Saul Goode
New member
I'm pretty sure King's Wharf and a number of other infill projects around the harbour are also mostly pyritic slate dumps.
Well, yes, of course they are. What's your point?
I'm pretty sure King's Wharf and a number of other infill projects around the harbour are also mostly pyritic slate dumps.
OK, it makes sense that there needs to be a location to dispose of the slate. What I do not know is whether the cove as it currently is has much depth or any use as a marine site if unchanged. I look at that abandoned pier just south of the Macdonald bridge and wonder if perhaps that might be a useful site for such things. Or some other location outside of the city.
I’ve always wondered whether infill could be added in Bedford basin along the route of the CN tracks so that a dedicated commuter rail line could be created
Here's my little rant:
If you own a house in the middle of a growing city CENTER, why not sell and move out of the city center if what you want is no development, no high rises, no traffic etc etc. Why stay and fight against every single development that could actually bring economic oxygen to a stagnant economy. Atlantic Canada needs a major city. Nova Scotia needs a major city. Major cities are the heart and lungs of any regional economic ecosystem. The city center of Halifax and Dartmouth need major developments. Infills like kings wharf are driving the future of Halifax for the betterment of all Atlantic Canada
Just suggesting it. It's what I would do. If too many high rises are going up around me and I don't like it, I would seriously consider selling and buying a place in an area that is more suited to my small town preferences.
Dartmouth Cove by A.J. Forsythe, on Flickr[/URL]
Vancouver west end beach by A.J. Forsythe, on Flickr[/URL]Keep in mind that the “Friends of Dartmouth Cove” or whatever the activist group is called is a pretty extreme sort of bunch who want no development there at all (despite it formerly being a shipyard site) and want the usual parkland/recreational sort of uses. Seems like a no-win situation.
Against my better judgement I’ll take the bait here. The former shipyard site is at King’s Wharf, which is not the area under discussion. Few people have any objection to that development, nor to other developments on the existing land in Dartmouth Cove. Easily thousands of units can and will be created in those areas. For most the fight against ARCP isn’t about blocking construction in the area. The issue is the continued existence of the trail, which was a rare amenity given to the local community when the sewage treatment plant was constructed towards Woodside. If ARCP’s infilling proceeds, access will be blocked intermittently, and with no clear path to development of the new land there’s a good chance of it remaining an eyesore for the foreseeable future and making it a much less pleasant place to walk. And again, there’s no shortage of opportunity sites in the vicinity - the infilling isn’t necessary to meet demand for housing in Dartmouth. I’m sure opinion will vary, but if the city’s proposal is more limited infilling to facilitate the proposed emergency access route, I expect the community will be more receptive. With the benefit of hindsight, the city messed up by not procuring the water lot adjacent to the trail for what likely would have been peanuts.
If the trail is so important I don't know why Dominion Diving and ARCP can't come to an agreement to allow ARCP drive their trucks onto the Dominion site and dump from there. Dominion is an important inner harbour company that provides specialty diving, repair, and special refuse removal . The trail literally abuts the Dominion site for about a quarter mile just beside Kings Wharf. Not a peep out of the Nimbys for that very industrial site. I wonder if this is a fight to be big man on Campus?
I can see the Port eventually coming up with a combined public Use of the Cove for the Second Cruise terminal that has been touted before and perhaps a public Park covering the water lot after ARCP dumps the slate. None of which will impede the trail. I use the trail quite a bit by parking at Woodside and walking to Alderney as it provides an impressive walking tour of Halifax harbour.
It’s nowhere near a quarter mile, even including the other site next to Dominion. And sure, the trail would be nicer without the industrial sites but they predate the trail so people accept them. I don’t understand your comment about NIMBYs in that context. Access via Dominion makes no sense for several reasons, the primary one being that their lot doesn’t touch ARCP’s.
I doubt a Dartmouth cruise ship terminal will happen but if it does hopefully they’ll put it somewhere like the old Imperial refinery site so the passengers can hop right on the highway to go on their excursions.
With the benefit of hindsight, the city messed up by not procuring the water lot adjacent to the trail for what likely would have been peanuts.
It's interesting to contrast the beach and park/amenity situation and mentality in Halifax with Vancouver. Parts of Vancouver have an almost resort-like feel (e.g., around Davie and Denman), and there are nice beaches with lots of amenities nearby. As the AI suggests above these beaches are significantly man-made and maintained. The summers here aren't really any longer or hotter than Halifax. Vancouver is a much larger city, but Halifax could have some of the same kinds of amenities.
There is Black Rock Beach but it's kind of underwhelming and low on amenities. The Waegwoltic has an outdoor waterfront pool but it's private. Something like an outdoor saltwater pool by King's Wharf and/or a small beach (which they had in some renderings) with city and harbour views would be great. I wonder if it's possible to do some kind of solar heating system that brings in salt water then heats it a bit more.
Halifax should aim for something like Icebergs at Bondi Beach. Nobody should be swimming in harbour water without significant treatment. I'm not sure people are aware how dirty the water actually is.
Bondi Beach Club by A.J. Forsythe, on Flickr[/URL]With water quality data backing it up, I think that the dirty water idea might just be a little outdated. Understandable if you haven’t been in the city for a very long time.