Noise from Heathrow does not affect people in central London or Kensington & Chelsea. For those people, Heathrow is a much better alternative than any Thames estuary airport, and will continue to be.
My point about frequent fliers is that this is not a "one man, one vote" matter. The opinion of a person who flies 30 times per year counts for 30x as much as that of a person who only flies once a year. Essentially, I don't think there are 12 million people whose opinions are meaningful on this subject.
The noise contours from the present operations at Heathrow (the lowest contour is 55 dBA, equivalent to a noisy office) extend into Westminster and Southwark, beyond Kensington & Chelsea. Expansion of Heathrow – more specifically the North/North West options – would intensify the noise pollution that affects Kensington & Chelsea and a whole host of other London Boroughs. Kensington & Chelsea is but one of thirty two London Boroughs (and the City of London), let alone the wider regional economy.
An airport should provide a universally high quality experience regardless of the end user; perhaps that is why the New York (and US) airports perform poorly relative to their London and international counterparts.
This idea may seem somewhat off-center, but maybe the best solution is a second channel tunnel to funnel more Continential Europe traffic onto the train system and thus would free up more space at Heathrow for the ever growing African/Asian buisness.
Also, diverting some more flights to Birmingham or Bristol connected by HSR might do the trick. After all, whose to say in 40 or 50 years a Thames estuary airport won't become hemmed in by continued development?
The present Channel Tunnel to my knowledge still has plenty of capacity, so a second tunnel is unlikely for at least two decades, if not more. You then run into the issue of network constraints on the UK and continental side.
There are areas of improvement on the way however; Eurostars’ new class 374 trains which should begin operating next year will offer a higher top speed compared to the present rolling stock (199mph v 186mph) and more seats (950 v 750). Other projects such as the LGV Picardie in France could shave twenty minutes off the London-Paris journey time.
Part of the HS2 project involves the construction of a connection to HS1 thereby allowing Manchester trains to be re-routed to the continent. There are however two issues; the first is that the UK isn’t part of Schengen which would require platform areas to be secure, as is the case at St Pancras. The second is time: high speed works well compared to short-to-medium haul flights, Manchester-Paris could work (especially with the LGV Picardie), but Manchester-Frankfurt would be pushing things.
One of the problems with Heathrow’s location is that it has poor outward connectivity to the rest of the UK; the result is numerous low-capacity flights from regional cities. The Thames Estuary airport would go some way to relieving this by incorporating superior local and national transport connections which would tie into HS1 & HS2.
Whilst it would be entirely plausible that the present designs for the Thames Estuary airport would be unsatisfactory in 50 years, it is being designed to cope with up to 180mppa which would be equivalent to the current traffic of O’Hare, LAX and JFK combined. As for further expansion options, unlike Heathrow it is bordered by water on two sides (the land could be reclaimed), contaminated heavy industrial land to the south, and agricultural land to the west which is unlikely to ever be developed with the exception of airport facilities.
Even with the electrification of the Great Western Main Line and the new intercity rolling stock, Bristol airport is a long distance from London, isn’t located on a rail line (unlike most airports in the UK) and is on the wrong side of Bristol. Birmingham airport is already connected to Central London by rail (via the West Coast Main Line), with the quickest off-peak journey time of 72mins and trains every 10 minutes. As part of HS2, it is proposed that a new station would be built in close proximity to the airport and present railway station (connected by people mover) which would have a journey time of 38minutes, less than the present journey time on the Stansted Express.
The big issue why these airports won’t take major slack away from Heathrow is that whilst international in their offering, they aren’t international aviation hubs, and thus not major consideration by the main alliances. Essentially Heathrow creates its own snowball effect, consolidating its strengths and the weaknesses of other airports.
Finally caught up on some of the Route Masters episodes, up to #5 at any rate. Are there any plans to expand Victoria Coach Station, or open another Coach terminal?
They are actually looking to close and redevelop the present site. One (and the most likely) replacement option is to relocate the site to Old Oak Common. OOC at the moment is a mix of industrial lands, of which a part is currently being used for constructing the concrete tunnel portions for Crossrail (the factory will then be replaced with the primary Crossrail depot).
It is envisioned in the longer term that as part of the HS2 project, OOC will be entirely redeveloped around the future mega-interchange of HS2, Crossrail, Great Western Main Line, and London Overground services housing thousands of people. It would thus make a lot of sense to construct a coach station here as the land is cheap and the potential onward transport connections far more extensive than is presently the case. The downside is that OOC isn’t in Central London and it will take at least a decade to develop.
For some reason, the final episode (six) of ‘The Route Masters’ has yet to be broadcast by the BBC, a final airing date has yet to be announced.
My impression is that almost anyone who wants to ride the train from London to Continental Europe is already doing so. The people who are flying are those heading to faraway destinations, where train travel is dramatically slower.
Frankfurt is about as far as I would expect a Londoner to travel by rail. Any further than that, and they're gonna fly.
Eurostar currently has around 90% market share of the London-Paris and London-Brussels routes. With the new higher capacity and faster rolling stock, Eurostar announced this weekend that they will be offering direct London-Amsterdam services from 2016 taking four hours (it currently takes five hours with a change at Brussels), which would be competitive with the airlines.
Deutsche Bahn is also looking to providing a direct London-Frankfurt service (and London-Amsterdam) in 2016, with journey times from London to Cologne of 4hrs and Frankfurt of 5hrs.
You are correct that the scope beyond these areas for market share attraction becomes more limited without extensive infrastructure upgrades. That said there could be scope for the leisure sector, as is the case already with Eurostar services to the Alps for skiing holidays.