Halifax Transit


But then they have also had many projects like the Commonwealth Games that the city chased funding on, mismanaged, and then dropped. Then there was the Bedford arena case where everybody started throwing "$40M" around (much like the $50M commuter rail fixation) with the assumption that there would be cost sharing, but then council decided to move forward anyway without funding from the province or federal government. That project effectively ended up costing about 3 times as much as what was initially presented. Washmill's another good example; what's the cost recovery on that? 9-24%?

The small town aspect is completely true too. This commuter rail proposal is considered an enormous undertaking for Halifax, but there might be $200-500M projects with a vastly better ROI. We don't really know because they are largely considered beyond the pale. Meanwhile, LRT in Kitchener is a $790M project in a city of about the same size. Vancouver is about 5x larger (actually the municipality is only ~1.5x larger and coordinating with nearby municipalities is much more challenging than what Halifax has to deal with) but tends to take on a ~$1.5B transit project every 5-10 years.

Another sad thing is that HRM projects have been in that $30-60M range for as long as I can remember. People freak out if they see $100M because it has an extra digit. However, when you account for population growth, economic growth, and inflation, a $100M project is slightly less of a burden on the city than a $60M project would have been back in 1996.

Maybe if we were to have some stronger politicians champion some reason projects the emphasis would shift away from all of the negativity driven by the media.

Another element that I often see is an enormous resentment of anything that might be perceived to benefit affluent people.

Fast water ferries from Bedford to downtown? No way! Rich Bedford people can afford cars and insurance!

Stadium? No way! If you can afford season tickets to CFL games, you can afford to fly to Montreal for that stuff!

Big library? No way! Library people drink Starbucks and if you can afford Starbucks you can afford your own damned books!

That $20 million should be spent on hospital beds! Nursing homes! (It ALWAYS comes back to hospital beds and nursing homes.) No matter that the government already spends something like 45% of its budget on health care.
 
This is key to what I've been struggling to convey. The map Q12 posted of "short commuting corridors" shows people coming from Wolfville and Truro. I'm not saying people don't make those commutes--I'm saying is that the city we want?

How we build a commuter rail network will effect how the city grows. Put a station out in Enfield, and suddenly people start going, "Hey, maybe I'll live Enfield not that it has that commuter train line." So the number of commuters from Enfield grows much more than it otherwise would--and those are people who would otherwise probably live closer to the city..

I think everyone on here agrees that Halifax needs to density and urbanize--so why do we want a rail system that will encourage decentralization?

By all means serve the major suburbs. That'll make it easier for people to move around to employment and other opportunities, suburb to city and in the opposite direction. But I don't see why we need to extend this thing out to every area where there are or could conceivably be commuters. It's not the city responsibility to essentially subsidize and encourage sprawl.


Totally agree. That's part of the reason I was lobbying so hard for people to recognize that the real urban/suburban concentration of 300,000 people is in Halifax-Dartmouth.Bedford-Sackville, and there isn't enough density to support rail for the other 100,000 dispersed sparsely throughout the wilds. But for some reason some people don't like when I point out this reality and think I'm trying to make Halifax "small".

If Halifax wants to develop into a denser, more walkable, more diverse, and more interesting city, it needs to continue to focus on creating self-contained neighbourhoods each with their own commercial areas, and with good, reliable, and fast transit between all such neighbourhoods.

It looks like the Young - Almon area is finally developing in that regard. Parts of Spryfield are not bad in that regard. Parts of Bedford are not bad in that regard. I'd like to see parts of both Fairmont/Fairview and Clayton Park get better in that regard - right now the residential and the commercial are still far too segregated from one another out here. Maybe the Mother House development will help improve that. The Wedgewood area is still really isolated. Larry Uteck area seems to have lots of commercial but also seems to be being built for cars. Basically, I despise residential-only "subdivision" style suburban developments, with the occasional strip mall set behind a huge parking lot, in the middle of a city.

Overall, I feel Halifax is a city that has been built in this style in too many areas, and built for cars instead of for people. I think a good reliable rail-based transit link could help with that, if it is also serviced by well-timed feeder shuttles and short, relatively straight routes that connect to the train stations. The current mess of long, meandering, slow, meandering, poorly timed, meandering bus routes is not something I ever want to bother with. I want to get on and head in a fairly straight line toward when I'm going - as a train would - not have a tour of half the bloody city.
 
Again, I think its naive to think that if we don't get a certain amount federal and provincial money for one thing, then that leaves us with that amount of money to spend on something else.

From the perspective of the municipal government, and local media, people should be looking at how we can leverage scarce tax dollars to get the best public infrastructure and quality of living possible. Funding projects that the province or federal government will kick into is one aspect that is missing, but another is that projects grow the tax base to varying degrees. There are some classic areas of investment like pro sports that tend to do almost nothing for a local economy, whereas transportation improvements can have enormous, relatively predictable payoffs.

The idea that people in Halifax should avoid wasting federal or provincial dollars makes no sense whatsoever. If the money doesn't go to Halifax it will go someplace else. Halifax is likely the only place in NS where significant numbers of people worry at all about their own municipality's impact on provincial finances, and the city has effectively zero impact on federal finances. If you don't like how much the upper levels of government spend you need to think of a way to directly impact their budgets. Cutting back on requested funding from Halifax is not an effective way of doing this.
 
From the perspective of the municipal government, and local media, people should be looking at how we can leverage scarce tax dollars to get the best public infrastructure and quality of living possible. Funding projects that the province or federal government will kick into is one aspect that is missing, but another is that projects grow the tax base to varying degrees. There are some classic areas of investment like pro sports that tend to do almost nothing for a local economy, whereas transportation improvements can have enormous, relatively predictable payoffs.

The idea that people in Halifax should avoid wasting federal or provincial dollars makes no sense whatsoever. If the money doesn't go to Halifax it will go someplace else. Halifax is likely the only place in NS where significant numbers of people worry at all about their own municipality's impact on provincial finances, and the city has effectively zero impact on federal finances. If you don't like how much the upper levels of government spend you need to think of a way to directly impact their budgets. Cutting back on requested funding from Halifax is not an effective way of doing this.

Exactly. If provincial and especially federal funding is made available to a project, take what you can get!
 
Totally agree. That's part of the reason I was lobbying so hard for people to recognize that the real urban/suburban concentration of 300,000 people is in Halifax-Dartmouth.Bedford-Sackville, and there isn't enough density to support rail for the other 100,000 dispersed sparsely throughout the wilds. But for some reason some people don't like when I point out this reality and think I'm trying to make Halifax "small".

Or accused of being anti-rural. I'd just prefer to say pro-urban, and we very much need more unabashed urban boosters in NS, who can advocate for urban issues without fearing that such advocacy will hurt people's feelings outside the city, or that every dollar the city gets must be matched elsewhere.
 
Exactly. If provincial and especially federal funding is made available to a project, take what you can get!

This province has gone broke in part for chasing federal 50-cent dollars for generations. The idea of "taking what you can get" leads to all sorts of useless projects which nevertheless require both a provincial/municipal capital contribution along with ongoing operating costs. Your POV is incredibly naive.
 
This province has gone broke in part for chasing federal 50-cent dollars for generations. The idea of "taking what you can get" leads to all sorts of useless projects which nevertheless require both a provincial/municipal capital contribution along with ongoing operating costs. Your POV is incredibly naive.


Useless to those who hate pretty much everything, sure.

I'll continue to be an advocate for city-building so that we don't all have to live in a sterile suburban wasteland with no cultural assets, thank you.
 
Last edited:
Useless to those who hate pretty much everything, sure.

I'll continue to be an advocate for city-building so that we don't all have to live in a sterile suburban wasteland with no cultural assets, thank you.

I hate foolhardy public spending on things we do not need while other needs go begging.
 
Useless to those who hate pretty much everything, sure.

I'll continue to be an advocate for city-building so that we don't all have to live in a sterile suburban wasteland with no cultural assets, thank you.

I just don't understand why we cannot have both a 'sterile suburban wasteland, for those who like that style of living and a central urban core for those who like that life style. Seems we are arguing over either or as opposed to both.
 
I just don't understand why we cannot have both a 'sterile suburban wasteland, for those who like that style of living and a central urban core for those who like that life style. Seems we are arguing over either or as opposed to both.

No, I never meant ti imply that there shouldn't be both.

But the suburbs should be in suburban territory, and too much of urban Halifax is built suburban-style (commercial and residential segregated, strip malls behind parking lots, etc. etc.) which means a heavy reliance on cars in areas where you shouldn't really need to.

In plenty of other cities, hundreds of thousands of people do just fine without cars at all. In Halifax, I would not really be interested in living in much outside of downtown without one!
 
I just don't understand why we cannot have both a 'sterile suburban wasteland, for those who like that style of living and a central urban core for those who like that life style. Seems we are arguing over either or as opposed to both.

I'm not sure why people often try to present this as a matter of equally valid competing aesthetic preferences. The differences are a lot more than aesthetic and come down to fundamental issues like energy consumption, personal mobility, and infrastructure costs. Regardless of which development pattern a person happens to "enjoy" the most, these objective differences remain.
 
I'm not sure why people often try to present this as a matter of equally valid competing aesthetic preferences. The differences are a lot more than aesthetic and come down to fundamental issues like energy consumption, personal mobility, and infrastructure costs. Regardless of which development pattern a person happens to "enjoy" the most, these objective differences remain.

It's important not to be condescending about suburban communities or imply that their residents have made the wrong choice--they've just made a sort of default choice, and if advocate of density and urbanism want to sell more people on that pattern of development, we have to be careful to be seen as criticizing development patterns, not people (or, in a tricky rhetorical balancing act, their communities, even if said communities are exactly what we find undesirable.)

But, on a forum like this, I agree there's no reason to pretend that all planning patterns are equally valid. Bluntly, we need more communities that look like the peninsula and central Dartmouth, and fewer that look like Fall River and Enfield and the like. That's my opinion and I'm sticking to it.
 
It's important not to be condescending about suburban communities or imply that their residents have made the wrong choice--they've just made a sort of default choice, and if advocate of density and urbanism want to sell more people on that pattern of development, we have to be careful to be seen as criticizing development patterns, not people (or, in a tricky rhetorical balancing act, their communities, even if said communities are exactly what we find undesirable.)

But, on a forum like this, I agree there's no reason to pretend that all planning patterns are equally valid. Bluntly, we need more communities that look like the peninsula and central Dartmouth, and fewer that look like Fall River and Enfield and the like. That's my opinion and I'm sticking to it.

I tend to like this post. I see a lot of disregard for anyone who doesn't want to live in a condo or apartment right in the city.

Some of us have pets and need space to let them run. I don't want to pack my dogs in the car each day just to take somewhere to run.

Does living downtown and having lots of amenities at my finger tips appeal to me? Of course it does. But I also like the freedom that the space I have allows.
 
Seems to me we have a lot of anti auto Nazis.

Who knew Godwin's Law would apply to a thread about commuter rail?

Nobody's anti-auto - but we're in a thread about urban public transit and how it helps make a city more accessible and walkable here. Not driving is sort of the point.

Not sure I see condescension or disregard for suburban people here either. Again, suburbs where the residential is completely segregated from the commercial are a fact of life, and they mean driving or taking public transportation, which again is what this thread is about.
 
Seems to me we have a lot of anti auto Nazis.

I have never met a right-wing planner so that is probably the wrong term. But auto-haters - well, I think they all are. It is how they are taught. The ideal is the East Germany model of having everyone concentrated in concrete towers so they can be more easily controlled. Personal freedoms like auto transportation are deemed a bad thing. Suburban property ownership just does not fit the model. It is really more an indictment of the planning schools than anything else.
 
I have never met a right-wing planner so that is probably the wrong term. But auto-haters - well, I think they all are. It is how they are taught. The ideal is the East Germany model of having everyone concentrated in concrete towers so they can be more easily controlled. Personal freedoms like auto transportation are deemed a bad thing. Suburban property ownership just does not fit the model. It is really more an indictment of the planning schools than anything else.

Uh, no. That's amusingly paranoid, though. Straight out of the Agenda 21 conspiracy nutters handbook, which tends to weirdly imply that property = FREEDOM!

It IS true that some progressive planning types are rather snooty and condescending though. I like this piece by an writer on urban issues, talking about the need for good communication, and just generally not being a jerk when advocating for density and urbanism. Choice quote:

It’s possible to forget amid all the talk about our increasingly urbanized world that not everyone lives in urban settings, or wants to, or even wants to hear about urban problems as if they were the only problems on earth. That’s not to say we shouldn’t talk about cities. But there is a way to do so without patronizing or triggering the defenses of people who don’t...“Smart growth” implies all other living patterns are stupid. “Density” sounds a lot like “sardines.” And “auto-oriented” anything can come with a whiff of condescension.
 
I have never met a right-wing planner so that is probably the wrong term. But auto-haters - well, I think they all are. It is how they are taught. The ideal is the East Germany model of having everyone concentrated in concrete towers so they can be more easily controlled. Personal freedoms like auto transportation are deemed a bad thing. Suburban property ownership just does not fit the model. It is really more an indictment of the planning schools than anything else.

LOL

I love good satire.

Keep it up!

(Extra points for second (implied) application of Godwin's(ish) Law.)
 
I have never met a right-wing planner so that is probably the wrong term. But auto-haters - well, I think they all are. It is how they are taught. The ideal is the East Germany model of having everyone concentrated in concrete towers so they can be more easily controlled. Personal freedoms like auto transportation are deemed a bad thing. Suburban property ownership just does not fit the model. It is really more an indictment of the planning schools than anything else.

I don't think auto transportation is generally regarded as a bad thing because of its association with "personal freedom" (which is debatable anyway) but more because of its effects. Two very common underlying values influencing contemporary planning are efficiency and equitability. Designing cities to facilitate car use is not equitable (because not everyone can drive) and creates massive inefficiencies in land use, which is ultimately the focus of planners.

There is also a fairly widespread (ie. global) movement to cut down on things like carbon emissions, and a realization that oil won't last forever. Planning for cars is thus often seen as unsustainable at best and in many cases, kind of irresponsible.

Most contemporary planners also aren't too keen on "concrete towers" - mixed-use midrise is the name of the game these days.
 


Back
Top