portapetey
New member
But then they have also had many projects like the Commonwealth Games that the city chased funding on, mismanaged, and then dropped. Then there was the Bedford arena case where everybody started throwing "$40M" around (much like the $50M commuter rail fixation) with the assumption that there would be cost sharing, but then council decided to move forward anyway without funding from the province or federal government. That project effectively ended up costing about 3 times as much as what was initially presented. Washmill's another good example; what's the cost recovery on that? 9-24%?
The small town aspect is completely true too. This commuter rail proposal is considered an enormous undertaking for Halifax, but there might be $200-500M projects with a vastly better ROI. We don't really know because they are largely considered beyond the pale. Meanwhile, LRT in Kitchener is a $790M project in a city of about the same size. Vancouver is about 5x larger (actually the municipality is only ~1.5x larger and coordinating with nearby municipalities is much more challenging than what Halifax has to deal with) but tends to take on a ~$1.5B transit project every 5-10 years.
Another sad thing is that HRM projects have been in that $30-60M range for as long as I can remember. People freak out if they see $100M because it has an extra digit. However, when you account for population growth, economic growth, and inflation, a $100M project is slightly less of a burden on the city than a $60M project would have been back in 1996.
Maybe if we were to have some stronger politicians champion some reason projects the emphasis would shift away from all of the negativity driven by the media.
Another element that I often see is an enormous resentment of anything that might be perceived to benefit affluent people.
Fast water ferries from Bedford to downtown? No way! Rich Bedford people can afford cars and insurance!
Stadium? No way! If you can afford season tickets to CFL games, you can afford to fly to Montreal for that stuff!
Big library? No way! Library people drink Starbucks and if you can afford Starbucks you can afford your own damned books!
That $20 million should be spent on hospital beds! Nursing homes! (It ALWAYS comes back to hospital beds and nursing homes.) No matter that the government already spends something like 45% of its budget on health care.