was only an old Walmart with very little in terms of commercial space around it.

Kingsgate Mall will soon be redeveloped, as has been discussed here in the past.
 
I love Main Street. It's the street in Vancouver that most closely resembles those streets in Montreal where there is always something of interest while you walk along it. In a few years, Main Street from Alexander to, say, 41st, can be just one long strip of really interesting and varied stuff.

Anyways, interesting that Uptown was used as a suggested model to improve Mount Pleasant. Folks at Vibrant Victoria seem to hate Uptown. I don't quite understand their distaste for underground parking. It's been awhile since I've been to Victoria, but I liked it, esp. in comparison to the old strip mall.
 
Lots of shitty little stores in equally shitty little old buildings in that 'hood-having someone else drive a few times in a week & thus getting a good look is really an eye opener

Yes, the modern Alberta suburb strip mall model is far more exciting. Exact same buildings of 1 shoppers drug mart, 1 bank, one major food store, and 1 hair salon, is far superior to an eclectic vibrant mix of store serving a community.
 
I love Main Street. It's the street in Vancouver that most closely resembles those streets in Montreal where there is always something of interest while you walk along it. In a few years, Main Street from Alexander to, say, 41st, can be just one long strip of really interesting and varied stuff.

Anyways, interesting that Uptown was used as a suggested model to improve Mount Pleasant. Folks at Vibrant Victoria seem to hate Uptown. I don't quite understand their distaste for underground parking. It's been awhile since I've been to Victoria, but I liked it, esp. in comparison to the old strip mall.

I think most people do concede that Main Street is interesting, but acknowledging that fact does not translate to people actually wanting to go there on a regular basis. The concept of having a long stretch of shops along a single vehicular traffic-heavy street just doesn't work, unlike, say, Granville island, where many attractions are bundled into a relatively small area. Numbers do tell, as how you can see how many more of us throng the malls and supermarts (like Superstore and Costco), than going through the racks and shelves of the antique stores along Main. Think about it from a business perspective, and it doesn't take a rocket scientist to know that many of the Main street shops are not doing very well.

I like Uptown too. Even though people may voice their "distaste" about the underground parking, you should see how packed the place is. It just acts like a magnet, drawing in people to shop there. Now it is expanding, and a Wholefoods store is going to be constructed, together with perhaps a residential condo at a later stage.
 
Yes, the modern Alberta suburb strip mall model is far more exciting. Exact same buildings of 1 shoppers drug mart, 1 bank, one major food store, and 1 hair salon, is far superior to an eclectic vibrant mix of store serving a community.

Noone is talking about a suburban strip mall in the prairies. There are many other retail concepts that work better.
 
I think most people do concede that Main Street is interesting, but acknowledging that fact does not translate to people actually wanting to go there on a regular basis. The concept of having a long stretch of shops along a single vehicular traffic-heavy street just doesn't work, unlike, say, Granville island, where many attractions are bundled into a relatively small area. Numbers do tell, as how you can see how many more of us throng the malls and supermarts (like Superstore and Costco), than going through the racks and shelves of the antique stores along Main. Think about it from a business perspective, and it doesn't take a rocket scientist to know that many of the Main street shops are not doing very well.

Lol your preferences != facts.

Some people like malls, some people hate them. The sort of people that shop at Canadian SuperStore don't shop on Main street. They're entirely different markets that have no real relationship to one another.

The single data point you posted earlier of a dip in retail rents on Main doesn't change the broad trend that Mount Pleasant is a popular, successful, growing area of Vancouver. High streets like Main are the norm the world over. It's an enormously successful way to build cities.

Building another mall-like thing on the Kingsgate site would be an enormous mistake. The neighbourhood has moved in a completely different direction in terms of the sort of people that live there and their preferred lifestyle. As well the neighbourhood plan is quite explicit that big box stores are not the preferred development model.

Have you even been to Mount Pleasant? It honestly doesn't sound like you know anything about the area or people that live there.
 
