Helladog
Unregistered Loser
Nuke decision 'very close'
Energy Minister Jack Keir expects to seek approval for two additonal nuclear reactors at Point Lepreau early in New Year
Rob Linke and
Christine Morris
Telegraph-Journal
OTTAWA - Energy Minister Jack Keir hopes to ask Canada's nuclear regulatory agency early in the new year to approve not one but two new nuclear reactors at Point Lepreau.
The reactors would be built and financed by the federal Crown corporation Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd. and its private-sector partners, which include global engineering firms such as SNC-Lavalin and Hitachi Nuclear.
The consortium - known as Team Candu - has been gradually lining up investors.
"I've met with many of the investors and they're very excited to move forward," said Keir. "I think we're very close."
Keir has said applying for a licence is tantamount to the private sector and the provincial government deciding to go ahead with the megaproject.
Building even one reactor could cost an estimated $4- to $5-billion and employ several thousand construction workers.
Together with a proposed second Irving Oil refinery, Lepreau would anchor an energy-based cluster the Graham government hopes would transform the province's economy.
Getting Lepreau 2's design, safety and environmental approvals from the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission and other agencies would likely take two or three years.
Deciding to go ahead with a second reactor at this point would be a surprise in at least one regard.
Some observers expected the Graham government to see if AECL could first prove it could complete the $1.4-billion refurbishment of NB Power's existing reactor at Lepreau on time and on budget.
That Candu 6 reactor, brought online in 1983, is the first in the world to undergo a total refurbishment.
AECL, the main contractor, stands to benefit if it can demonstrate costly nuclear plants can undergo smooth midlife overhauls that extend their useful service by another 25 years.
The 18-month project has a completion deadline of Sept. 30, 2009.
But this fall, AECL has had trouble with automated tooling, causing delays that have eaten up all the leeway in the schedule.
Unless engineers find ways to save time with the remaining work, the project will not meet its 18-month deadline.
NB Power expects to know sometime in January if the refurbishment can still be done on time.
Going ahead with site licensing also raises several other questions.
They include which Canadian or New England utilities will buy the power, and what specific benefits Team Candu has committed to in return for New Brunswick agreeing to host the new reactor, which is expected to be a new design, the ACR-1000.
For Lepreau 2, Team Candu would bear the estimated $10- to $30-million cost of the approval process.
Approval for two more reactors does not mean construction would go ahead on both simultaneously, although Team Candu and its potential investors are weighing that possibility, said Keir.
Approval for a third reactor would allow for the option of building it once a key obstacle - lacking enough transmission lines to ship the extra electricity to customers - is overcome by new construction.
Keir said there would be cost savings from building two at a time, but "the biggest hurdle is capacity in the transmission lines."
Early this year, he had hoped a site licence application could be submitted by this past summer.
He intimated the holdup has been in ironing out the precise details of responsibility and liability in the merchant model.
Under a merchant model, Team Candu would finance, build and own the project.
NB Power would hold the site licence and operate the plant, just as it does Lepreau's existing publicly owned reactor.
NB Power and other utilities in the Maritimes and New England would be potential customers for the electricity.
A merchant model has never been used in Canada for any energy plant.
This would be the first merchant model in the world for a nuclear plant.
Keir said the questions of who is responsible and who is liable is "very complex.
"You want to make sure you get that right up front."
The global credit crunch is not expected to be much of a factor, as the project would not start to spend significant sums for a few years.
"Every private sector investor I've talked to in the last three months since all this started has said the exact same thing - if there's a good business case, specifically if there's a good business case in the energy sector, there's still money around to invest," Keir said.
The province and its consultants finished their review of the Lepreau 2 feasibility study some time ago.
The study, undertaken by Team Candu, concluded Lepreau 2 had a viable market for its 1,100 megawatts of power - roughly twice what the existing reactor pumps out - and that it could be competitively priced and the transmission network could get it to customers.
Keir said the province's own analysis of Team Candu's study agreed with those conclusions.
The Team Candu study has never been made public.
This fall, a Court of Queen's Bench judge turned down a request from the Telegraph-Journal to compel the province to release the Team Candu study in response to a right to information request.
Through a spokesman, Paul Robichaud, the energy critic for the Conservative Opposition, declined to comment.
