Migrant_Coconut
Active member
Pretty sure djmk means "really?" as in "shouldn't we at least have a vote on it?" That's been the case for most other boundary shifts.
Pretty sure djmk means "really?" as in "shouldn't we at least have a vote on it?" That's been the case for most other boundary shifts.
Reviving this thread to advocate for amalgamation once more, especially since it has been on the tongues of municipal politicians this election.
Saanich and Victoria will both have a non-binding question on municipal ballots about merging.
The Vancouver Liberals want to absorb the UEL into Vancouver.
Metro Vancouverites are split roughly 50-50 pro vs against amalgamation as of polling last year. Though apparently Burnaby and New West, the most geographically central municipalities, are the most opposed.
How are forum members feeling about amalgamation these days?
How are forum members feeling about amalgamation these days?
That's out of a total metropolitan Vancouver population of about 3 million.Vancouver is the largest city in British Columbia with an estimated population of about 750,000. Surrey is the second-largest city in the province at approximately 730,000, growing fast and expected to pass Vancouver in the late 2030s.
I mean look at the list of the most logical cities to amalgamate and those are the ones who probably hate amalgamation the most.
The only way it would ever happen is if BC/federal government promised some massive hundred billion dollar infrastructure campaign tied to amalgamation.
If BC wanted to amalgamate municipalities together, they wouldn't need to bribe anyone. Toronto and Ottawa were merged at the whim of the provincial government and people still complain about it to this day.
Personally I disagree with the thesis that Vancouver shouldn't amalgamate "because look at Toronto". I don't think I agree with the general political tide of Richmond of the North Shore but I also think I deserve a say in how transit development, land use, and bylaws are set in the areas I work, live, and play and so do they. It's very anti democratic to say "if we let people vote, I think they will vote for the wrong things, so they shouldn't be allowed to vote." It's actually insane to me that someone can live in Port Coquitlam and work in Vancouver and commute across the Burrard Peninsula every single day but they have zero political power in Coquitlam, Burnaby, or Vancouver. If Coquitlam voters decide they want politicians to kill transit improvements or cheap out on road maintenance the PoCo resident just has to accept that. It also grinds my gears a little that Vancouver can let its aquatic centres and community centres fall into disrepair to save Vancouverites a buck or two, but those same Vancouverites get to hop the border into Burnaby to use their facilities.
Politically, it appears to be a non-starter; different factions of YIMBYs and NIMBYs all have different incompatible interests that prevent a merger.
Logistically, it's pretty stupid how we have a dozen different fire and engineering departments, a dozen different library systems, a dozen different city halls (etc etc) and one unified infrastructure org that's mostly toothless and seemingly only exists to flush money down a toilet.
That is really it, if the North Vans and Langleys were to merge, the "city of" in both cases would be overridden by their NIMBY counterparts (I have similar opposition to the suggestions of merging New West with any of it's neighbours for this reason).
I think the answer is a regional government that's more accountable to the people of the region, and the uploading of some services to Metro Vancouver. Also having the Province reorganize its' services like healthcare and schools into a more unified structure. It makes no sense that we have both Vancouver Coastal Health and Fraser Health doubling up on their administration (and inevitably causing issues when one moves from one city in our region to another).
That is really it, if the North Vans and Langleys were to merge, the "city of" in both cases would be overridden by their NIMBY counterparts (I have similar opposition to the suggestions of merging New West with any of it's neighbours for this reason).
Fraser Health covers a lot more than the Lower Mainland, including Abbotsford, Chilliwack and Hope. I assume the services offered to those residents beyond the Lower Mainland would still have to be run, but by a much smaller agency that would then have to buy in specialist services currently available under the Fraser Health umbrella. I wonder if there would be any benefit really - you would just be replacing the current boundaries with different ones. Schools are based on municipalities, so wouldn't the same arguments about not wanting New Westminster to be a smaller part of a larger merged municipality apply to schools as well?
I still think I dislike this line of thought. At the end of the day all I hear is:
Problem: I don't like how my neighbours think and vote.
Solution: We should ensure the system is designed to make sure their vote doesn't count. At least not, "here".
What's to stop us from saying, "Well the Dunbar neighbourhood tends to be NIMBYs so we should expel Dunbar from Vancouver to ensure the voting pattern of the city is what I'd like." Secession is just amalgamation in reverse after all.
It feels very authoritarian to me and in the same vein as US Republican gerrymandering and voting laws.
That's an incredibly exaggerated perception of what I was getting at, I don't think it's really relevant. I just support the status quo for this reason, I like that there's a few municipalities that are progressive compared to their counterparts.
That is really it, if the North Vans and Langleys were to merge, the "city of" in both cases would be overridden by their NIMBY counterparts (I have similar opposition to the suggestions of merging New West with any of it's neighbours for this reason).
I think the answer is a regional government that's more accountable to the people of the region, and the uploading of some services to Metro Vancouver. Also having the Province reorganize its' services like healthcare and schools into a more unified structure. It makes no sense that we have both Vancouver Coastal Health and Fraser Health doubling up on their administration (and inevitably causing issues when one moves from one city in our region to another).
city and district of NV share so many costs, its a bit wild that they have not amalgamated