PHILADELPHIA | THE LAUREL @ 1911 Walnut | 604 FT | 48 FLOORS


Come on CMX-5.

It's never apples to apples--but the Residences at the Ritz has 270 total units, if this wins zoning approval they are looking to propose over 400 units.

This thing is going to have some serious scale.
 
What is Southern Land Co's track record like? I would think they'll see things through if they're plunking down $30-$40m for a lot.

Edit: Here's their site. I dunno. Fingers crossed.

I had written about this last week in the main development thread. They are a legit company with a track record; it's just not a great one.

This would seem to be Southern's most ambitious project to date. I perused their website (Wow - 1911 Walnut is already up there!) and their portfolio is not at all exciting (location, concept, and designs are all "blah"). It's mostly Toll Bros-esque McMansion communities, suburban town centers, and a few mid-rise projects - very little of it in cities.

On the plus side, they did develop 3601 Market; besides proving they can work in Philly, it's by FAR their tallest and most urban project to date. They're definitely a "real" builder, but their urban high rise experience is lacking. I think they can pull it off but am wary of what the design will look like. I'm praying the square is not punished with another faux historical tower. I hope that 1911's prestigious location and the scale of what they're going after is enough to justify a stellar design. Of course after seeing what Robert Stern did w/ 10 Ritt, I have a tinge of doubt.

http://southernland.com/
 
I had written about this last week in the main development thread. They are a legit company with a track record; it's just not a great one.

Yeah, 10 Rit is definitely some of Stern's worst work. But I would love to see something like 30 Park Place rise there. What a classy, timeless building. Something like that would be perfect right by the Square.

http://www.thirtyparkplace.com/the-building/

https://www.google.com/search?q=30+...tion-update-30-park-place-august.html;600;896

Or even something like 520 Park Avenue

http://ny.curbed.com/tags/520-park-avenue

I'm guessing the latter is not feasible as Philly condos will not be able to sell at a price that makes cladding in limestone as opposed to precast concrete feasible. But a building like 30 Park Place would be great there.
 
30 Park Place is classic, but I personally would like to see a modern glassy skyscraper on the square. Architectural diversity is a good thing! And the square already has many styles. And of course, we've seen what happens when builders try to replicate pre-war styles with modern (read: cheap) building techniques. It never works! I always appreciate when a builder tries to step out of the city's stodgy traditional red brick constraints.
 
30 Park Place is classic, but I personally would like to see a modern glassy skyscraper on the square. Architectural diversity is a good thing! And the square already has many styles. And of course, we've seen what happens when builders try to replicate pre-war styles with modern (read: cheap) building techniques. It never works! I always appreciate when a builder tries to step out of the city's stodgy traditional red brick constraints.

To each their own. But we don't have anything like 30 Park Place that's been built recently. Everything going up in Philly is a glass tower (or some bastardized design like 10 Rit). At the end of the day, I'll be happy whatever it is, as long it's done well.
 
To each their own. But we don't have anything like 30 Park Place that's been built recently. Everything going up in Philly is a glass tower (or some bastardized design like 10 Rit).

eTyqHuz.jpg
 
I hope one day - this last open parcel off Rittenhouse Square gets something like this - or the building to the right ------- and not :yuck: mediocrity. Only time will tell.

777x736x45-East-22nd-777x736.jpg.pagespeed.ic.PjeCkqBNt5.jpg
 
I think we're realistic looking at about 425' and 250' towers here.

Maybe 525' and 300' if they get the zoning variances to build higher. Praying for something around 625' and 400'. That would be killer.
 


Back
Top