• City-versus-city activity is flat-out banned from being posted here in all its forms.

    City vs city trolling sets up a rather nasty and personal fight between forumers from one place and forumers from another place, potentially affecting hundreds of members any time it breaks out. Nothing good comes of versus-trolling, but long after the insults and mockery have been removed, bad feelings between individuals and between groups tend to linger, oftentimes popping up in unrelated threads for months afterwards.

    Thus, when it comes to 'versus' trolling, a line must be drawn--sharply. Anyone who crosses that line shall be disciplined, up to and including suspension and even summary banishment without warning. Forum moderation and administration shall be the arbiter of what constitutes versus-trolling, so if you think your post might be perceived as an unfair attack on an entire city that will upset residents there, tread lightly or reconsider how you intend to express your opinion. No forumer shall successfully claim ignorance of our policy against versus trolling, and no forumer should believe he can get away with it.

    The ban on versus activity applies to all posts and all threads, even ones that are not initially set up as city-versus-city.

    If you see any troublesome posts please report them using the "report a post" icon -
    report.gif
    in the upper right corner of every post on the forum.

Could something like this ever get built in the US?


In my excursions on Google maps I've recently encountered the Münchner Haus at the summit of the Zugspitze, Germany's highest peak at 9,700+ feet, and I'm rather flabbergasted that the thing exists at all. Granted, it was first constructed in the late 19th century, but obviously it's been expanded and modernized, probably many times, since then ...

--> Good image of its precarious location <--
--> Another one <--

... Which got me wondering: Would any place in the US ever permit something like that to be built? :shrug: I'm not sure that even in the late 1800's anywhere in the US (and maybe Canada) would have the guts to build such a large and well-used structure on such a precarious location. But maybe I'm wrong? I know there are plenty of ski huts and clubs at the top of ski slopes in the US, but AFAIK there's nothing in remotely such a precarious position.

We can turn this into a discussion of things that got built elsewhere that would never be permitted to get built in the US.
 
It's not a hiker's lodge, but there is that big weather station at the top of Mt. Washington in New Hampshire.

Pike's Peak strikes me as the best opportunity for a Zugspitze-style hiker's hut in the US, since it has that road and railway to the top anyway. It's not like it has been preserved as some park or something.
 
Mt Washington isn't remotely like the one on Zugspitze. Mt Washington is basically a large, gentle hill. Same with the Smoky Mountains. Zugspitze is a rock precipice.

Pikes Peak might a better example, but the fact you can drive up to it indicates it's still relatively gentle. Zugspitze is a rock precipice, it would be like building something on the edge of the top of El Capitan in Yosemite, except 9700 feet up.
 
Mt Washington isn't remotely like the one on Zugspitze. Mt Washington is basically a large, gentle hill. Same with the Smoky Mountains. Zugspitze is a rock precipice.

Pikes Peak might a better example, but the fact you can drive up to it indicates it's still relatively gentle. Zugspitze is a rock precipice, it would be like building something on the edge of the top of El Capitan in Yosemite, except 9700 feet up.

Is there even a mountain in the US that is a huge rock precipice then?
 
getting touristy crowds up and down is more the issue than the site.

munchner is for hikers, but i dk if that is finacially practical?

ski lifts or a train?

it would probably have to be tied to a ski resort.
 
getting touristy crowds up and down is more the issue than the site.

munchner is for hikers, but i dk if that is finacially practical?

ski lifts or a train?

it would probably have to be tied to a ski resort.


Jay Peak in Vermont has a gondola cabin up top that turns into a giant icicle in the dead of winter. I’m gonna get shot down for that suggestion, too. Lol
 
This is what lies (near) the top of Sulphur Mountain, in Banff National Park (Alberta, Canada)

PX-View-from-Boardwalk.jpg


It is the Gondola Station + levels of gift shops, coffee/snack shops, restaurants, and observatories.
 
One of two Peak-to-Peak Gondola Stations that connect the top of Whister mountain with Blackcomb mountain (British Columbia, Canada)
6eb16b69-1adb-4c09-9b08-f73adb564070.jpg


whi100.jpg
 
Mt Washington isn't remotely like the one on Zugspitze. Mt Washington is basically a large, gentle hill. Same with the Smoky Mountains. Zugspitze is a rock precipice.

Zugspitze is part of the Alps, a young mountain range produced with flat-slab subduction. The only similar mountain range is the rather isolated St. Elias Mountains in Alaska. Other mountain ranges do not have that opportunity for such precipicious structures as the mountains are older and more weathered.
 
Zugspitze is part of the Alps, a young mountain range produced with flat-slab subduction. The only similar mountain range is the rather isolated St. Elias Mountains in Alaska. Other mountain ranges do not have that opportunity for such precipicious structures as the mountains are older and more weathered.
There are plenty of mountain ranges in western North America with similar steep, rocky precipices. As I said before, Mt Shuksan in the Cascades would be similar one.

The other ones above in Whistler and Banff are a little closer, but I was thinking of something that's practically hanging off a cliff like the one on Zugspitze.
 
This is just crazy. Can't believe they'd ever try something like this in the US. Lawyers would go crazy, probably it would never get built just because insurance would be too expensive, or something.

Post-Image_Zugspitze-Day-Trip-A-Journey-to-the-Top-of-Germany-in-Summer.jpg
 
If it was done in the US, it would be in a place like Colorado or maybe California where you currently have a fairly dry climate, but also had extensive glaciation during the ice ages of the pliestocene and holocene periods that grinds along the base of the drainages. That''s what forms the steep sided, U shape profile of all the various features like cirques, gullies, chutes, etc that shape the sides of steep precipitous summits.

Shuksan is inundated with snowfall every winter and it's slopes are laced with glaciers and icefall. The rock is greenshist and is crumblier than harder rocks like granite. There's no feasable way you're building anything without billions. You could possibly find something in the Wenatchee Mountains that had big sheer granite faces, but as with most of the west, the feds own everything and that alone precludes private enterprise from attempting this.

I agree it's an intriguing concept.
 
Alyeska resort has a lodge that's kind of on a cliff, I guess?
1920px-Mount_Alyeska.jpg
(wikipedia)

but yeah, the US doesn't do alpine infrastructure like Europe. few gondolas not corresponding to ski resorts, very few mountain cabins to speak of etc. even Romania has better mountain infrastructure...
 


Back
Top