• City-versus-city activity is flat-out banned from being posted here in all its forms.

    City vs city trolling sets up a rather nasty and personal fight between forumers from one place and forumers from another place, potentially affecting hundreds of members any time it breaks out. Nothing good comes of versus-trolling, but long after the insults and mockery have been removed, bad feelings between individuals and between groups tend to linger, oftentimes popping up in unrelated threads for months afterwards.

    Thus, when it comes to 'versus' trolling, a line must be drawn--sharply. Anyone who crosses that line shall be disciplined, up to and including suspension and even summary banishment without warning. Forum moderation and administration shall be the arbiter of what constitutes versus-trolling, so if you think your post might be perceived as an unfair attack on an entire city that will upset residents there, tread lightly or reconsider how you intend to express your opinion. No forumer shall successfully claim ignorance of our policy against versus trolling, and no forumer should believe he can get away with it.

    The ban on versus activity applies to all posts and all threads, even ones that are not initially set up as city-versus-city.

    If you see any troublesome posts please report them using the "report a post" icon -
    report.gif
    in the upper right corner of every post on the forum.

Ranked:The World’s Strongest City Economies by 2050


The US has some advantages for the innovation economy (such as willingness to take risks) but will lose some of our innovation role for several reasons.

First, we're defunding the basic pre-commercial science that precedes a lot of our commercial innovation.

Second, we're no longer attracting the world's best and brightest. It's like the NBA deciding to discourage Wemby/Giannis/Jokic/Doncic/SGA, so they stay home or found a super-league elsewhere. Other countries/cities are stepping up in big ways to attract STEM folks.

Third, we care about safety, quality of life, and sustainability to some degree, at least locally. We also have strict liability laws. This is stifling some innovation and development.

Fourth (a big one), reliance on US companies is now a risk to anyone else, because apparently we can simply cancel other users/buyers at any point. Other countries are furiously creating workarounds, which will result in real competition across a broad range of industries.

Fifth, any product that relies on components that repeatedly cross the US border is either paying multiple tariffs or (more importantly) could at some point. Avoiding this is a major focus for a lot of supply chains.

Sixth, we're no longer a reliable or predictable partner for any kind of shared effort. Partnerships between companies, between universities, etc., are often the genesis of major innovations, but it's a real risk to include us now.

That's just some factors off the top of my head. There are others.

very good points.
 
China didn't invent solar panels.

Correct. My Dad was working on solar panels back in the 1970s. One time, around 1980, we got in the car and toured a Long Island housing development that was outfitted with the technology his institute had developed (you couldn't see the panels from the street, so that was a bust).
 
who really cares who invented what? In Brantford (Ontario), there are signs everywhere about Alexander Graham Bell inventing the telephone, apparently in that city (never mind that he probably didn't). Today Brantford is little more than a bedroom community for the GTA.

The Chinese invented gunpower, but it was the Europeans that mobilized that technology to conquer the world. The amount of technology "stolen" by the Europeans from other places is staggering.
 
So, I've had a look at this. Apparently Chinese apparel and footwear now dominates the African market, with 70% to 80% of clothes and footwear sold in Africa being Chinese, leaving Nikes and US brands only a tiny percentage of the African market..

Chinese clothing is pretty big here as well and actually fits me better than most western brands however, the draw to brands like Shein is that they are cheap and decent looking, not because they are Shein or Chinese. Where as clothing like Nike is all about the branding which is associated with American culture.

As for the music videos, it's hip-hop and R&B, American exports which Africa and other places put their own spin on but it's apparent that American pop culture was the inspiration.
 
Spoken like a true imperialist, but entirely laughable. You guys don't even control Cuba, which is 90 miles off the coast of Florida.

The U.S. passed on several opportunities to make Cuba part of the United States. So to all of you who decry expansionism, look what can happen when you don't take an opportunity - it can can come back to haunt you. The U.S. did not take military action against Cuba after the missile crisis because of a diplomatic agreement with the Soviet Union. So to all of you saying the U.S. is always warmongering and doesn't understand diplomacy - well here is somebody accusing the U.S. of lacking the military ability to take Cuba when in fact we were adhering to a diplomatic agreement.

