Why does this Province insist on replacing bridges when the solution really should be adding ADDITIONAL bridges?
Toll the new ones.. leave the old ones alone. Oh, and ban big trucks on the Patullo. (yes, I'm gonna beat that drum every chance I get)
Well, the seismic issue is probably the main reason why replacement is being done as opposed to building new bridges. With the forecasts of a mega earthquake to hit the Pacific coast in the next few decades, replacing outdated infrastructure is probably more prudent than adding fewer lanes on new spans and continuing to rely upon bridges that are 50+ years old.
We've been running scared under the "mega earthquake" paranoia for decades already. Sure it's going to happen.. but it could very well be after we have to replace the 'new' George Massey Bridge 80 years from now. Or it could be tomorrow, who knows and frankly who cares anymore.
I understand the costs and so on with upgrading for seismic... but you can only protect people so much. I still think getting rid of the Massey Tunnel is a waste of time (at this point). If it's for the Ports and bigger ships, then let the Ports pay for the replacement. Period.
Other than the Golden Ears (which technically replaced the ferry..but not really..), we haven't added any new bridges since the Alex Fraser. Now we have the new Hwy 17, long overdue, but it has much more potential to connect to new bridges that don't seem to be being built.
I wish they'd alleviate the problems with the Massey being jammed up, with another route. Leave the damn thing alone for now.
Well, the seismic issue is probably the main reason why replacement is being done as opposed to building new bridges. With the forecasts of a mega earthquake to hit the Pacific coast in the next few decades, replacing outdated infrastructure is probably more prudent than adding fewer lanes on new spans and continuing to rely upon bridges that are 50+ years old.
It’s too bad the http://www.gatewayprogram.bc.ca/ no longer exists, or I’d provide a link.
So do we really need to replace the tunnel and expand it?
Well if tunnel cant be removed? How are the Panamax ships going to go up the Fraser?
Or am i mistaken?
Are we really going to dredge the Fraser much deeper for the entire length from the mouth to the docks?
http://voony.wordpress.com/2012/10/05/the-george-massey-tunnel-saga/
"some rumors suggest that the presence of the tunnel is limiting the possible amount of marine traffic, due to draft restriction. The Nautical chart of the Fraser river tell another story. In fact the depth along the channel is around 11 meters, 12 meters above the Tunnel.
![]()
The nautical chart doesn’t show the tunnel location as being the shallower point of the channel, in fact opening the channel to greater draft ship could require considerable dredging of the whole channel.
Allowing ships with greater draft than allowed now could require considerable dredging of the Fraser channel, from the Stevenson jetty far end to East of the tunnel, as well as significant on going maintenance, due to constant build up of sandspit. That certainly has a non negligible ecological cost as well. The economic rational of this is pretty unclear, and we notice that around the world, ports don’t seem to develop operation inland…beside barging (option here restrained by the railway bridge at New West)… since not all ports can count on a government building road for free to them."
So do we really need to replace the tunnel and expand it?
The average weekday daily traffic volume on Highway 99 in 2012 was 84,500. This is down from the peak of 90,600, down 6.7% off the peak.
Highway 91 traffic has gone up recently, possibly due to more people diverting from the Port Mann due to the tolls, up 10% since 2008:
Though the Highway 91 Ramps at Nordel Way have dropped slightly ~ 5% from the 2003-2007 average:
The Port Mann has data available to 2011, traffic is down 10% from its 2003-2007 average. Traffic will also have been diverting to the Golden Ears bridge which opened in June 2009:
Here is a site that shows the downward trend on the tunnel traffic:
![]()
There are other ways to alleviate traffic as well:
Is it some other solutions?
At least two avenues deserve to be explored: better transit and road pricing, both working better hand in hand
Better transit
Currently, the transit modal share in the tunnel is nothing to cheer about:
Transit modal share Lions gate Bridge George Massey Tunnel
overall (all day all direction) > 20%[6] ~ 11%[7]
AM peak hr To Vancouver direction > 26%[6] ~ 19%[8]
PM peak hr leaving Vancouver direction > 28%[6] ~ 18%[8]
Sure, let's assume that instead of acknowledging that traffic is dropping everywhere, and has been doing so since before the start of the "great recession"...One could argue that if the tunnel is at capacity and truck traffic through it continues to increase mostly due to the Roberts Bank terminal that the result must be a reduction in daily volume due to the simple fact that trucks are A) some 6 times longer than a average car B) have slower acceleration and deceleration causing larger gaps in traffic flow.
To be honest, I wouldn't consider the tunnel to be at capacity. At rush hour, it's definitely at/over capacity. But besides that i've yet to see any major gridlock near the tunnel unless there's a major accident. :shrug: