CHICAGO | St. Regis Chicago (Vista) | 1,191 FT | 101 FLOORS


being at the top of your industry rarely correlates with massive amounts of competence.

Sadly this is true but there's not being competent and then there's releasing a design for a building to the public and realizing it's almost double your budget.

It's almost as bad as the time they forgot to add an elevator to a 47 story building in Benidorm, Spain. :runaway:
 
This other rendering would be a huge disappointment. The original one at least made people oooooo and ahhh (at least it did with my friends). Throwing up some more super tall rectangles into the air is just so blah. Hopefully the materials would exude something of significance.
 
This other rendering would be a huge disappointment.
the "other rendering" i posted is not a thing.

i did a quick photoshop of the old arquitectonica proposal for this site with something approximating the general massing of the gang design for a laugh.

it was just a joke. not real in any way, shape, or form.
 
This other rendering would be a huge disappointment. The original one at least made people oooooo and ahhh (at least it did with my friends). Throwing up some more super tall rectangles into the air is just so blah. Hopefully the materials would exude something of significance.

This is why I'm not a fan of Sears......

Anyways we could have dodged a bullet maybe they will now design a nice looking, none gimmicky, building. If you're going to go with gimmick at least make it something like the Chicago.
 
Sorry Steely. Not to crush on your rendering skills. It would be a lovely proposal in and of itself, not replacing the Gang proposal. :)
 
Please refer to post #587 in this thread.

Yea it's a good thing that isn't real.

I know they won't rebuild the Waldorf Astoria but I would love to see something similar to that here. I did think this was a pretty cool design though. 1150' is a great height and it is unique looking, almost Taipei 101-ish.

Plus this site is/was our only hope for another Chi-town supertall besides Wolf Point or the spire site, neither of which are certain to pass 300m.
 
A friend who lives in LSE said there was some kind of survey crew out on the site again all week last week. Wonder how much "recalculating" is going on behind the scenes right now if they really are having such budgeting issues.
 
AFAIK, solutions involve 'shallowing' the frustums so they will allow the structure to run vertically and just cantilevering the floors rather than the structure following the envelope in and out as was priced (so, essentially the same structural solution as in Aqua), and "trying to stuff more program into the building"... not sure how you do that with hotel rooms, reducing the size of condos I can see and maybe lowering floor to floor heights... but the big 'concept', 3 frustum towers, remains

still not sure why 3 beautifully detailed, thin boxes that met the ground and their neighbors well wouldn't be better... painful to see this amount of cost-cutting so early in the design process...
 
Last edited:
^ that's because it's not your $$$ :)

the architects have to be reigned in sometimes...this will still be a killer building based on the detailing we saw...they can't go too cheap, the long term cost of maintaining it would be astronomical at that size.
 
AFAIK, solutions involve 'shallowing' the frustums so they will allow the structure to run vertically and just cantilevering the floors rather than the structure following the envelope in and out as was priced (so, essentially the same structural solution as in Aqua), and "trying to stuff more program into the building"... not sure how you do that with hotel rooms, reducing the size of condos I can see and maybe lowering floor to floor heights... but the big 'concept', 3 frustum towers, remains

still not sure why 3 beautifully detailed, thin boxes that met the ground and their neighbors will wouldn't be better... painful to see this amount of cost-cutting so early in the design process...

Responding to constraints in my experience is a positive thing for design. Not to be confused with value engineering.
 


Back
Top