Metro Phoenix Transit/Transportation Developments


That's the new option that may be added to the regional transportation plan. The debate we're having over the auto dealerships is an academic one because no route down East Camelback is currently planned. There is an eventual possibility that the northeast extension may head east from Central, but that could just as easily happen via Indian School given the broad scope of the study area: http://www.valleymetro.org/images/uploads/prop_reports/Northeast_Report_Card_-_January_2015.pdf

Finally! It's long overdue!!! I hope they will be approved sometime in the future. I think they will go on Central Ave to Camelback Rd East to SR-51 North and then go on 32nd St north and then go east on Cactus Rd. This will be shorter route.
 
The purpose of light rail isn't to bring "the same kind of urban experience" felt downtown to every area it reaches. It's purpose is to provide accessible transit options that connect people to the places they need to go. TOD and urban development are typical side effects of rail transit, but they shouldn't be the main driver of such decisions.

Regardless, the fact that Central Ave is lined with street-fronting parking lots is a symptom of the poor planning procedures and decisions made in the past. If we ignored every auto-centric neighborhood in the City, then light rail wouldn't exist beyond downtown Tempe and Phoenix. The point is, the Central Corridor is a key business/employment center and connecting it to downtown was absolutely the right choice. Unfortunately, the recession hit just before many planned projects were going to break ground and so the area hasn't seen the investment it would have otherwise, but having the infrastructure in place is one of the few reasons to think Midtown might be able to revive itself.

Similarly, the Biltmore area is another hub of economic activity that would be well-served by a mass transit connection to LRT. You realize Freeway would disagree with running light rail down any of McDowell, Indian School, etc., right? Anyway, I don't see a problem with any of these arterials being used whether for light rail or something like BRT, but probably prefer Camelback becoming a complete street with light rail or BRT, with streetcar serving McDowell (15th ave-16th street).

We're actually pretty close to the same opinion about this. I just feel that building LRT a block or two up to one half mile from a major street like Camelback could be more beneficial to the city as a whole as far as developing underdeveloped areas than forcing light rail down a very well developed street.
 
I like the way you think Freeway.
Honestly, Camelback or even Central from McDowelish to Camelback is probably never going to be the same kind of urban experience that downtown could be so it is not ideal to try and force that. I say this based on the fact that the majority of businesses worth visiting in the area are street fronted with large parking lots and it isn't just Camelback Colonnade or Town and Country.
If the ultimate goal is to connect the Biltmore area with Downtown/Midtown and Tempe then wouldn't a better option be Washington/Jefferson to Camelback via 24th st or similar? Other maybe even better options could be Camelback and Central goes east to 7th and then south to Highland and then ride along Highland the rest of the way to Biltmore. Or how about Central makes a eastward turn at either Indian School, Thomas, Osborn or McDowell and heads up to either 16th or 24 before making the rest of the way along Highland. I personally would love to see either a Osborn, Thomas or McDowell extension that turns north towards Biltmore.
Part of my opinion about this is based on while I feel that getting a good rail system between different parts of the valley has been great overall, the Central Corridor has not felt the same effects as downtown and thusly still feels like a car dominated part of town. It would be great to bring some of the same benefits that light rail can provide to an area that can really use it rather than a street that is already probably even better off than Central Ave was before light rail.
I'm a Phoenix native that currently resides in Gilbert so I stand to gain nothing from this, however, I would love to see Phoenix make the right transportation decisions.

Agreed. Osborn, McDowell, Thomas and Indian School could all stand to be revitalized. Those streets would be more appropriate for LRT.

It would be a travesty for the Northeast extension to not run off of Camelback. The 39 (former blue line) connects straight to a burgeoning transit center on Central and Camelback where people are already making multimodal connections.

Freeway, if you're going to only tacitly approve of light rail when it doesn't affect people who drive, you don't approve of light rail at all. ANY LRT installation will superficially make it more difficult to drive, but as it stands, that's not the case. Light rail down Central hasn't wrecked that avenue, in fact it even made it easier to drive down. We don't have abandoned freight ROW in Phoenix that we can re-appropriate towards grade-separated transit that preclude anything else than rails in the median.

