The more I read about the developments going up on Roosevelt, the more I get frustrated at both sides. For the Wood Partners project on Roosevelt/3rd, I've already discussed how they could have easily modified their (currently pretty sprawling) design to end just west of the former Bodega 420. They're also the same developers of Alta Lofts (Skyline), so are capable of creating a successful URBAN project and its just inane that in an even more commercial-oriented space, they've abandoned those principles (the wrapped garage becomes a standalone building, the retail and live/work is nonexistent). If they wrapped the garage in units, that could provide the density needed to not develop the eastern edge. Together with live/work space on the ground level of Roosevelt - which has been successful and currently fully occupied at Skyline - their project would then become, IMO, more of an asset to the community than a burden despite losing Canvas and the home next door.
However, instead of building within the context of the site to begin with, the developer put forth a cheap, templated design that provides nothing to the community in return with regards to preservation or public space. And, instead of focusing on this compromise, the community is progressively taking an anti-development mentality which is not to the benefit of Roosevelt Row longterm. The latest article on Blooming Rock sums up these views. For starters, in this 'fight,' the building on 7th Avenue shouldn't even be up for discussion. Let Wood demo it and build their complex as planned there. 7th Ave will never be a ped-oriented street and it distracts attention from where it is most needed.
Next, the article talks about how lucky the area was to have been victim to the recession and not seen investment by developers during the last several years... seriously? For a blog that is based on urban principles, this is a wild statement to make. How many times has this very community cried about not having a grocery store? How many small businesses have they lamented the loss of? How can it not be clear that in order for the community to evolve and grow, housing supply is desperately needed. If the recession hadn't happened, maybe there would be quality projects on the table instead of the cheap, value-focused ones being proposed now.
Lastly, the Barron development team keeps claiming that they are open to ideas on how to save the murals and lessen the impact on the community... however, they own not only the entire plot slated for Roosevelt/3rd, but also the lot across the street on 4th and plan to built "more expensive units" there. So, you mean to tell me, with all of that real estate, you can't make the numbers work to preserve that entire building and build around it? That would give them a leasable space to earn revenue on, preserve the murals in whole, and soften the deadzone of apartments being constructed.
So much room in the gray zone for compromise... and yet, the developers are lame and the community prefers dirt lots and abandoned retail to progress.