Opinion: Corrupt Chinese officials flee with $120 billion, says report
By JONATHAN MANTHORPE, Vancouver Sun June 26, 2011
Read more:
http://www.vancouversun.com/busines...+says+report/5009270/story.html#ixzz1QTIekxSX
Estimates by China’s central bank that up to 18,000 corrupt officials have fled overseas with over $120 billion in stolen money in the last few years are undoubtedly well short of the truth.
The 68-page report by the People’s Bank of China, dated 2008 and marked “confidential,” was mistakenly posted on the bank’s website a week ago and has since been removed.
But the analysis which cites specific examples of how corrupt officials and Communist party members have, since the mid 1990s channelled their ill-gotten gains into countries like Canada, the United States and Australia in return for resident status or citizenship, has caused uproar among Chinese netizens.
There are reports of at least eight new websites coming on line in China last week to provide forums for people wanting to express their anger at this and all other petty corruption that dogs the daily lives of Chinese people.
The authors of the report recognized the inflammatory nature of their analysis, especially as the Communist party prepares to select next year the fifth generation of leaders since its 1949 seizing of power.
Corruption, says the report, “is a direct threat to the clean politics structure of the Communist party and harms the foundations of its power.”
The report says that for high-ranking party or government officials the U.S. is the favourite destination with Canada second and Australia third.
Lower-ranking officials without the same resources head for Thailand, Malaysia, Mongolia or Russia.
In many cases the stolen money is taken out through Hong Kong, where financial institutions have a long history and great expertise in moving money around the world out of sight of officialdom.
An earlier report from 2007 by the Chinese Academy of Social Science, the government’s main in-house think-tank, tabulated the number of fleeing corrupt officials by province. Guangdong, just over the border from Hong Kong, was well ahead of second place Fuchien on the southern coast opposite Taiwan.
The central bank’s report gives some specific examples of how corrupt officials operate.
It cites the case of a top politician, Cheng Kejie, who arranged for his mistress to live in Hong Kong and then transferred money to her.
In another case, Ministry of Finance official Xu Fangming simply placed large amounts of money in the bank account of his son studying abroad.
While there are examples of some officials leaving China with suitcases full of cash, laundering their loot through the casinos of Macau, or even using their credit cards to buy assets while abroad and then paying off the debts at home, most of the methods of money movement are far more sophisticated.
Most are disguised as business transactions between the enterprises run by officials in China and companies overseas. But often these overseas companies are fakes, set up by officials for the purposes of stealing and laundering money.
Another favourite scheme is not to repatriate profits made in overseas transactions and to sideline them into the personal foreign accounts of corrupt officials.
A 1999 report by the China Reform Foundation’s National Economic Institute estimated that about 52 per cent of customs declarations were falsified so as to mask the retention of stolen money in overseas accounts.
The same report produced figures on capital flight which suggest the latest estimate by the central bank of $123 billion between the mid-1990s and 2008 is well shy of the truth.
The National Economic Institute report reckoned that in 1998 alone $48 billion was slipped out of the country.
The report, by the institute’s director and noted economist Fan Gang, said that the technique of over-reporting imports and under-reporting exports was responsible alone for up to $20 billion a year in capital flight.
This raises the question why China’s wealthiest people and the country’s incipient middle class want to get their assets abroad and usually acquire another citizenship at the same time.
One is that there is no legal protection for private property in China, even for the best connected corrupt party cadres.
And the increased numbers in recent years in which wealthy Chinese are moving money abroad and getting second citizenships suggests a lack of faith in the strength of the country’s economy, or the future of the Communist party, or both.
Read more:
http://www.vancouversun.com/busines...+says+report/5009270/story.html#ixzz1QTHtFNud