After the disaster in Cuba, the U.S. became very vigilant in stamping out any and every communist cell in Central America and South America. Keep in mind that the Soviet Union had been plotting in Mexico for decades prior - it's no coincidence that Leon Trotsky fled to Mexico.


If your country was truly so great, you wouldn't have the need to constantly remind everybody about it.

On this forum various people like to make ridiculous comments about the United States, then flip out when somebody corrects them. China is nowhere near the economic, cultural, or military peer of the United States, and it's perverse that so many people here are rooting for it because they've been fooled by China into thinking we are the problem.
 
They are nearly equal or have perhaps already passed the US in terms of science and R&D.

Yeah, that's Chinese propaganda that the fools at outlets like NPR fall for.


They are only a few years away from being ahead of the US in terms of technology and military.

The U.S. is two generations ahead of China in every military category. Most of their new stuff is at the level we were building in the 1970s - 50 years ago.

Unless they commit some big blunders (which is always possible), it's hard to imagine how they could not become world's #1.

Like...tanking their own population? The total population of China is predicted to fall by 50% by the end of this century, and most of their population in 2100 will be old. But the working-age population is predicted to fall from 900 million (current) to as low as 200 million, so that's more like a 75% decline.

It is estimated that China had 25 million births per year in the 1950s. Now they're down to 8 million. By contrast, the U.S. was having 4 million births per year in the 1950s and currently has 3.5 million births. We also have many immigrants arrive each year, whereas China loses people to out-migration each year.
 
The U.S. passed on several opportunities to make Cuba part of the United States. So to all of you who decry expansionism, look what can happen when you don't take an opportunity - it can can come back to haunt you. The U.S. did not take military action against Cuba after the missile crisis because of a diplomatic agreement with the Soviet Union. So to all of you saying the U.S. is always warmongering and doesn't understand diplomacy - well here is somebody accusing the U.S. of lacking the military ability to take Cuba when in fact we were adhering to a diplomatic agreement.

After the disaster in Cuba, the U.S. became very vigilant in stamping out any and every communist cell in Central America and South America. Keep in mind that the Soviet Union had been plotting in Mexico for decades prior - it's no coincidence that Leon Trotsky fled to Mexico.




On this forum various people like to make ridiculous comments about the United States, then flip out when somebody corrects them. China is nowhere near the economic, cultural, or military peer of the United States, and it's perverse that so many people here are rooting for it because they've been fooled by China into thinking we are the problem.

I'm glad that you brought up Leon Trotsky. How can I argue against you when you dredge up the threat of Trotskyism (never mind that Trotsky was exiled from the USSR, living in Turkey, then France, then Norway, then Mexico, and later assassinated by Stalin's henchmen).

For the record, I hold a PhD from a Business School (with more than 25 years of teaching and researching business-related topics), so please don't try to characterize me as some sort of Commie. I'm not rooting for China. I am not rooting against the United States. But I despise a lot of what I am seeing in America, from the god-awful Trump administration, and his equally awful supporters.

By the way, you aren't by chance related to Joseph McCarthy?


While the United States remains the world's largest economy by nominal GDP and leads in foundational semiconductor design and cutting-edge software development, China has taken a commanding lead over the USA across several critical technological, industrial, and social sectors.

1. Green Energy & Transportation
• Electric Vehicles (EVs) & Batteries: China produces over 60% of all electric vehicles globally. It completely dominates the lithium-ion battery supply chain, enabling brands like BYD to outpace American competitors.
• Renewable Energy Grid: China adds more solar and wind energy to its power grid than any other nation, producing roughly 40% of the world’s solar photovoltaics.
• High-Speed Rail: China possesses the world's largest high-speed rail network, spanning tens of thousands of miles, while the US network remains negligible.


