CHICAGO | Highrise Projects & Construction


Status
Not open for further replies.
Great to see! All of these new highrises on the West side of the freeway are seriously challenging the WLCO height restrictions. I can see highrises pushing West quickly after the lots along Halsted are all dried up.
 
^GOOD. I'm sorry, but after the proposed Nobu hotel/restaurant had to chop their proposal in half (Totally unnecessary), in order to appease WLCO and Neighbors of the West Loop, I've decided I'm totally against these community organizations. They're a free-market cancer, and do nothing to actually enhance the neighborhoods they claim to protect. The ONLY organization that comes remotely close to doing a decent job in providing a sensible dialogue and direction for growth in a neighborhood is SOAR, and most of that is because of Gail. All others are shit, frankly.
 
I've decided I'm totally against these community organizations.
you're just coming to this decision now? where have you been since the dawn of humanity?

and yes, SOAR is the only one that actually seems to give a shit about design.

every other community group in the city only seems to scream "too tall!", "too dense!", "traffic!", "won't somebody please think of the children!", "ahhhhhhhh!!!!", regardless of what is being proposed.
 
Great to see! All of these new highrises on the West side of the freeway are seriously challenging the WLCO height restrictions. I can see highrises pushing West quickly after the lots along Halsted are all dried up.


I thought Halsted was the cut off point, so to speak, for highrises? I though WLCO held sway over everything west of that street, no? I hope I'm wrong, but if not, I hope they build a solid wall of skyscrapers 2000 feet tall down Halsted that blocks out the sun and precious views of every WLCO tick burrowed in over there. These guys are THE WORST! They crush everything, nothing above 11 stories, and yet they are ok with paying $500,000 for that crappy sign into Fulton Market that looks like it was designed in the 90's. WLCO is trash.
 
you're just coming to this decision now? where have you been since the dawn of humanity?

and yes, SOAR is the only one that actually seems to give a shit about design.

every other community group in the city only seems to scream "too tall!", "too dense!", "traffic!", "won't somebody please think of the children!", "ahhhhhhhh!!!!", regardless of what is being proposed.

Uhh heavy-handed sarcasm aside, my point was after a while, any potential benefit of the doubt becomes exhausted. Forgive me.
 
you're just coming to this decision now? where have you been since the dawn of humanity?

and yes, SOAR is the only one that actually seems to give a shit about design.

every other community group in the city only seems to scream "too tall!", "too dense!", "traffic!", "won't somebody please think of the children!", "ahhhhhhhh!!!!", regardless of what is being proposed.

I'm offended by this post.

NIMBYs are genuinely concerned about safety in their communities, particularly children. They also have a right to demand adequate parking in all new developments, especially since there is a parking crunch in Chicago right now. There isn't enough room in the city for all of these new people and their cars, and parking has to be part of the equation.

Children everywhere are choking from all this dense development. Parking is impossible to find anywhere, and it is making the city unlivable, especially for toddlers and old people. Old people and children are going to die.

Real issues. Real people. God bless our citizenry and their elected officials.
 
I thought Halsted was the cut off point, so to speak, for highrises? I though WLCO held sway over everything west of that street, no? I hope I'm wrong, but if not, I hope they build a solid wall of skyscrapers 2000 feet tall down Halsted that blocks out the sun and precious views of every WLCO tick burrowed in over there. These guys are THE WORST! They crush everything, nothing above 11 stories, and yet they are ok with paying $500,000 for that crappy sign into Fulton Market that looks like it was designed in the 90's. WLCO is trash.


As bad as WLCO is, and I make no representations that they're not still on the whole bad - this Neighbors of the West Loop outfit is positively malignant.

My theory is that as WLCO started to turn the corner ever so cautiously in certain cases and projected just the faintest glimmer of hope that they might have the potential to make more sense in certain cases, this created what the founders of NOWL saw as a building vacuum to WLCO's crazy flank, and they rapidly formed, grew and filled it. Now they need to be dealt with in addition to WLCO, where a lot of progress still remains to be made....
 
^^^ It has been my impression that WLCO has actually mellowed out somewhat compared to back in the day when they seemed to think the West Loop should consist only of warehouse loft conversions and new construction townhomes. I think there has been some splintering at the top and that some of the nuttiest have formed the West Loop Neighbors or whatever they call themselves. All the better to slap up some highrises and inject more chaos into the NIMBY politics. It's just like what is happening along Milwaukee in Logan Square with 6-8 new huge TOD developments proposed all at once. They don't know what to do with themselves because there are too many evil skyscrapers to shout down.

PS, did I mention that I saw soil test rigs on the California/Milwaukee site a week or two ago?

They're a free-market cancer, and do nothing to actually enhance the neighborhoods they claim to protect.

Not to get off topic, but free market cancer? Lol. Free market would be if the government had absolutely no power over developers to enforce this NIMBY bullshit. Groups of neighbors trying to control the property rights of plots of land they don't own is literally the exact opposite of free market. I'm not trying to turn this into an economics discussion, but referring to these fascists as "free market" just struck me as absurd. They want anything but in their neighborhood. If they were for it, then they would welcome new businesses like Nobu as their neighbors.

Now we wait for the "Randian adolescents" response from Sam in 3... 2... 1...
 
Not to get off topic, but free market cancer? Lol. Free market would be if the government had absolutely no power over developers to enforce this NIMBY bullshit. Groups of neighbors trying to control the property rights of plots of land they don't own is literally the exact opposite of free market. I'm not trying to turn this into an economics discussion, but referring to these fascists as "free market" just struck me as absurd. They want anything but in their neighborhood. If they were for it, then they would welcome new businesses like Nobu as their neighbors.

Now we wait for the "Randian adolescents" response from Sam in 3... 2... 1...

Umm, you misunderstood my point, I was trying to say that they are a cancer on the free market system. Mea culpa..
 
crying-tears-toddler-sad-baby-unhappy.jpg


But what about the children?
 
Umm, you misunderstood my point, I was trying to say that they are a cancer on the free market system. Mea culpa..

Ah, makes sense then. I will say though, as much as I disdain their mucking up of the West Loop, I also appreciate the added layering effect on the cityscape that will undoubtedly result. The West Loop will eventually become a skyscraper district, it just depends on when the lucrative contributions from developers start to outweigh the nagging of the NIMBY hordes. When that does happen, there is a going to be a really cool urban effect of a forest of 5-8 story buildings with nice tall skyscrapers interspersed, built on whatever lots remain after the NIMBY's break. I also can't complain about the effect this artificial height barrier has had on the supply of vacant land there. The demand has been spread out by the height restriction resulting in more lots wiped out more quickly, but that positive is now no longer worth it East of Racine or so as much of the open parcels in that area have been filled in and highrises are necessary to meet demand.
 
I'm offended by this post.

NIMBYs are genuinely concerned about safety in their communities, particularly children. They also have a right to demand adequate parking in all new developments, especially since there is a parking crunch in Chicago right now. There isn't enough room in the city for all of these new people and their cars, and parking has to be part of the equation.

Children everywhere are choking from all this dense development. Parking is impossible to find anywhere, and it is making the city unlivable, especially for toddlers and old people. Old people and children are going to die.

Real issues. Real people. God bless our citizenry and their elected officials.

Where is that meme showing Fry from Futurama thinking something along the lines of "Can't tell if joking ..."
 
Ah, makes sense then. I will say though, as much as I disdain their mucking up of the West Loop, I also appreciate the added layering effect on the cityscape that will undoubtedly result. The West Loop will eventually become a skyscraper district, it just depends on when the lucrative contributions from developers start to outweigh the nagging of the NIMBY hordes. When that does happen, there is a going to be a really cool urban effect of a forest of 5-8 story buildings with nice tall skyscrapers interspersed, built on whatever lots remain after the NIMBY's break. I also can't complain about the effect this artificial height barrier has had on the supply of vacant land there. The demand has been spread out by the height restriction resulting in more lots wiped out more quickly, but that positive is now no longer worth it East of Racine or so as much of the open parcels in that area have been filled in and highrises are necessary to meet demand.

^ In all seriousness here, I agree that there is a silver lining as LVDW is pointing out.

River North is full of slow slung buildings interspersed with highrises, and frankly it is much more pleasant of a place than Streeterville, with its increasingly canyonized sterility.

The West Loop, with its low slung buildings, is more likely to preserve some street level character if it develops some day into a skyscraper district. My only complaint is that ground level commercial seems limited to only a few strips, where most of the community is purely residential. In that way, River North is unique
 
Where is that meme showing Fry from Futurama thinking something along the lines of "Can't tell if joking ..."

