Millennium Line - Evergreen Extension | Completed


Status
Not open for further replies.
That's just because you are comparing a brand new system with an almost 30 year old one. I assure you when the Canada Line is 25+ years old it will be in even worse shape with higher decibel levels than the Expo Line.

The point is the Canada Line could have been built much better with longer platforms and a 20 minute vs the 25 minute we have now end to end travel time from Waterfront to Richmond.

I don't see how you can say that. Speed is virtually the same (Expo Line almost never exceeds 80 km/h) and the bid that offered longer platforms was $500m over budget and included a 20-block open trench! Just think, that money saved on Canada Line is the difference between the Evergreen Line being built or not built. I for one will be appalled if we ever again build a line with the gold-plating of the Millennium Line. Talk about a needless extravagance. Nice to have, but not at the cost of delaying future lines.
 
I don't see how you can say that. Speed is virtually the same (Expo Line almost never exceeds 80 km/h) and the bid that offered longer platforms was $500m over budget and included a 20-block open trench! Just think, that money saved on Canada Line is the difference between the Evergreen Line being built or not built. I for one will be appalled if we ever again build a line with the gold-plating of the Millennium Line. Talk about a needless extravagance. Nice to have, but not at the cost of delaying future lines.

That's the Bombardier bid based on the requirements set out by RAVCO. What he's referring to is the first proposal by Bombardier before its bid proposal. Bombardier has proposed to build the Canada Line as an fully integrated system with the Expo and Millennium Line, using the same ALRT technology and train dimensions (rolling stock could be shared). Platform lengths would have also been the same as the rest of the system at 80-metres. The cost came to a little over $1.8-billion. However, RAVCO rejected this integrated SkyTrain proposal as it favoured a competitive bidding process, and it also had to be fair which meant Bombardier couldn't submit the integrated approach and had to create something new and separate from the existing SkyTrain.

In contrast, the winning SNC-Lavalin bid proposal based on the separated system requirements was a little over $1.7-billion - only about $150-million short of the much more superior integrated ALRT/SkyTrain proposal from Bombardier. As you stated, Bombardier's trench proposal was most certainly inferior unlike its integrated proposal, and cost a rumoured $2.5-billion. Even so, the SNC-Lavalin proposal didn't stay at $1.7-billion...it went up to $2.05-billion with overruns.

If I remember correctly, the Millennium Line cost $1.1-billion to build. For what that money bought, it was a steal even in 2001 dollars. Architecturally unique and inspiring station designs, 20.3-kms of train track including a 1-km cut and cover tunnel, and 12 stations (VCC-Clark completed in 2006, became the 13th station).

Everything this city does is all about being merely functional, it never goes above and beyond on design (as seen with condo designs over the last few decades) nor does it seem to have the foresight to properly plan ahead for future needs and demands. For a young region and aspiring major city that lacks history, culture, art, landmarks, etc., unique looking train stations is a small part of establishing the aforementioned.
 
How was Bombardier planning on integrating the Canada Line with the rest of the network? I thought that there wasn't enough room to attach to the end of the line..
 
The only issue I have with Canada Line is the lack of super elevation for the track, which result in slow and squeaky turns.
Super elevation? No, this is a result of the bogies, which are unlike INNOVIA Metro's in that they do not share the articulated technology that prevents turning squeaking/noise on the Expo Line.
when the Canada Line is 25+ years old it will be in even worse shape with higher decibel levels than the Expo Line
Given the maintenance disadvantage of the standard electric rotary motor, I would have to agree. Once the Expo and Millennium lines eliminate the Mk I stock and proceed with an exclusive fleet of ART 200 and INNOVIA Metro 300 stock, the ball will really be rolling :tup: I do think some of the stations could definitely use a redesign, however. The fenced edges in many stations are not exactly interesting.
 
I don't see how you can say that. Speed is virtually the same (Expo Line almost never exceeds 80 km/h) and the bid that offered longer platforms was $500m over budget and included a 20-block open trench! Just think, that money saved on Canada Line is the difference between the Evergreen Line being built or not built. I for one will be appalled if we ever again build a line with the gold-plating of the Millennium Line. Talk about a needless extravagance. Nice to have, but not at the cost of delaying future lines.

Appalled if another Gold plated line got through are you kidding me? You're acting like we got ripped off. The 'Gold plated' Millenium Line cost 1.06 billion dollars including VCC, Lake City Way, the rolling stock and the failed Bombardier Centre, it was a smoking deal. The Canada Line however WAS THE BIGGEST RIP OFF in Lower Mainland transit history.

It's not just about top speed. It's about acceleration, decceleration and maintaining a higher speed through turns, something you can really feel on the SkyTrain travelling the turns from New Westminster Station to 22nd Street station. Notice how despite the turns in that stretch, the train never lets off the pedal basically barrels through those turns at full speed, something the Rotem trains couldn't even dream of as they slow to a crawl before all the measly turns on the Canada Line, how pathetic.

That's how it would have been had the 1.8bn Bombardier SkyTrain proposal gone through with a Waterfront to Richmond travel time of 20 min instead of the 25 min travel time we got. If the Canada Line was built as SkyTrain it was going be a roller coaster, full speed from Waterfront to Richmond only slowing down for stations, the trains would have been barreling through all those turns at full speed not ever slowing down which is how you get that 20 minute travel time. You know...something more...Japan like...it was going to be an incredibly satisfying ride. We truly got shafted. We paid a Gold plated price to fill up the pockets of Gordo's buddies through the P3 scam and got shafted with a slow Hyundai clunker instead of the sports car we paid for with over 2 billion dollars of cash.
 
Last edited:
So the 2.05B Canada Line is somehow a ripoff compared to a 1.6B (or more) Evergreen line?

Guys, seriously, cut the Canada Line hate. I don't get it. For me the biggest question mark is the decision to go P3. We will see how that goes long term financially for Translink.

We got an airport line, it's driverless, it's fast and comfortable, and yes, in much better shape that the Expo and M Lines, so far.
 
both of them are good deals, the millenium line even better. "Gold plated" would be the $2.7 billion going into the Spadina extension, which adds 6 palatial UNDERGROUND stations in Toronto's equivalent of Maple Ridge, just to serve only 80,000 extra passengers daily, or 3% of the ttc's daily ridership.

407_JaneSt_image.jpg
407_Platform_image.jpg
407_Interior_Bus-Ter.jpg


STW_Aerial_View_imag.jpg
STW_Bus_Terminal_ima.jpg
YU_South_Entrance_im.jpg


Sheppard-West-Station.jpg


http://www3.ttc.ca/Spadina/Stations/Highway_407_Station/index.jsp
 
Last edited:
Appalled if another Gold plated line got through are you kidding me? You're acting like we got ripped off. The 'Gold plated' Millenium Line cost 1.06 billion dollars including VCC, Lake City Way, the rolling stock and the failed Bombardier Centre, it was a smoking deal. The Canada Line however WAS THE BIGGEST RIP OFF in Lower Mainland transit history.

It's not just about top speed. It's about acceleration, decceleration and maintaining a higher speed through turns, something you can really feel on the SkyTrain travelling the turns from New Westminster Station to 22nd Street station. Notice how despite the turns in that stretch, the train never lets off the pedal basically barrels through those turns at full speed, something the Rotem trains couldn't even dream of as they slow to a crawl before all the measly turns on the Canada Line, how pathetic.

That's how it would have been had the 1.8bn Bombardier SkyTrain proposal gone through with a Waterfront to Richmond travel time of 20 min instead of the 25 min travel time we got. If the Canada Line was built as SkyTrain it was going be a roller coaster, full speed from Waterfront to Richmond only slowing down for stations, the trains would have been barreling through all those turns at full speed not ever slowing down which is how you get that 20 minute travel time. You know...something more...Japan like...it was going to be an incredibly satisfying ride. We truly got shafted. We paid a Gold plated price to fill up the pockets of Gordo's buddies through the P3 scam and got shafted with a slow Hyundai clunker instead of the sports car we paid for with over 2 billion dollars of cash.