2. Manufacturing, Logistics & Infrastructure
• Industrial Scale: China is the undisputed "world's factory," accounting for roughly 35% of global manufacturing output compared to America's ~12%.
• Shipbuilding: China vastly outperforms the U.S. in commercial and naval ship production capacity, giving it a numbers advantage in total naval vessels.
• Mega-Infrastructure Speed: China constructs public transit, ports, and data centers at a fraction of the cost and time it takes the U.S.. Massive shipping channels like the Pinglu Canal showcase this logistical advantage.


3. Advanced Hardware & "AI Bodies"
• Robotics: China is highly dominant in the production of commercial drones (e.g., DJI) and manufactures 90% of global humanoid robot exports.
• Cost-Efficient AI Execution: While the U.S. leads in pure computing power and expensive chip design (like Nvidia), Chinese firms like DeepSeek lead in creating highly cost-efficient, open-weight AI models. The performance gap between top Chinese and U.S. AI models has narrowed to just 3%.
• Quantum Communication: China leads in secure quantum encryption networks, having successfully established massive, multi-thousand-mile quantum key distribution corridors.


4. STEM Education & Human Capital
• STEM Graduates: China produces roughly 3.5 million Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math (STEM) graduates annually, compared to America's ~820,000.
• PhD Pipelines: China has surpassed the U.S. as the top global producer of STEM doctoral degrees. In fact, elite American tech labs and universities heavily rely on Chinese-born researchers to staff their own operations. China leads the world in scientific publications.

images
 
Anyways, the discussion thread has veered out of City Discussion territory and into Current Events Territory. I will skip out for now.
 
China's economy has actually been losing ground to the U.S. this decade. And this during a period when the U.S. economy hasn't exactly been firing on all cylinders in its own right.

China's GDP as percentage of U.S. GDP

2000: 12%
2005: 18%
2010: 41%
2015: 62%
2020: 71%
2025: 64%

According to Statista China's GDP is projected to be about 69% of the U.S. GDP by 2030, which is still below what it was in 2020. If China had remained on its pre-2020 trajectory, it would have overtaken the U.S. economy by now. But I don't know if they can close the gap by just being an exporter economy. And even if they do eventually overtake the U.S., I wouldn't bet on that happening within the next 20 years.

Japan's economy peaked around 70% of the U.S. economy in 1995, so China is exactly where Japan was 30 years ago relative to the U.S. economy.
 
US economy hasn't been firing on all cylinders? The US economy has seen faster growth in the last decade than the 3 decades preceding it and has consistently posted by far the fastest growth out of basically any western, developed nation. It's absolutely incredible how much the US economy has grown in the last 10 years, especially since it's starting at what is already a very high base level.
 
US economy hasn't been firing on all cylinders? The US economy has seen faster growth in the last decade than the 3 decades preceding it and has consistently posted by far the fastest growth out of basically any western, developed nation. It's absolutely incredible how much the US economy has grown in the last 10 years, especially since it's starting at what is already a very high base level.

Not true, at least not according to Google AI:

"No, the U.S. economy has not seen higher average annual real GDP growth in the last 10 years (2016–2026) compared to the 30 years preceding that (1986–2016).

📊 Growth Comparison

• Last 10 Years (2016–2026): Real GDP growth averaged roughly 2.0% to 2.5% annually, punctuated by the sharp 2020 pandemic contraction and subsequent robust post-rebound normalization.
• Preceding 30 Years (1986–2016): Real GDP growth averaged closer to 2.7% to 3.0%+ annually, driven by stronger labor force expansion and higher productivity booms in the late 20th century."

Even if our economy is doing well, it's irrelevant to people who are struggling with inflation, higher living costs, higher borrowing costs, etc. We're number 1 in GDP. Whoopdee-fuckin'-doo.
 
Democratic societies are necessary for free market capitalism.

I nearly spit out my tea when I read that.

You do realize that true, 100% free market capitalism does not exist in the world, right?

