PITTSBURGH | Development Rundown II


Someone really needs to develop that lot, it makes that part of downtown kinda suck.

Absolutely. However, I wouldn't mind waiting a bit if it meant getting something really spectacular. Maybe not a new tallest, but at least something on the scale of the Oxford Centre or perhaps even BNY Mellon.
 
2500 Smallman coming along on the left. The offices at 3 Crossings on the right. They've been pouring the concrete floors of the office pretty much all week.

So you inspired me to take a walk through that area.

I hadn't really fully grasped what a large site The Yards was going into until I saw it in person. But I guess it is going to have a lot of green space along the river, which I am OK with.

Also a very big site--the former Ayoob location near St. Stanislaus. You could do a whole complex there.

Edit:

I'm not sure I had seen this particular rendering before of Three Crossings:

Three_Crossings.jpg


Still not a fan of the design of the office buildings and I could do without that surface lot along Railroad, but all-in-all I think that is a pretty nice project for that part of the Strip.
 
Starting to think that Three Crossings is the hideous project that we should be focusing attention on. Those buildings look fucking awful.
 
ELDI has released the second in a planned series of papers on crime reduction in East Liberty, based on the reports of a consultant they hired:

http://www.eastliberty.org/sites/de...evitalization- Crime Reduction Strategy_0.pdf

This paper suggests the reduction in crime they observed from 2008 to 2012 can be explained by a combination of three theories: "hot-spot" targeting (going after the addresses where a hugely disproportionate amount of crime occurs); "place-based management" (specifically going after those spots not just with police action, but also investment and management--in this case, ELDI ended up just buying a bunch of properties, fixing them up, and installing better management); and "collective efficacy" (basically getting the community more involved in the hope of encouraging informal social measures).

As always it is a bit difficult to be sure what caused a specific crime reduction in a specific place, but it is hard to argue with the results:

Screen%20Shot%202015-03-13%20at%207.22.45%20PM.png


And I am persuaded, at least, that ELDI's efforts likely were at least a strong contributing factor.

Just as impressive, perhaps, is the following:

It is especially noteworthy that these developments occurred in an environment where the median income stagnated and actually declined in real terms and where there was minimal change in the racial composition of the neighborhood.

To be blunt about it, there are an awful lot of people out there who will suggest some variation on the theme that the only way to significantly reduce crime rates in neighborhoods like this is to displace all the poorer black residents. If you actually get to know these neighborhoods a bit, however, it quickly becomes apparent that the vast majority of poorer black residents are if anything victims, not criminals, of the crime in these neighborhoods, and are just as interested in trying to do something about local crime as anyone, if not more so.

So it doesn't surprise me at all that if you can really efficiently target just the small percentage of people who are truly causing a crime problem, you can otherwise keep the composition of the neighborhood largely the same. But again, there are lots of people out there who will tell you that isn't possible--and yet East Liberty is in the process of proving them wrong.
 
Um--when did 350 Fifth, Oxford's proposed skyscraper for the Frank & Seder location, grow to 29 stories from 20?

http://www.oxforddevelopment.com/our-portfolio/350-fifth-avenue/

350 Fifth is a new 29-story multi-tenant office building in the heart of downtown Pittsburgh built by Oxford Development Company, which has managed the development and construction of more than $9 billion of real estate, including 5.4 million square-feet of LEED-certified construction. Designed for two signature tenants in one distinctive building, 350 Fifth features an outdoor plaza for each of the two headquarters and wide-open floor plans that allow for utilization of more than 92%, making it the most efficient high-rise in Pittsburgh. . . .

Building Highlights

29-story, 521,000 GSF office building
15,000 SF of first floor retail
$190 – 200 million Estimated Total Development Cost

Edit:

Older website (no longer linked directly from the main Oxford page it appears, but you can still link through indirectly):

http://350fifthpittsburgh.com/about/

350 Fifth is a new 20-story multi-tenant office building in the heart of downtown Pittsburgh.

And older brochure:

http://www.oxforddevelopment.com/wp-content/uploads/350-Fifth-Avenue.pdf

BUILDING HIGHLIGHTS
Twenty (20) Story - 466,520 RSF Office
Building, with 23,505 SF per Floor . . .