Well said. It really does irritate me how the Canada Line train really slows down at many, many sections. There are only two sections it "barrels down" like SkyTrain - the section between 49th and Marine, and King Ed and Broadway. The worst section has to be the area around the future 33rd Avenue Station, what modern train line slows down and sounds like that: is this the old New York subway? The Chicago EL? To be fair though, I do feel sometimes that the trains could go faster at certain sections but may be restricted by the limited rolling stock in order to keep up with a schedule. For instance, slowing down to a crawl at every track switch....whereas the Expo/Millennium Line just flies over them.....it looks like they're trying to save on maintenance costs of those track switches.

They Hyundai trains were ultra cheap. SNC-Lavalin probably asked for the cheapest vehicles, with absolutely no consideration on design. Afterall, there was little required from them on vehicle design, as stated in their P3 contract. For a modern train, it has some of the worst interiors ever...and for that matter, exterior as well.

Either way, this was RAVCO's fault (and RAVCO was part of Translink). For whatever reason, the stated minimum design requirement for bids was 25-minutes from terminus to terminus and a capacity of just 15,000 pphpd.
 
both of them are good deals, the millenium line even better. "Gold plated" would be the $2.7 billion going into the Spadina extension, which adds 6 palatial UNDERGROUND stations in Toronto's equivalent of Maple Ridge, just to serve only 80,000 extra passengers daily, or 3% of the ttc's daily ridership.

http://www3.ttc.ca/Spadina/Stations/Highway_407_Station/index.jsp

Holy crap...those are gorgeous. But I disagree, the Canada Line was not a good deal.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
We got an airport line, it's driverless, it's fast and comfortable, and yes, in much better shape that the Expo and M Lines, so far.

Well that isn't exactly fair......the Canada Line is only 3 years old, whereas most of the Expo is now closing in on 3 decades and the Millennium is now over a decade old.

It's true that the P3 contract makes the Canada Line cleaner, it forces ProTransBC to actually give a care about proper cleaning of the trains. I seldom ever see cleaners/garbage pickers on SkyTrain, unlike the Canada Line.
 
Oh for crying out loud!!! Why did this thread descend into another Canada Line thread. I can understand including it in the context of SNC Lavalin, but now we're talking about all these details that was discussed to death already? Sheesh!

And mr.x, I don't remember you opposing any aspect of Canada Line when it was in the drawing board, or before it was underconstruction anyway. Its build at all cost mentality, let the Evergreen and all who oppose it be damned! I'm just happy that SNC Lavalin, not Bombardier, got it, and they are using Hyundai Rotem trains, the same trains that they use for Manila's LRT2, which I am familiar and impressed with.

Can we please stay on topic! I understand why finalcoolmen wants Evergreen to be like the Millenium Line, and the end result why its so expensive today was solely because it was delayed at the first place. But I do agree with others that say that I'd rather have a simple system that actually gets built, rather than a fancy system that never gets built.
 
all I know is that I am happy to have the Canada line, especially when looking at the majority of systems being built in other North American cities. For example, I would put the Canada Line ahead of the Portland max, the Seattle LRT, the Phoenix LRT, even the C-Train any day.

I ride it every day and have no real problems with it. Is it perfect? No. Is it worth worrying about / ragging on? No.

I also like the Rotem Cars. Anyone who is over 6 feet tall prefers the Canada Line cars over the E/M line cars ;)

Also, 99% of the comments I hear from tourists / out of towners about the Canada Line arriving from YVR are positive.

Sometimes I think we have been spoilt here in Vancouver regarding our rapid transit system. We should consider ourselves lucky the Canada Line was not built as an at grade LRT, as once planned...
 
