ScreamingViking
Ham-burgher
It’s a fact that a train is never able to leave its tracks, whereas a bus can be flexible and change routes. It’s true that, if there is an accident in a transit lane, a bus can briefly go into mixed traffic to avoid it, whereas a train will simply be waiting for it to be cleared. And, if the system operates in mixed traffic for any segment, it can be delayed by other traffic accidents or blockages, and buses have more flexibility in those cases. Anyway, I think you’re right that there is misconception about both LRT and BRT.
I’m a bit concerned when I hear people say that there’s no point to half-measures, even though I understand the sentiment. Buying a few more articulated buses to put on Main and King now; or improving the 10 to actually act more like a BRT; those are not even close to half-measures, but they would be useful things to do that would improve mobility for a lot of Hamiltonians. We shouldn’t be ruling anything out, and I include stubby little lines (actually, McMaster to Downtown is 4 kilometers, which is not such a bad place to start); BRT; some BRT “light” that operates in mixed traffic most of the way. Going for LRT is great, but I hope we don’t wind up spiting ourselves, saying “if we can’t have LRT, we don’t want anything better than what we’ve got now.”
Yes it's less flexible in some ways, but that is outweighed by increased reliability and capacity IMO. Some people don't see both sides of the argument, sometimes because they don't want to, but more often I think because they just aren't aware of them both. So I wish the city would do a better job explaining the details so that the average person has a more informed picture of the transit alternatives. Costs and benefits of each of them... operational details... how often problems like blockages occur vs. buses in general purpose lanes being affected by heavy traffic... what they mean to transit users, and what they mean for other street users... what they mean for the longer-term future of the transit system... etc.
I think too many opinions are being formed based on too little information (or on misinformation). Detractors exaggerate the negatives. Many advocates exaggerate the positives, or are not able to explain the positives in a concise enough way or in terms that people can relate to. The city should be active communicating a balanced, factual story about transit in plain language. They stopped doing that long ago.
My fear regarding partial implementation or partial measures is the risk that they will become full measures by default, because we won't end up taking the next steps or putting any "savings" from building a BRT on the B-Line into the other options that have been brought up. It's easy to say "let's invest in better transit across the whole city" but how many people really mean it?
Last edited: