• City-versus-city activity is flat-out banned from being posted here in all its forms.

    City vs city trolling sets up a rather nasty and personal fight between forumers from one place and forumers from another place, potentially affecting hundreds of members any time it breaks out. Nothing good comes of versus-trolling, but long after the insults and mockery have been removed, bad feelings between individuals and between groups tend to linger, oftentimes popping up in unrelated threads for months afterwards.

    Thus, when it comes to 'versus' trolling, a line must be drawn--sharply. Anyone who crosses that line shall be disciplined, up to and including suspension and even summary banishment without warning. Forum moderation and administration shall be the arbiter of what constitutes versus-trolling, so if you think your post might be perceived as an unfair attack on an entire city that will upset residents there, tread lightly or reconsider how you intend to express your opinion. No forumer shall successfully claim ignorance of our policy against versus trolling, and no forumer should believe he can get away with it.

    The ban on versus activity applies to all posts and all threads, even ones that are not initially set up as city-versus-city.

    If you see any troublesome posts please report them using the "report a post" icon -
    report.gif
    in the upper right corner of every post on the forum.

Select Cities by Elevation Gap between Lowest and Highest Points


Anchorage and Juneau are city-boroughs, which are city-counties in the mainland US.

Anchorage Borough has a land area bigger than Rhode Island's land and water, and Juneau Borough have a land area bigger than Delaware's land and water.

Just some perspective on elevation difference.
 
The NYC islands also added drama - the placing of the Statue of Liberty being the most iconic.

I feel NYC still has a wonderful opportunity to build on all of this. It's rare that a city in this day and age has still such major features to exploit, if ever the economics will allow it.

1. The islands becoming unique attractions or parks, each with their own character.

2. The granite hillsides attracting dramatic housing and building (rather than a shelf for a highway)

3. The numerous unused wharfs reborn as waterside regenerations, once again each with their own character. The 'coastline' is made much, much bigger than similar cities, and compacted into walkable distances. There are already famous wharfs where this reinvention has come to fruiion, but imagine if all of them followed suit.


In short, what can be a restriction in a city can become a highlight, and NYC is a good example. However, it can still go further (which is a good thing, it's not reached it's potential yet)


Other good examples include some of the most celebrated of cities, despite their problematic siting - Hong Kong, Venice, San Francisco, Rome, Chongqing, Wuhan, Constantine (Algeria), Istanbul, Amsterdam, Singapore, St Petersburg, Sydney, Edinburgh, Rio, Barcelona.

Not sure when you were last here but this is what was done to Governor's Island in New York Harbor about 15 years ago. Some of the other islands have contamination issues that need to be sorted before they can be opened to the public though.



There is a rail right-of-way up the west side of Manhattan and the Bronx. The highway was built there because the rail ROW already existed. The only way to move housing closer to the shore than it already is would be to tunnel the rail line. But that would be extremely expensive because of the bedrock.

However, they did do this in Brooklyn, which did not previously have a heavy rail line along the waterfront before they started building housing. The highway came after the housing and runs underneath the boardwalk here: https://maps.app.goo.gl/NZvYuswg8mP8BJSk8

There is public space along just much of the waterfront on the outside of the perimeter highways in Manhattan and Brooklyn, but very little housing on the exterior of the perimeters. There is a bike trail along the outer periphery of West Side Highway that is connected to a bike trail network that goes throughout New York State. The highways in Manhattan (West Side Hwy and FDR) are partially built on landfill so they will likely never be buried. The West Side Highway was actually elevated until the 1970s. It was torn down due to deterioration and transformed into an at-grade boulevard below 59th Street.


Yeah, in the past 20 years or so, New York has been undergoing a dramatic transformation of its oft-neglected islands' coastlines. Not only Governor's Island been turned into recreational oasis, but as part of the very large push for reconnecting New York with its coastline and islands, a large part of Roosevelt Island and Randall's Island have been devoted to parkland and the public realm in recent-ish years.



Governor's Island

55296918568_406d2e1be0_b.jpg


55297009354_67812a41cf_b.jpg


55295852832_cac4310341_b.jpg


55297006309_33a3261afe_b.jpg


55297006624_2785441f85_b.jpg


55297006329_fe9c079588_b.jpg



Roosevelt Island

55295286732_0717f5593c_b.jpg


55296612710_9669ea42ae_b.jpg


55296441704_b2fb407cd0_b.jpg




Randall's Island

55296436519_578fb5c901_b.jpg


55296196371_96df4fc6e9_c.jpg


55296196531_5832ef361d_b.jpg





And almost the whole coast up and down Queens and Brooklyn side of the East River is being regenerated block by block with parkland, public spaces people now flock to, and dramatic towers.