So the 2.05B Canada Line is somehow a ripoff compared to a 1.6B (or more) Evergreen line?

I thought the Evergreen Line is 1.4B? (1.5B if you have to include the bus loop, Commercial-Broadway, and other wayfinding improvements)

Both of them are a steal compared to what they're building in other cities in Canada. Calgary's 8km West LRT is close to 1.5B now. Toronto's Eglinton-Scarborough Crosstown is ~6B for 19 'new' km (plus 6km of reconstruction). Ottawa's LRT is 2.1B for 12.5 km and outside downtown core the train will use existing transitway. Both Calgary and Toronto's system are not even fully grade separated. How does Evergreen Line even considered rip-off compared to these three?
 
I thought the Evergreen Line is 1.4B? (1.5B if you have to include the bus loop, Commercial-Broadway, and other wayfinding improvements)

Both of them are a steal compared to what they're building in other cities in Canada. Calgary's 8km West LRT is close to 1.5B now. Toronto's Eglinton-Scarborough Crosstown is ~6B for 19 'new' km (plus 6km of reconstruction). Ottawa's LRT is 2.1B for 12.5 km and outside downtown core the train will use existing transitway. Both Calgary and Toronto's system are not even fully grade separated. How does Evergreen Line even considered rip-off compared to these three?

To be fair, much of the cost of the Calgary West Extension is property acquisition. I remember when I was in Calgary and the forumers showed me where that West extension would go too. I was puzzled since there was so many things that were already built and on its way. These weren't exactly little properties too, some were big commercial establishments, irrc. I even had my doubts, but they pointed out, its all going to give way for the train, and that is what we've seen. I can't comment on the other lines since I know little of it.

Though there are many properties acquired for Evergreen, its still miniscule compared to the Calgary LRT West extension. I guess one big advantage of Evergreen is a large part of it goes in the middle of a street, or in CP Rail ROWs. A few houses, some building modification, road widening and track relocation, and there ya go. Looking at the contracts already tendered for the "Early Works", it sure didn't cost them that much...
 
They Hyundai trains were ultra cheap. SNC-Lavalin probably asked for the cheapest vehicles, with absolutely no consideration on design. Afterall, there was little required from them on vehicle design, as stated in their P3 contract. For a modern train, it has some of the worst interiors ever...and for that matter, exterior as well.

Either way, this was RAVCO's fault (and RAVCO was part of Translink). For whatever reason, the stated minimum design requirement for bids was 25-minutes from terminus to terminus and a capacity of just 15,000 pphpd.
Yes they were. If I'm not mistaken at $1.5 million a train car ($3 million for consist) I can see why the choice for Hyundai Rotem rolling stock (over other options) was taken.

That's how it would have been had the 1.8bn Bombardier SkyTrain proposal gone through with a Waterfront to Richmond travel time of 20 min instead of the 25 min travel time we got. If the Canada Line was built as SkyTrain it was going be a roller coaster, full speed from Waterfront to Richmond only slowing down for stations, the trains would have been barreling through all those turns at full speed not ever slowing down which is how you get that 20 minute travel time. You know...something more...Japan like...it was going to be an incredibly satisfying ride. We truly got shafted. We paid a Gold plated price to fill up the pockets of Gordo's buddies through the P3 scam and got shafted with a slow Hyundai clunker instead of the sports car we paid for with over 2 billion dollars of cash.
And yet the Canada Line is still the fastest option from Richmond and south into Downtown Vancouver, travel-time wise - and the most reliable option. I don't think the 5 minutes would have been an issue in the selection process. Canada Line wasn't a rip-off; it was right on the dot. Given that the end ~$2 billion cost included more than 9km of cut-and-cover as well as expensive bored tunnel.

What I don't understand is why it is thought that a Bombardier ART/INNOVIA Metro specific proposal would have been thought as more expensive. LIM infrastructure allows for smaller radius bored tunnels and lower height cut-and-cover tunnels, which would have actually resulted in a sizable cost savings. I have a feeling it was outbalanced by some other specifics (perhaps cost-modifying specifics in themself like platform length or alignment specifics like an open trench) in whatever proposal were to involve ART.
 
