Time to update my opinion. Not a fan of the reservations at all. I've tried to get a spot at Dalhousie station a few times now, each time progressively earlier. I've yet to be able to get a spot. So, basically unless I can get to the lot before 7:30 or so (I'm assuming, having never actually succeeded yet), I'm out of luck... meanwhile the vast majority of the reserved spots are empty, at that point. I'd honestly rather just pay the three bucks. Sure, I could triple my commute time and take a bus to the station... or I could just hop in my car and get to the university way faster. The situation is still salvageable, though, I think. I'm hoping they'll make running adjustments to the size of the reserved sections in these lots.
Calgary Transit will be making adjustments to the size of Reserved parking area, however not ti your liking.
For May 2011:
- Crowfoot reserved parking has over 130 additional parkers signed up. They will likely be openning up another parking lot to reserved parking for May 1.
- Dalhousie parking has increased by over 40 spots. Look for another row of parking to go into reserved parking status.
- I have no information on the other PnR lots.
PnR is not really designed for the occaisional transit user such as yourself. It is really intended for the 4-5 days per week parker that also has a Monthly transit pass. In order to be able to provide PnR to the occaisional user, it would require significant under utilized parking space. Lots would be required to excced the demand of the regular PnR users by about 120% to 150% to handle the additional traffic from occaisional use.
Additionally, the itinerant parker should pay a hefty premium to cover the over build-out of the PnR lots. This methodology is most apparent in the airfare pricing models used by major airlines. If you are a frequent user, there is a ticket pack available. Infrequent, last minute flyers pay a signficant premium to have the service on demand.