There are labor laws, contract laws, anti-trust laws, health boards, government subsidized infrastructure, environmental laws, consumer protection laws, laws against fraud, minimum wages, child labor laws, etc., etc., etc.

A street food vendor setting up shop right outside of a brick-and-mortar restaurant and being allowed to do so would be an example of free market capitalism---unfettered business being allowed to compete, yada yada yada. But of course the brick-and-mortar restaurant proprietor in the real United States would have a hissy-fit and would want that street vendor gone. So much for the free market and competition.

And free market capitalism isn't the savior for us all.
 
Literally every country has some free market capitalism, including black markets and the specific categories that the USSR, China, etc., have opened up.
 
"The economy" isn't just GDP and the stock market. By those measures we're fine.

By others we've declined. It's getting tougher for the median person to afford healthcare, college, or any sort of home. A smaller percentage of wealth or prosperity is reaching people in the middle and lower levels of the spectrum. More people are on the edge, or literally homeless, and/or with no realistic retirement plan or working extreme hours.

Some of that needs context. Part of the growth in college costs is big reductions in state spending, which have to be replaced by higher tuition. Healthcare costs are padded by huge costs due to the insurance process and giant malpractice payouts. Homes have gotten much bigger (well, houses have).

The expensive cities are often the ones with the widest split between rich, middle class, and poor.
 
US economy hasn't been firing on all cylinders? The US economy has seen faster growth in the last decade than the 3 decades preceding it and has consistently posted by far the fastest growth out of basically any western, developed nation. It's absolutely incredible how much the US economy has grown in the last 10 years, especially since it's starting at what is already a very high base level.

Not really. I mean, our GDP and the markets are on a rip but much of that is due to the AI sector which is propping up most of our good numbers.
 
China's economy has actually been losing ground to the U.S. this decade. And this during a period when the U.S. economy hasn't exactly been firing on all cylinders in its own right.

China's GDP as percentage of U.S. GDP

2000: 12%
2005: 18%
2010: 41%
2015: 62%
2020: 71%
2025: 64%
Only because of the devaluation of the reminbi, because China wants a weak currency to export more. It's rather artificial, and does not reflect the real economy. Things that reflect the real economy, like electricity consumption, show continued growth, and China is already ahead of the US with many metrics.

At the end of the day, if China can produce 50 aircraft careers, and the US only 30, it doesn't really matter if the 50 Chinese aircraft careers are estimated to be worth less billion USD at market exchange rates than the 30 US Chinese aircraft careers. 50 trumps 30, and the fact your 30 are worth a couple more billion dollars than the 50 Chinese ones will not win you the naval battle.
 
In the real world, these are the latest figures from the IMF.

Real GDP growth (= inflation deducted) 2000-2009:
China: +10.35% per year
USA: +1.90% per year

Real GDP growth 2010-2019:
China: +7.66% per year
USA: +2.40% per year

Real GDP growth 2020-2026:
China: +4.81% per year
USA: +2.37% per year
 
Only because of the devaluation of the reminbi, because China wants a weak currency to export more. It's rather artificial, and does not reflect the real economy. Things that reflect the real economy, like electricity consumption, show continued growth, and China is already ahead of the US with many metrics.

At the end of the day, if China can produce 50 aircraft careers, and the US only 30, it doesn't really matter if the 50 Chinese aircraft careers are estimated to be worth less billion USD at market exchange rates than the 30 US Chinese aircraft careers. 50 trumps 30, and the fact your 30 are worth a couple more billion dollars than the 50 Chinese ones will not win you the naval battle.

China didn't devalue its currency enough for that much of a divergence. China's GDP went from adding 20% of US GDP every 5 years to losing 9% between 2015 and 2020. The renminbi was only slightly less expensive against the dollar in 2020 than it was in 2015 (6 rmb/ 1 dollar in 2015 versus roughly 7/1 in 2020). And the renminbi is still more expensive today in dollars than it was in 2005.
 


Back
Top