Energy Minister Jack Keir expects to seek approval for two additonal nuclear reactors at Point Lepreau early in New Year
Rob Linke and
Christine Morris
Telegraph-Journal
OTTAWA - Energy Minister Jack Keir hopes to ask Canada's nuclear regulatory agency early in the new year to approve not one but two new nuclear reactors at Point Lepreau.
The reactors would be built and financed by the federal Crown corporation Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd. and its private-sector partners, which include global engineering firms such as SNC-Lavalin and Hitachi Nuclear.
The consortium - known as Team Candu - has been gradually lining up investors.
"I've met with many of the investors and they're very excited to move forward," said Keir. "I think we're very close."
Keir has said applying for a licence is tantamount to the private sector and the provincial government deciding to go ahead with the megaproject.
Building even one reactor could cost an estimated $4- to $5-billion and employ several thousand construction workers.
Together with a proposed second Irving Oil refinery, Lepreau would anchor an energy-based cluster the Graham government hopes would transform the province's economy.
Getting Lepreau 2's design, safety and environmental approvals from the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission and other agencies would likely take two or three years.
Deciding to go ahead with a second reactor at this point would be a surprise in at least one regard.
Some observers expected the Graham government to see if AECL could first prove it could complete the $1.4-billion refurbishment of NB Power's existing reactor at Lepreau on time and on budget.
That Candu 6 reactor, brought online in 1983, is the first in the world to undergo a total refurbishment.
AECL, the main contractor, stands to benefit if it can demonstrate costly nuclear plants can undergo smooth midlife overhauls that extend their useful service by another 25 years.
The 18-month project has a completion deadline of Sept. 30, 2009.
But this fall, AECL has had trouble with automated tooling, causing delays that have eaten up all the leeway in the schedule.
Unless engineers find ways to save time with the remaining work, the project will not meet its 18-month deadline.
NB Power expects to know sometime in January if the refurbishment can still be done on time.
Going ahead with site licensing also raises several other questions.
They include which Canadian or New England utilities will buy the power, and what specific benefits Team Candu has committed to in return for New Brunswick agreeing to host the new reactor, which is expected to be a new design, the ACR-1000.
For Lepreau 2, Team Candu would bear the estimated $10- to $30-million cost of the approval process.
Approval for two more reactors does not mean construction would go ahead on both simultaneously, although Team Candu and its potential investors are weighing that possibility, said Keir.
Approval for a third reactor would allow for the option of building it once a key obstacle - lacking enough transmission lines to ship the extra electricity to customers - is overcome by new construction.
Keir said there would be cost savings from building two at a time, but "the biggest hurdle is capacity in the transmission lines."
Early this year, he had hoped a site licence application could be submitted by this past summer.
He intimated the holdup has been in ironing out the precise details of responsibility and liability in the merchant model.
Under a merchant model, Team Candu would finance, build and own the project.
NB Power would hold the site licence and operate the plant, just as it does Lepreau's existing publicly owned reactor.
NB Power and other utilities in the Maritimes and New England would be potential customers for the electricity.
A merchant model has never been used in Canada for any energy plant.
This would be the first merchant model in the world for a nuclear plant.
Keir said the questions of who is responsible and who is liable is "very complex.
"You want to make sure you get that right up front."
The global credit crunch is not expected to be much of a factor, as the project would not start to spend significant sums for a few years.
"Every private sector investor I've talked to in the last three months since all this started has said the exact same thing - if there's a good business case, specifically if there's a good business case in the energy sector, there's still money around to invest," Keir said.
The province and its consultants finished their review of the Lepreau 2 feasibility study some time ago.
The study, undertaken by Team Candu, concluded Lepreau 2 had a viable market for its 1,100 megawatts of power - roughly twice what the existing reactor pumps out - and that it could be competitively priced and the transmission network could get it to customers.
Keir said the province's own analysis of Team Candu's study agreed with those conclusions.
The Team Candu study has never been made public.
This fall, a Court of Queen's Bench judge turned down a request from the Telegraph-Journal to compel the province to release the Team Candu study in response to a right to information request.
Through a spokesman, Paul Robichaud, the energy critic for the Conservative Opposition, declined to comment.