q12
Active member
So the paper today say 10,000 permanent, 10,000 temp.
http://thechronicleherald.ca/Front/1268042.html
Nothing has been decided yet. The paper should have used the words "could have".
So the paper today say 10,000 permanent, 10,000 temp.
http://thechronicleherald.ca/Front/1268042.html
I've been living in Toronto the last 10 years and football people here seem to feel the same way. We want a 10th team after Ottawa, and we want it in Halifax. Halifax is not too small. Lets not forget that Edmonton built Commonwealth Stadium in 1978 when they had about 480,000 people.
I find it astonishing that Haligonians are debating whether to build a 10,000 seater expandable to 20,000. There are high schools in the States that have stadiums bigger than that. Halifax needs to stop viewing itself as some puny little outpost on the Atlantic. There are 400,000 people in metro and another 1.4 million people in the region.
28,000 should be the capacity sought. Build it right the first time; you don't want another Moncton Stadium. Moncton did a great job for such a little city, but all their stadium shows is that they're not quite there yet.
We do have a shortage of sports infrastructure in a number of areas, but the question is do we need a 10,000+ stadium to address that? I don't think many amateur events require that level of infrastructure and we could build a lot more for the same cost. In fact, investing the money from a stadium in smaller atheletic facilities would actually do a lot more for our health problems then building one big stadium (no one gets fit while eating hotdogs and drinking beer in the stands watching semi-professionals play). I'm interested to know how many uses are anticipated that will actually require significant spectator seating. I think there were some rough estimates in the the Phase 1 and if memory serves it wasn't all that many events/days.
The more I hear about the case for a stadium, the more I find myself troubled. Building this to get FIFA is fine, but then what? If it's outside the Downtown the univeristies have said they won't use it so then what's left? A handful of concerts, a few regional championships and the odd larger event that we can attract. It would be great to have a CFL team, but the reality is we're still too small a market to support one. With Halifax's relatively large corporate base, we're well setup to grab one in the future (much better than Moncton in fact), but with just under 400,000 people I just don't see the current market being large enough to sustain professional football.
For this to be realistic, I think HRM needs partners onside, specifically the universities since they are really the only dependable tenant, the business community and support from upper level governments. Hopefully, we can identify some sustained uses for beyond FIFA. If we can't meet those criteria, that $60-$100 million or whatever it ends up costing might be better spent elsewhere. The convention centre feels like a much safer bet to me at this point, but I'll wait to see the final results.
Back from the session....not sure how I feel about it all.
I dont really like the musical chair idea, just seemed childish to me....but did appreciate the opportunity to input ideas even though it was via the dummy post-it note on a board thingy again.
There were a few not gonna go so we dont need it people there, and lots of who is gonna pay people.....
The committee did not take questions nor did the architects....would have been good to get some info on what they uncovered so far....sites, costs, etc
The naysayers say there are more important issues like jobs and economy etc.
I might add that having entertainment options is intimately tied to jobs and the economy. Companies/entrepreneurs look at these things when deciding where to locate as they're a powerful draw when recruiting top talent. A CFL team and stadium aren't enough by themselves, but they're important pieces in the puzzle. Many young talented people leave because they're fed up waiting. Life's too short; graduates will leave for other cities that offer sports, theatre, amusement parks, great shopping, etc.
Those that only see a sports stadium are blind.
I guess its one of those things!!!!
I thinks its very important and often missed point that this Stadium (should it go up) is to be for the future not the present. Someone used the word "grow into it" like when you were a kid and your Mom bought you new clothes for school a size bigger.....makes sense now doesn't it.
10 + 10 makes sense for the present opportunity and maybe that is a funding request "ask" situation but......the reality seems to be so far off that mark!
The general public...whoever that is....is not informed enough to add very much to these sessions....REALLY. There needs to be some teaching done by the committee that has been studying the STADIUM. At the very least the committee to share what it has already learned itself. HRM has limitations....and some advantages too....those need to be publicly discussed. The public needs to be brought up to date and then can wade into the sessions with support or critical comments.
I heard one comment from a person that said hey they only sold 11,000 seats for the CFL exhibition game afew years ago....what makes HRM think it can fill a 20,000 seat stadium.....duh! they had a sell out! if they had more seating they would have sold them...! Then the "if its in Dartmouth I'm never gonna go" people COME ON!!!! This is not a Hal-Dart thingy at all.....this should be supported as an
ATLANTIC STADIUM !!!!
Can you tell I'm starting to RANT now?
Certainly there are games at play here in the funding issues......
DD said "no" then he said "not right now".....
Petey said sure we will be there.......when HRM is there..provided its not for "PRO" sport.
HRM has said lets first build a business case.....
CFL says they'd love to expand to become a coast to coast league.....but who would be the owner to build anew team or to bring an existing one? There is no Stadium big enough to sell enough tickets......
UNLESS TAX DOLLARS DO IT WHO IS GOING TO BUILD IT ?
Private developer???? Interesting scenario....
SAy.... just saying.....
That HRM gives...gifts...a developer a large portion of land say like the top of Burnside.....on the proviso that they build an ATLANTIC STADIUM! and they get free range on the rest of the parcel of land....to build.... office, parking, restaurants, hotels, .....they also get to manage the site....lease the Stadium, sell advertizing....lease concessions....all that stuff.....
AND..... no other competing "new" development get approval for ten years within a 5 km distance of the STADIUM~!!!! Not a monopoly but a protection of their investment
Do you think any developer has already been tossing that around?????
ATLANTIC STADIUM ~ Atlantic Storm ~ Ride the Wave!