I refuse to make it obvious whether I am being sarcastic or not based on the fact that:

I've been a forumer here for nearly 11 years, and everybody knows that I hate NIMBYs. If you don't, then you've been spending too much time away from our planet. ;)
 
Umm, you misunderstood my point, I was trying to say that they are a cancer on the free market system. Mea culpa..


I understand what you were saying originally. (and sorry, LVDW, but as I'll explain this is one of the few times it's difficult to find a good opportunitely to bash Rand and her juvenile ideas and followers) But it's actually not so much a free market question as it pertains to land development in Chicago (ie where does Chicago stand on the spectrum of classical liberalism to centrally planning primacy in real estate development). Where you would place the dot for Chicago on such a 'line' I don't know would be all that different from the US average....it would actually be, in the big picture, somewhat further liberal in the classical sense (laissez faire) than the aggreagate of the big coastal cities.

The issue is the mechanisms by which zoning change decisions are made. In other words, near-absolute aldermanic prerogative, which is by and large unique to Chicago among big cities at least, and encourages of course a kind of micro populism, ie pandering, ie rule by the mob for specific decisions. The government mechanism here is very flawed, and the system as a whole would actually benefit by moving away from this sort of mini-states' rights approach, and move toward the political left and toward a stronger central planning (yes actually having things like a meaningful planning department) function that can make individual project decisions in addition to undertake initiatives such as neighborhood upzonings, prevent arbitrary downzonings etc, create true, professional technocratic-driven growth plans and actually proactively help make them happen, etc etc, instead of having these 50 goons out there with no expertise in anything planning and development-related making decisions big and small in order to please their little fiefdoms' voters.....
 
^^^ Not having a reason to bring up Rand certainly hasn't stopped you in the past, but when the words free-market come up you have a hard time making the association? :P

Anyhow, I actually do, by in large, agree with you about the pandermanic system and pandermanic perogative. I think we could even retain much of the current zoning system and see a great improvement if we just halved or 2/5th'd the number of alderbeasties. Having significantly larger wards would heavily dilute the influence of major NIMBY groups within any particular alderman's ward causing him to give less of a shit what they think.
 
If 151 N Franklin gets built, I unfortunately do not see Wolf Point 2 starting anytime within the next 5 years. I would prefer WP 2 and 3 gets built over all other office towers so WP 1 does not stick out like a sore thumb.


Others have already pointed out, but as I've tried to get through previously (and by all appearances unsuccessfully), I'll give this stuff another go:

1) Why would anybody assume that both future WP towers will have office space I just can't understand. As I've reiterated, the development will have residential and likely hotel components in the future phase(s). And further, there is plenty of evidence from recent history that office space 'prefers' to be in its own building. At least that is what developers apparantly think, and quite possibly tenants as well. Therefore, it seems at least reasonably likely that one of the future towers will have no office space. This could quite possibly be a mixed-use residential/hotel tower. Such a tower it stands to reason would be closer to the luxury end of the market than the entry level end. It could quite possible be the south tower (the proposed tallest building) that has this mix and it could quite possibly (considering the condo market I think beginning to heat up very soon, and the hotel market by all accounts historically strong) be the next WP tower to begin development.

2) Let's assume for a moment that you were correct about tying WP to near-term office development. This is another topic I've been steadfast on: This is not a cycle in which we will see only 3 large office towers launch (that seems sort of like an implicit assumption in your post). For those investors and market observers that are counting on this kind of supply constraint, you're dreaming. I've been at 4-6 large towers (note to all econoboxes: you do not count toward this total!) and I'm still there, and even more confident than ever for a multitude of reasons. I won't get into them all here, but all of the factors I've mentioned previously are still in full effect. Perhaps most likely number is 5 large towers, but could be as high as 6, and perhaps a (relatively low) chance it might only be 4. Most likely the next one after (or who knows - perhaps an outside chance it might even be concurrent with or slightly before!) 151 N Franklin is a perennial favorite and the aforementioned's close neighbor 130 N Franlin. And then? Honestly not sure, I think at this moment it seems to at least me that the field is fairly wide open for strongets prospect after 130...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


Back
Top