16,793 SF of Retail and Restaurant space

If my math is right, it looks like they may have both added some square footage and also slimmed down the design a bit. I sure hope all that is true!
 
I'm not sure I had seen this particular rendering before of Three Crossings:

Still not a fan of the design of the office buildings and I could do without that surface lot along Railroad, but all-in-all I think that is a pretty nice project for that part of the Strip.

architecture in pittsburgh is dead - it's difficult to comprehend how the quality of design in this city has sunk so low so fast
 
We should figure out how to get someone here credentialed for access to this sort of stuff during the media embargo.

when you say "We should figure out how to get someone here credentialed for access to this sort of stuff during the media embargo" does that mean the forum would benefit from having a member who has access to local statistics?
 
I do wonder why the last speck of high crime in "residential East Liberty" appears to be at Vintage Senior Services.

I hope that isn't a bunch of muggings of elderly people, which would suck.

Edit:

Here is a bigger heat map they included in the first paper in the series:



As the text points out, the Shadyside portion of the map serves as a sort of control, including because there are often higher crime rates in commercial districts within neighborhoods.

I don't know if that fully answers the question, but that area is really more commercial than residential.

Edit #2:

By the way, this set of heat maps also shows that crime rates in Garfield really aren't that bad, and in fact have gone down as well. Moreover, it is the parts of East Liberty near Garfield that have seen the biggest crime rate reductions.

So that is another reason to think maybe it is not such a bad bet to believe that Garfield is ripe for residential investment.
 
Last edited:
So you inspired me to take a walk through that area.

I hadn't really fully grasped what a large site The Yards was going into until I saw it in person.
Three_Crossings.jpg

For reference to others who aren't as aware, the buildings currently under construction in this rendering are the bottom left and top right (the entire block).

The residential area they are putting in along the river is a pretty big site. They have some block up for a bunch of the structures, but with the fencing and the lack of elevation in the surrounding area there isn't a great way to get a decent picture.
 
By the way, this set of heat maps also shows that crime rates in Garfield really aren't that bad, and in fact have gone down as well. Moreover, it is the parts of East Liberty near Garfield that have seen the biggest crime rate reductions.

So that is another reason to think maybe it is not such a bad bet to believe that Garfield is ripe for residential investment.

The segments of Garfield nearest East Liberty are now being marketed as East Liberty. This is particularly true for Margaretta Street, which is technically in Garfield (albeit unconnected to the Garfield road grid). A house sold there for $325,000 late last year, and another two are now on the market for similar values. Rippey Place, and the lower part of Columbo Street have likewise seemingly been annexed by East Liberty - at least in realtor speak. I expect this part of N Fairmount will see interest eventually too.

That said, I do think the "Garfield ripe for residential investment" comment is a bit ironic, because I think residential "investment" has in many ways set the neighborhood back. Bloomfield-Garfield corporation has basically made it a policy to fill in vacant lots with infill rental housing as cheaply as possible. This has really cut down on the number of vacant lots on and near Broad/Dearborn west of N Atlantic, but at a heavy cost, given the infill housing doesn't fit the neighborhood vernacular and is almost invariably ugly as hell. The infill houses sit far back on their plots, and take up what used to be lots which took up 2-3 historic houses, and are manifestly worse than any of the "mixed income" infill done in places like the Hill District or Manchester in the last 20 years.
 
Three_Crossings.jpg


Still not a fan of the design of the office buildings and I could do without that surface lot along Railroad, but all-in-all I think that is a pretty nice project for that part of the Strip.

Starting to think that Three Crossings is the hideous project that we should be focusing attention on. Those buildings look fucking awful.

I honestly don't get why the office buildings are so hideous.


I know; They are hideous. It's disheartening to see such prime real estate get such mediocre design.
I also hate the trend of suburban style cookie cutter hotels being built all over the city in GOOD locations: Southside Works; North Shore; Oakland. They are all so incredibly bland! They are the opposite of good architecture.

- Bland hotels
- Bland office blocks
- Bland apartments

It is an era of uninspired Henry Ford assembly line style, value engineered regurgitated architecture and it's not just happening in Pittsburgh. It seems like every city in the country is getting shat upon with this garbage.
 


Back
Top