Did you just say that Canada is more connected or identifies more closely to South America than the U.S.? Seriously?It already has one, moreso than the United States, at least.
Erm...did you really just suggest that I'm a cunt for laughing at South Americans who corner you at a party and hold forth in earnest on the topic of the proper meaning of "America"? If so, then I don't think you know the proper meaning of said c-word.No...
Two things: first, I wish I could be a cunt around people who annoy me. But I can't. It's just not in me.
Second, no... our connection with the U.S. is stronger. I just meant... O.K, let me just say what I actually think so it's clear and can't be misinterpreted: Canada isn't a "thing". It's a political arrangement. The THING is NL/Maritimes/New England, TO/Great Lakes US/Eastern Seaboard, Prairies/Prairies. B.C./Washington. We have stronger connections to the portions of America below us than we do to each other.
What they really mean by "America" is the "New World," and that's a problematic concept in itself due to its Eurocentrism. See what I just did there?
Latin Americans can blather on all they want that "America is a continent," but that doesn't make it so, and we are under no obligation to change our terminology for their benefit. They sound like miserable, small-minded cranks when they hold forth on how wrong they think we are about this.
It's a meaningless, tedious argument that nobody cares about save for them. I've heard it before, and I just laugh, shrug my shoulders and change the topic. Or order another beer.
But this notion of greater vertical affinities than horizontal ones for Canada vis-a-vis the U.S. is overblown. It's a cute notion that doesn't stand up to scrutiny. Any Canadian in Toronto is going to feel a more immediate affinity with someone in Vancouver in terms of shared culture and history than he will with someone from Detroit. In spite of how much we are influenced by the U.S., we really are oriented horizontally.
It's not that hard a concept to understand:
In the English language "America" refers to the United States, and "American" refers to a citizen of the United States.
Some other languages use "America" to mean the entire landmass from top to bottom, notably Spanish (and, I think, Portuguese). But there's a good argument to be made that that doesn't really make a lot of sense, as it is actually two continents.
Not one. Two.
What they really mean by "America" is the "New World," and that's a problematic concept in itself due to its Eurocentrism. See what I just did there?
Latin Americans can blather on all they want that "America is a continent," but that doesn't make it so, and we are under no obligation to change our terminology for their benefit. They sound like miserable, small-minded cranks when they hold forth on how wrong they think we are about this.
It's a meaningless, tedious argument that nobody cares about save for them. I've heard it before, and I just laugh, shrug my shoulders and change the topic. Or order another beer.
Thing is, I've got American friends. Seriously, I do. And while living overseas there have been times that I've avoided the Canadians at the pub and gone over and sat with the Americans.As for vertical being more... I think you're wrong. I think, if we all went out for a beer, one from each state, I sure as hell wouldn't be with the TO crowd. I'd be with the Maritimes, and New England. And we'd be having a time. And you'd be with NYC or whoever. And the west would be with each other.
I've seen it actually happen too often to believe it's not the natural reaction.
I see far more of a cultural and historical connection between Canada and Western and Northern Europe than I do with South America.
What exactly is the connection between Canada and South America? We're in the same hemisphere? We're both technically part of the same landmass? Do we even get many immigrants from South America, compared to places like east and south Asia? I don't really see the connection.
Thing is, I've got American friends. Seriously, I do. And while living overseas there have been times that I've avoided the Canadians at the pub and gone over and sat with the Americans.
I'm just talking about immediate socio-cultural affinities. They don't necessarily run that deep, and they don't mean that Canada and the U.S. are different planets the way that India and China, say, are.
You're pushing this New England and the Maritimes narrative too far. Someone from Boston is going to have a lot more in common with someone from New York than they will with someone from Halifax or St. John's at the socio-cultural affinity level. "Massholes" from Western Massachusetts are going to have virtually nothing in common with Newfoundland, but they will totally be in sync with the guys from New Jersey.
My guess is that people on the coast of Maine probably really do share a lot in common with coastal Maritimers, but you're extrapolating this too far.
That's not true at all. We've gone over this before on this board.
Ontario has very little connection to New York or Michigan, save perhaps for economically with the car industry. They feel completely different.