I don''t consider myself qualified to have an opinion on this specific building.
That said I wouldn't agree particularly with the rest. Not a perfect comparison but in Denver's LoDo district, the residential and office development additions are the hot places to be. These uses and others seem to have enhanced the area, not hurt it.
Currently in the demo and site prep phase of an assembled full block, the Z Block project should be great. Long story short they scraped the history on one half of the block while preserving most (but not all) the history on the other half of the block. Of course some bemoaned losing any of the history. Historical powers-that-be were mostly positive about what WAS saved.
You can see a render of the scraped side HERE and a render of how they are preserving and fitting into their project the other half HERE. The building's height would reflect the allowable limits for LoDo on the first half.
LoDo, however, has been a great success for decades, anchored by the beautifully renovated Union Station along with existing upscale usages like the Oxford Hotel, authentic lofts, numerous brewpubs, and a much pleasanter ballpark. Its bones are strong and deep. By contrast, the very modest Phoenix warehouse district is struggling to create enough interest to stay viable as a gentrification project. The dozen or so buildings that comprise it are not great by anyone's standards but the little historic cachet that downtown has is mostly here and on the nearby Luhrs' block.
I lived in Denver back in the 1970s when its downtown was fully functional. All the major department stores (May, D&F, Joslin's, Foley's) were there. 17th St. was called the Wall Street of the west although today it feels sleepy. Demographically, Denver and Phoenix are fairly similar, sunbelt cities with huge sprawl issues. The key difference is age and legacy. Denver was a major city in the 19th century when Phoenix was a small town. Denver has a great building stock that Phoenix never had. Even so, it's stunning the to look at the treasures that Denver abandoned. I bet you wish you had some of those buildings that urban renewal took out in the 1960s. Denver and Phoenix share one other commonality: a huge number of vacant parcels on the periphery of downtown. I'm guessing land speculators have both cities in their greedy grip.
Those renderings look great. The problem for Phoenix is that new development is difficult to create in an area that hasn't gentrified and renovated. To repeat, Phoenix has much weaker bones on which to construct its urban renaissance. Timing is everything. Denver came of age in a golden era while Phoenix came of age when people were running away from cities.