What stands out
Safety and disorder is the top theme, even though nothing asked about it. About 23% of comments are about open drug use, crime, encampments and not seeing police around. Most are about Uptown and Waterloo St. People compare Saint John with KV and Rothesay, and with the crackdowns in Fredericton and Moncton. Only about six comments want police spending cut. About a dozen people say they have moved, or are thinking of moving, to the suburbs because of it. This lines up with police being #2 in Q1 at 49.8%.
The most common revenue idea is taxing industry, not residents. About 17% name Irving or heavy industry, the 2013 tax break, industrial assessment levels or provincial tax reform. A few also raise industry's water pricing. This matches the top pick in Q5, regional cost-sharing and tax reform at 53.4%. People plainly see this as the missing third choice between raising taxes and cutting services.
Anger about traffic calming is mostly about speed cushions. About 14% want speed cushions or bike lanes stopped, and speed cushions come up slightly more often than bike lanes. Several people suggest ticketing instead, and some want the City to lobby the Province for a share of fine revenue. About 28 comments support transit or active transportation, which is roughly 2.5 against for every one in favour. That's almost the same ratio as the checkbox questions: 43.9% spend less on active transportation vs 18.5% spend more. The supportive comments are mostly about transit frequency and hours, not bike lanes, and transit comes out positive in the checkbox results too.
People think suburbs should pay their share. About 26 comments call for amalgamation, tolls, a "poll tax", recreation fees for non-residents, or requiring City staff to live in the city. One says Council dropped a planned non-resident recreation fee in 2020 in exchange for a $60K payment.
People think the City has too many managers and not enough frontline workers. About 24 comments say "fewer managers, more boots on the ground." Some give specifics: HR's budget went from $1.4M in 2020 to $2.8M in 2025, and management and admin positions went from 92 to 102 while total permanent positions fell. Others complain about the new CAO's salary postings and the 4-day work week.
Opposition to the data centre shows up even though the survey didn't ask. About 19 comments oppose the Lorneville/VoltaGrid data centre and 3 support it. The concerns are the power grid, water, few permanent jobs, and the fact that industrial assessment means it won't pay much tax.
Sensible ideas that came up more than once:
- escalating taxes on vacant land and derelict buildings
- coordinating road and sidewalk plows so the road plow doesn't bury the cleared sidewalk
- holding paving contractors to warranties, and better asphalt
- sending a smaller vehicle instead of a fire truck to medical calls
- partnering with Saint John Energy on renewable energy revenue
- bringing back weekly garbage pickup