And, yes, people still buy cars in Phoenix but just because we planned for massive dealerships and parking lots sixty years ago doesn't make that the ideal land use today--a functioning urban area needs to grow out of these presumptions.

Maybe it's *not* the best use of land for customers to be trying out cars in a 120 degree parking lot in Central Phoenix when we're already have denser, garage-based dealerships in Chandler where sales taxes are less. Eg, all the traditional auto dealerships in San Francisco on Van Ness Avenue are in multistoried buildings on reasonably small lots, SF is still building BRT in front of them, and yet the city still thrives.

Ultimately, this isn't freaking 1970 anymore. The best use of Phoenix's massively-wide right-of-ways is in "shared streets" where light rail, bicycles, pedestrians, and vehicles have equal opportunity. If you discount that and instead opt for the status quo where drivers enjoy unencumbered use of city streets you get the implicit stagnation of an auto-oriented central city that everyone up and down the line is trying to retrofit for the better.

It would be a travesty to existing businesses to run rail down Camelback. The problem with this city is it constantly being treated like an experiment. "Let's try this option out to see if it sticks." It normally doesn't work and ends up failing miserably. The idea to turn the Central Corridor up to Camelback into a highrise zone was a failure. The idea to tear up the organic downtown area in favor of a bunch of soulless highrises and parking lots with a bunch of dead space was a failure. The idea to plow the 10 just south of McDowell and destroy an intact neighborhood was a failure. The idea to charge for parking 7 days a week for 12+ hours a day is a failure. This idea to plow light rail down a street (Camelback) that is successful because of the auto traffic that runs down it would be a failure. Camelback does not need to be revitalized with multi-story TOD boxes built 2 feet from edge of the street. It is fine the way it is.

The businesses along the street, dealerships and small mom and pops, have functioned well on Camelback for decades. Compromising auto access on that street is ridiculous because it will negatively affect businesses. We don't need to experiment with light rail on Camelback to see if we can turn a successful major arterial in Phoenix into an arterial lined with TOD and other uses that change the profile of the street.

We don't need to chase away sales tax revenue either. Camelback needs to be left alone. This is not SF or some other urban city. This is one of the most suburban cities in the country and even trying to compare Phoenix to a city with substantial pedestrian and pedestrian traffic on top of extremely expensive land is laughable.
 
Northeast extension

I like the idea of running LR along 24th street from Wash/Jeff. This would give the Biltmore area direct access to Sky Harbor once the people mover system is complete.

I would imagine that people in the Biltmore region don't travel to DT and having direct access to the airport would be a success.

Phoenix is not a HUB and spoke city (Boston), so why build a hub and spoke rail system?
 
I like the idea of running LR along 24th street from Wash/Jeff. This would give the Biltmore area direct access to Sky Harbor once the people mover system is complete.

I would imagine that people in the Biltmore region don't travel to DT and having direct access to the airport would be a success.

Phoenix is not a HUB and spoke city (Boston), so why build a hub and spoke rail system?

Again, if we make transit decisions based on what exists now, we'll never get anywhere. You need to have a long-term vision for it to work. And, long-term, downtown will have evolved to become more of a center for employment, housing, entertainment and culture. The people living there might want to shop at Biltmore, or work in Midtown, and vice versa. Light rail works best when it connects major centers of employment and housing, which it does currently, and would continue to do so through an E-W arterial connection to Biltmore vs. 24th Street. It's far more important to provide Biltmore residents with access to daily jobs, and frequent entertainment options, than to connect them to the airport which most residents will use at most 2-3 times per year. I don't get the priority placed on airport connections to begin with; the starter line's access to the SkyTrain is more than enough of a benefit to satisfy that need. Light rail should never be used to connect 1-off destinations (which is why a WestGate line would be a disaster). As mentioned, it should be used to move residents to/from centers of housing, employment and entertainment, which Phoenix is actually ideal for.
 