55296441529_450e3ae0fc_b.jpg


55296196571_496a84b3ab_b.jpg


55295291697_53a35fe889_b.jpg


55295286427_b581dc6334_b.jpg


55296201506_2893d6292d_b.jpg


55296344463_4fd778c603_b.jpg


55296344473_4c0c575ac0_c.jpg


55296196501_857c141632_b.jpg


55296344518_f35caca100_z.jpg


55296344728_0968f38aba_z.jpg


55296436579_936d000a2b_c.jpg


55296196476_8c2939edbe_b.jpg


55296344533_c941771495_b.jpg


55296612830_240229fc0b_b.jpg


55296344493_cebeb7eb6a_b.jpg






The Manhattan side is also getting its own glow up. With the East Side Coastal Resiliency Project all along the Lower East Side.

55295286502_d9d6a8b555_b.jpg


55296436544_c49392ae58_b.jpg


55296612820_2d8f5afdcb_b.jpg


55296441814_7c34fd070f_b.jpg






And further uptown, where buildings and the FDR highway abut the very edge of the Manhattan coast, they created the East Side Greenway which is a new long esplanade that juts out into the river for dramatic views and space the people crave.

55295291347_ee3cf6c063_b.jpg


55296349528_4b39897c91_b.jpg


55296201071_174ea1d264_b.jpg


55295291357_762e930e12_b.jpg




Construction is ongoing all the way up in East Harlem too as we speak

55296952589_5439b8f7c1_b.jpg


55296861923_b6f07a70da_b.jpg


55296711301_a39c60a0ec_b.jpg


55296861898_db3b5ee1ec_b.jpg


55296711286_ee10fe0675_b.jpg





And all the way down in Battery Park is newly renovated park space that links the city to the waterfront

55296613060_df17c932f5_b.jpg


55296344708_5e92bd07ba_b.jpg


55296436734_b0e8f4a0f8_b.jpg




Not to mention the quite pretty beaches in Rockaway, Queens and Staten Island that have existed for decades.
 
Last edited:
And let's not forget the West Side of Manhattan which has a beautiful and accessible coastline for the entirety of its stretch. It's been reinventing itself for the past 20 years or so and is teeming with people during the warmer months. And almost every old pier/wharf has been regenerated into unique hangout spots, cruise terminals, gyms, fields, playgrounds, small beaches, food halls, restaurants, sports fields, museum-on-aircraft-carrier, and even a major film studio. You name it. You can't be a New Yorker without having attended some outing on the West Side coastline

Here are some pics I've taken on this stretch:

52937392755_5132ff19f3_b.jpg


52937393605_873d4c0531_b.jpg


52937446118_20e996423b_b.jpg


52937392065_de18c1044b_b.jpg


52937154694_dcc65e0b2e_b.jpg


52937154144_ceeb5a2b31_b.jpg


52937391920_b8163df8b5_b.jpg


52936998526_fdc57635d5_b.jpg


55295820812_3018cae075_b.jpg


55296974784_c32b64cb3a_b.jpg


55295820727_4ae9ab0df2_b.jpg


55296733181_93fc949902_b.jpg


55295820922_df43298a71_b.jpg
 
Earlier this year I read an article from the 1930s that detailed the grade separation of that project around 1930~. It cost $150 million - a truly staggering sum for a project nobody thinks about today (more than construction of Penn Station), and it doesn't seem to receive much traffic (by NYC standards). That same periodical reported that construction of the IND subway in the late 1920s-early 1930s was about $400 million - at the time the largest civic improvement in the history of Planet Earth.

I believe Amtrak is, at the moment, the only operator that uses those tracks within Manhattan, hence the low traffic volume. The future plan is for Metro North to implement service into Penn Station using those track.
 
I believe Amtrak is, at the moment, the only operator that uses those tracks within Manhattan, hence the low traffic volume. The future plan is for Metro North to implement service into Penn Station using those track.

Yeah, Metro North plans on expanding service to Penn via the West Side line, but first needs additional capacity at Penn. That route will eventually have heavy service.

The MTA is also considering stations along the route, at 59th Street and near Columbia.
 
In Summer 2000 I walked around Roosevelt Island by myself for a few hours. I took 1-2 rolls of 35mm slides that I will scan sometime and post here.

At the time the island was semi-abandoned. I noticed it on maps as a teenager but didn't know anything about it so I took the subway there, not knowing the crazy history of the 63rd St. tunnel at the time. I believe that the subway extended one more stop into Queens but it definitely did not connect westward. From memory I believe that that connection opened in 2001 or 2002.

Occasionally subway expansion proposals extend to Brooklyn (typically to Red Hook) under Governor's Island, naturally leading people to want a station for that island. But a station wouldn't make any sense without an aggressive development plan.
 