There's cross-over between groups.
i.e. the No Frills on West 4th @ Pine is always busy - and it's in a traditionally villagey streetfront retail area.

And the dirty little secret about Yaletown is that residents drive out of their area to find supermarkets and big box stores (i.e. Costco) that provide the goods they need.
 
i read an article that the hipsters or that type were moving over to fraser, there are some cool shops and resataurants in the fraser/kingsway area
 
There's cross-over between groups.
i.e. the No Frills on West 4th @ Pine is always busy - and it's in a traditionally villagey streetfront retail area.

And the dirty little secret about Yaletown is that residents drive out of their area to find supermarkets and big box stores (i.e. Costco) that provide the goods they need.

Though I bet the No Frills shoppers (really just a super market size, not big box) are locals that are walking there. The distinction I was trying to draw is that the locals on Main, Fraser, Kits, etc are shopping locally, and their interest in their high streets are why they live there. They aren't getting in their cars to drive out to the Superstore or mall. There's a good chance they don't even own cars.

If that's true about Yaletown that surprises me because they have a wealth of nearby supermarkets, but demographically people who live in Yaletown are not the same as people who live in Kits, Mount Pleasant and Commercial. The fact that they vote differently is an indication that the groups aren't the same.
 
Building another mall-like thing on the Kingsgate site would be an enormous mistake. The neighbourhood has moved in a completely different direction in terms of the sort of people that live there and their preferred lifestyle. As well the neighbourhood plan is quite explicit that big box stores are not the preferred development model.

That's what I meant - that the people who live there and have that "hipster" preferred lifestyle (or the Kits lifestyle) will still shop at a supermarket
instead of the local independent grocer, farm market or butcher (a No Frills has the same atmosphere as a Superstore, just smaller).
So if Kingsgate is redeveloped, it may still be patronized by locals.
The underground parking at the 4th Ave. No Frills is also always pretty busy, so it is drawing customers from farther away, too.

It's actually pretty interesting demographically.
If the Broadway & Yukon No Frills is sold out of featured items - i.e. pork ribs - it will almost always be available at the Kits location.

In essence, the Kits customers - although shopping at the No Frills - aren't as cost conscious / frenzied as the Broadway store customers.
It could also be that meat does not sell as quickly at the Kits location compared to the Broadway store (Kits vegetarians, etc.)
The Broadway store always has big signs limiting family purchases to 2 packages / roasts per family. At Kits, the stock just sits there.

The stores are also franchised, so they carry different stocks of merchandise. (i.e. @ Kits, Quaker Harvest Crunch is perpetually on sale for $1.97, whereas it goes on and off sale at the Broadway store.) The Broadway store also has a lot of ethnic foods and a big selection of Filipino ice creams.

Some regular prices are also higher at the Kits location than the Broadway store (i.e. bananas - Broadway reg. $0.57/lb; Kits reg. $0.77/lb)

****

WRT Yaletown, people just don't like paying high prices all the time. For some basics, quick meals or treats, sure, but for the bulk of their groceries, Urban Fare, MarketPlace IGA and Choices are too expensive. Nestor's isn't quite as pricey.

The other thing is that people generally find themselves driving past a cheaper grocery store in the course of their weekly routines, so shopping elsewhere by combining trips isn't much of an issue.


Costco is within walking distance of Yaletown.

Yeah, but you need the car to carry big stuff (unless you're just buying a hot dog).

************

Construction pics of the YVR outlet mall:

mcarthurglen_221043930.jpg

Arlen Redekop / PNG
http://blogs.theprovince.com/2015/0...signer-outlet-not-your-typical-shopping-mall/

mcarthurglen_221043938.jpg

Arlen Redekop / PNG
http://blogs.theprovince.com/2015/0...signer-outlet-not-your-typical-shopping-mall/

mcarthurglen_221043932.jpg

Arlen Redekop / PNG
http://blogs.theprovince.com/2015/0...signer-outlet-not-your-typical-shopping-mall/
 
Last edited:


Back
Top