Again, if we make transit decisions based on what exists now, we'll never get anywhere. You need to have a long-term vision for it to work. And, long-term, downtown will have evolved to become more of a center for employment, housing, entertainment and culture. The people living there might want to shop at Biltmore, or work in Midtown, and vice versa. Light rail works best when it connects major centers of employment and housing, which it does currently, and would continue to do so through an E-W arterial connection to Biltmore vs. 24th Street. It's far more important to provide Biltmore residents with access to daily jobs, and frequent entertainment options, than to connect them to the airport which most residents will use at most 2-3 times per year. I don't get the priority placed on airport connections to begin with; the starter line's access to the SkyTrain is more than enough of a benefit to satisfy that need. Light rail should never be used to connect 1-off destinations (which is why a WestGate line would be a disaster). As mentioned, it should be used to move residents to/from centers of housing, employment and entertainment, which Phoenix is actually ideal for.

A 24th Street line could offer a connection between Downtown and the Biltmore area that would be every bit as direct as line on Camelback. There's no reason why some trains couldn't run south along 24th Street and then turn west on Washington heading into Downtown.
 
A 24th Street line could offer a connection between Downtown and the Biltmore area that would be every bit as direct as line on Camelback. There's no reason why some trains couldn't run south along 24th Street and then turn west on Washington heading into Downtown.

Sure, but I think it's much more beneficial/makes more sense to make it to downtown via Central to connect to employment opportunities along that corridor. Uptown and Midtown would be essentially bypassed from the connection in this case. It would also take less miles of track to be added to connect to the original line.

And, just as downtown is reachable via a 24th street route, the airport is reachable via a Camelback/Indian School route.

I guess I'm not totally opposed to it. Just think an E-W connection works best. What about 44th Street? The 44th/Washington station seems appropriate as a transfer station, and 44th Street is mostly dense and would connect neighborhoods like Arcadia to the line.
 
Interesting little survey put together by the Phoenix City Council as to what transit options you find worth funding. Take a look. :) https://transitsurvey.phoenix.gov/

Interesting. I can see Northeast Phase II to Desert Ridge Marketplace & CityNorth and Mayo Clinic. I think it's great ideas! I think it is right choice for me to go to downtown Phoenix and I can catch the light rail from my house and I don't have to take on city bus anymore. Sometime I can go to D-Backs games or something like that.
 
Phoenix council to weigh $30 billion transportation plan

http://www.azcentral.com/story/news...l-weigh-billion-transportation-plan/24288773/

A Phoenix plan to nearly double a city sales tax to fund decades of transportation maintenance and improvements could go to voters as soon as August if the City Council approves it Tuesday.

The plan, proposed by the Citizens Committee on the Future of Phoenix Transportation, would span at least 30 years and cost more than $30 billion. Funding would come in part from an increased sales tax that would replace the city's current voter-approved transit tax of 0.40 percent.

There is council meetings at 2:30pm tomorrow afternoon, and hopefully they will be approved it.
 
The council voted today to refer the proposal to voters in August. The vote was 6-3 with DiCiccio, Waring, and Gates dissenting. In any case, if there were robocalls leading up to this vote, I'm sure there will be more controversy as August approaches.
 
The council voted today to refer the proposal to voters in August. The vote was 6-3 with DiCiccio, Waring, and Gates dissenting. In any case, if there were robocalls leading up to this vote, I'm sure there will be more controversy as August approaches.

DiCiccio dissented, what a shocker :no:
 
The council voted today to refer the proposal to voters in August. The vote was 6-3 with DiCiccio, Waring, and Gates dissenting. In any case, if there were robocalls leading up to this vote, I'm sure there will be more controversy as August approaches.

Wow! Is that approved? What's exactly gonna do for now? Is going to be final approved in August?
 
