Yuri
Active member
Another proof that citypopulation cannot be trusted for anything other than the population of legally defined administrative areas. They suck at statistical areas.
And yes, it's the only international definition we have. Even Brazil's IBGE uses it (they call it arranjos populacionais).![]()
With their own set of (arbitrary) rules, regarding commute, absolute numbers, relative numbers, definition of the core city, which in Brazil is the municipality, whose sizes range from 3.6 km² (Águas de São Pedro, SP) to 159,533 km² (Altamira, PA; bigger than England & Wales).
And of course, no one uses them. In Brazil, when metropolitan area is dicussed, it's only the official ones, as definited by respective state legislation. That's São Paulo Metropolitan Area, for example: https://pt.wikipedia.org/wiki/Região_Metropolitana_de_São_Paulo . Exact the same boundaries since 1970 and widely used by government bodies and academia.
Every country, every single academic paper are free to set up their own rules. IBGE, for instance, is still on the 2nd edition of "arranjos" (note they don't even use "metro area" to designate them) and rules were changed a bit between the two studies.
It depends how you define Lille. The urban region of Lille including Roubaix and Tourcoing was ahead of the urban region of Lyon from the 1890s until 1914, but it wasn't really a city, more like an industrial conurbation. Roubaix and Tourcoing still functioned as independent cities back then, so I don't think anyone would have thought of as Lille being larger than Lyon.
A more narrowly-defined urban territory, like this one of 118 km² (the delineated red territory in the center of each urban territory is the extent of the Medieval walled city before the expansion of the Industrial Revolution) shows that at its peak in 1911 Lille 118 km² had 333,000 inhabitants, whereas Lyon 118 km² had 550,000 inhabitants, so Lille was at 60.5% the population of Lyon.
![]()
Note that Lille was closer to Lyon at the 1806 census (first modern and fully accurate French census). Lille 118 km² had 68.3% the population of Lyon 118 km² in 1806, then Lyon grew more than Lille until 1855 (at the 1856 census, Lille 118 km² had only 45.9% the population of Lyon 118 km²), then after 1855 Lille grew more than Lyon until 1911 but never went back to having 68.3% of Lyon's population.
If you take a larger area, let's say 500 km²: how Lille vs Lyon compared over time?