Last edited:
I was critical to Canada Line plans when the first plans for a short 40-metre platform for Bridgeport Station were revealed during a public consultation.


Yes they were. If I'm not mistaken at $1.5 million a train I can see why the choice for Hyundai Rotem rolling stock (over other options) was taken.

And yet the Canada Line is still the fastest option from Richmond and south into Downtown Vancouver, travel-time wise - and the most reliable option. I don't think the 5 minutes would have been an issue in the selection process. Canada Line wasn't a rip-off; it was right on the dot.

If memory is intact, it was $1.5-million per car....so $3-million per 2-car train. Pretty cheap...I think a single Mark II car from Bombardier cost $3-million, at least the latest orders before the Olympics for Mark 2.5 were.

A 5-minute travel time reduction is actually pretty significant, at least in my opinion. That's a 20% decrease over the original 25-mins, which makes it all that much more competitive against the car.


Anyway....

Speaking of train orders, how many new Bombardier trains are being purchased for the Evergreen Line? I understand that they are not part of the $1.4-billion price tag. I'm a bit surprised that they're starting off with a 3-minute frequency for the Evergreen, that's really good. But I wonder with what train lengths, the two-car or four-car?

And with Lougheed Station, what concerns me is the roof design for the third platform. According to renderings, it seems like they won't be making any attempt to complete the original architectural design of the Lougheed station roof....they seem pretty content to let it clash like an eyesore.
 
Well said. It really does irritate me how the Canada Line train really slows down at many, many sections. There are only two sections it "barrels down" like SkyTrain - the section between 49th and Marine, and King Ed and Broadway. The worst section has to be the area around the future 33rd Avenue Station, what modern train line slows down and sounds like that: is this the old New York subway? The Chicago EL? To be fair though, I do feel sometimes that the trains could go faster at certain sections but may be restricted by the limited rolling stock in order to keep up with a schedule. For instance, slowing down to a crawl at every track switch....whereas the Expo/Millennium Line just flies over them.....it looks like they're trying to save on maintenance costs of those track switches.

They Hyundai trains were ultra cheap. SNC-Lavalin probably asked for the cheapest vehicles, with absolutely no consideration on design. Afterall, there was little required from them on vehicle design, as stated in their P3 contract. For a modern train, it has some of the worst interiors ever...and for that matter, exterior as well.

Either way, this was RAVCO's fault (and RAVCO was part of Translink). For whatever reason, the stated minimum design requirement for bids was 25-minutes from terminus to terminus and a capacity of just 15,000 pphpd.

I have actually heard that the Canada Line is artificially made slow in many sections so it is able to retain its 25 minute to downtown mandate when the 3 unbuilt stations are added to the journey.
 
Speaking of train orders, how many new Bombardier trains are being purchased for the Evergreen Line? I understand that they are not part of the $1.4-billion price tag. I'm a bit surprised that they're starting off with a 3-minute frequency for the Evergreen, that's really good. But I wonder with what train lengths, the two-car or four-car?

And with Lougheed Station, what concerns me is the roof design for the third platform. According to renderings, it seems like they won't be making any attempt to complete the original architectural design of the Lougheed station roof....they seem pretty content to let it clash like an eyesore.
28 with options for another 28. There was a PDF on the TransLink website outlining the order but I have lost the source (trying to pinpoint...)
 
And with Lougheed Station, what concerns me is the roof design for the third platform. According to renderings, it seems like they won't be making any attempt to complete the original architectural design of the Lougheed station roof....they seem pretty content to let it clash like an eyesore.

The original firm which designed Lougheed Station was part of the EL Group bid. If EL won we would have had the Lougheed third platform built with the original envisioned design with the station completed the way it was designed to be completed :(

4021-1.jpg

4021-2.jpg
 
Status
Not open for further replies.


Back
Top