You should visit Roosevelt Island again. It's now fairly busy. There's a new Cornell University campus, the Theodore Roosevelt Memorial at the southern tip, and many thousands of new apartments. The northern third of the island is the last part to be redeveloped (old hospital replaced with highrise apartments).

I doubt Governors Island will ever get subway access, given all the higher priorities. Stony Brook University is building a campus there, kinda following the Cornell model on Roosevelt Island, but I think ferries will be sufficient.
 
You should visit Roosevelt Island again. It's now fairly busy. There's a new Cornell University campus, the Theodore Roosevelt Memorial at the southern tip, and many thousands of new apartments. The northern third of the island is the last part to be redeveloped (old hospital replaced with highrise apartments).

I doubt Governors Island will ever get subway access, given all the higher priorities. Stony Brook University is building a campus there, kinda following the Cornell model on Roosevelt Island, but I think ferries will be sufficient.

Like 15 years ago, Stanford was vying with Cornell to build that campus on Roosevelt Island, but it was awarded to Cornell after Stanford withdrew it's proposal.

"...Meanwhile, Stanford University withdrew its $2.5-billion bid to build a Roosevelt Island campus under the initiative on December 16. After weeks of negotiations with the city, it was determined that “it would not be in the best interests of the university to continue to pursue the opportunity,” Stanford said in a statement. It would not elaborate further. The university had proposed a 1.9-million-sq-ft, graduate-level teaching and research campus that was expected to house more than 200 faculty members and more than 2,000 students upon completion..."

https://www.enr.com/articles/11328-cornell-wins-nyc-s-applied-sciences-competition

That would have been very cool had it happened imo.
 
Like 15 years ago, Stanford was vying with Cornell to build that campus on Roosevelt Island, but it was awarded to Cornell after Stanford withdrew it's proposal.

Yeah, I remember all this. As a Cornell grad, I'm happy with the new campus. It has been good for the university and for NYC, but it would be amazing to have a Stanford campus in NYC. Maybe one day.
 
re: NYC/
Did anybody mention Fresh Kills? Just because it don’t have no skyscrapers don’t mean it ain’t worth mentioning, none, ain’t it?
 
Cincinnati has many similar hillside staircases and had five inclines until the last one was torn down in 1947. The big difference between Cincinnati and Pittsburgh inclines is that the Cincinnati streetcars traveled on the inclines as part of their regular routes:



One of the more ridiculous contraptions I've seen. I mean, why not just move the people up and down the hill rather then the streetcars themselves?

Can't imagine why they didn't last... :haha:
 
In Summer 2000 I walked around Roosevelt Island by myself for a few hours. I took 1-2 rolls of 35mm slides that I will scan sometime and post here.

At the time the island was semi-abandoned. I noticed it on maps as a teenager but didn't know anything about it so I took the subway there, not knowing the crazy history of the 63rd St. tunnel at the time. I believe that the subway extended one more stop into Queens but it definitely did not connect westward. From memory I believe that that connection opened in 2001 or 2002.

Yeah, they didn't connect the line through Roosevelt Island to the Queens Boulevard line until 2001. Since 2001 you have been able to go east from Roosevelt Island to Jamaica, Queens.

I doubt Governors Island will ever get subway access, given all the higher priorities. Stony Brook University is building a campus there, kinda following the Cornell model on Roosevelt Island, but I think ferries will be sufficient.

Everyone should really try as hard as possible to experience Governors Island before this happens. It's a great public space with extraordinary history right now but the historical feel will probably soon be developed away.
 
Yeah, I remember all this. As a Cornell grad, I'm happy with the new campus. It has been good for the university and for NYC, but it would be amazing to have a Stanford campus in NYC. Maybe one day.


as a Stanford grad... glad Stanford didn't do that.
 
Vienna/Austria:
Vienna stretches from an altitude of 151m (495ft) in the eastern district of "Lobau" to 542m (1,778ft) at the "Hermannskogel" in the Vienna Woods. The historic city center with St. Stephen's Cathedral is centrally located at around 172m (564ft) above sea level.
 
Vienna/Austria:
Vienna stretches from an altitude of 151m (495ft) in the eastern district of "Lobau" to 542m (1,778ft) at the "Hermannskogel" in the Vienna Woods. The historic city center with St. Stephen's Cathedral is centrally located at around 172m (564ft) above sea level.

thanks, I added Vienna to the list!:cheers:
 
In Montreal, the highest point is the summit of Mont Royal at 233 meters (764 feet). The lowest point is roughly 6 meters (20 feet) above sea level, located along the shoreline of the Fleuve St. Laurent near the Vieux Port.
 


Back
Top