There are only a few places I think a pedestrian mall would work well in Pittsburgh. Walnut Street (between S Aiken and Ivy) is one of them - it's narrow, street parking is only allowed on one side, and much (most?) of the foot traffic is from people within walking distance. Even here I'd expect to allow the cross streets of Copeland and Bellafonte through.
The problem The Strip faces isn't so much the cars, as it is a badly put-together parking structure. Since the lots cater to suburban "tourists" making a day of it, they charge all-day rates. Hence it's not a very worthwhile place to go if you live nearby and just need to stop into one or two places for 30 minutes for essentials (unless you live close enough to walk/bike).
The problem The Strip faces isn't so much the cars, as it is a badly put-together parking structure. Since the lots cater to suburban "tourists" making a day of it, they charge all-day rates. Hence it's not a very worthwhile place to go if you live nearby and just need to stop into one or two places for 30 minutes for essentials (unless you live close enough to walk/bike).