The council voted today to refer the proposal to voters in August. The vote was 6-3 with DiCiccio, Waring, and Gates dissenting. In any case, if there were robocalls leading up to this vote, I'm sure there will be more controversy as August approaches.

Not a Phoenix voter (Tempe resident), but I do work in Phoenix and spend a decent amount of time there. Hoping this will pass and we can see more meaningful transportation improvements.

DiCiccio dissented, what a shocker :no:

DiCiccio is a joke. Good thing he and his ilk are outnumbered.
 
DiCiccio dissented, what a shocker :no:

Well for a lot of people light rail is seen as a waste of money, theyll never use it and it will never be profitable etc etc. It makes sense that people in his representation wouldnt want transit why should thye need to pay to subsidize other peoples transport etc. etc.

Id like to explain the bennifits to them but there you have it.:shrug:
 
The council voted today to refer the proposal to voters in August. The vote was 6-3 with DiCiccio, Waring, and Gates dissenting. In any case, if there were robocalls leading up to this vote, I'm sure there will be more controversy as August approaches.

I'm slightly surprised Gates voted no, he's usually the more reasonable/intelligent of those 3.

Well for a lot of people light rail is seen as a waste of money, theyll never use it and it will never be profitable etc etc. It makes sense that people in his representation wouldnt want transit why should thye need to pay to subsidize other peoples transport etc. etc.

Id like to explain the bennifits to them but there you have it.:shrug:

And how long have people in the central city been subsidizing the 101, 51, 202, 303, I-11, etc etc etc. Turnabout is fair play.

E: Also, going back to the Camelback vs 24th St option for future LRT: Camelback makes so much more sense to me. The opportunity to redevelop the auto mile is too huge of an opportunity to pass up. Additionally, the NE extension to the PV Mall area could branch off from there around 7th St, heading through Sunnyslope and to PV via Cave Creek Rd and Cactus (also connection to Arizona Christian U. along the way).
 
Well for a lot of people light rail is seen as a waste of money, theyll never use it and it will never be profitable etc etc. It makes sense that people in his representation wouldnt want transit why should thye need to pay to subsidize other peoples transport etc. etc.

Id like to explain the bennifits to them but there you have it.:shrug:

That argument makes more sense when applied to District 2, which is represented by Jim Waring. District 2 is far northeast Phoenix. Many of the residents have Scottsdale or Cave Creek mailing addresses, some residents actually link they live in those places, and even some of those who know they live within Phoenix city limits like to pretend they're not Phoenicians.

District 6, on the other hand, is within half a mile of the current light rail line and could see light rail pass through its boundaries via a Biltmore line or the northeast extension. Of course, there are really two instances of District 6 -- the Arcadia / Biltmore portion, which is adjacent to Central Phoenix, and the Ahwatukee portion, which aligns more with Chandler and southern Tempe.
 
I'm slightly surprised Gates voted no, he's usually the more reasonable/intelligent of those 3.



And how long have people in the central city been subsidizing the 101, 51, 202, 303, I-11, etc etc etc. Turnabout is fair play.

E: Also, going back to the Camelback vs 24th St option for future LRT: Camelback makes so much more sense to me. The opportunity to redevelop the auto mile is too huge of an opportunity to pass up. Additionally, the NE extension to the PV Mall area could branch off from there around 7th St, heading through Sunnyslope and to PV via Cave Creek Rd and Cactus (also connection to Arizona Christian U. along the way).

That isnt quite the same thing very few residents of the central city have not used highways, but the far flung north and south ends of the city likely NEVER and WILL NEVER use lightrail/mass transit.

The way to win these people is to show overall ecinomic impact, development etc. that will win over the pople that are worried about the system not making money and things like that.

Dont get me wrong I think the lightrail is great I simply mean that you cant fault a guy for representing his constituants and of course you have party politics etc. etc.

Fun fact: Most people dont realize that no public transportation system makes money, most people assume that NYC Chicago, DC etc. Make a profit on their trains.
 


Back
Top