City-versus-city activity is flat-out banned from being posted here in all its forms.
City vs city trolling sets up a rather nasty and personal fight between forumers from one place and forumers from another place, potentially affecting hundreds of members any time it breaks out. Nothing good comes of versus-trolling, but long after the insults and mockery have been removed, bad feelings between individuals and between groups tend to linger, oftentimes popping up in unrelated threads for months afterwards.
Thus, when it comes to 'versus' trolling, a line must be drawn--sharply. Anyone who crosses that line shall be disciplined, up to and including suspension and even summary banishment without warning. Forum moderation and administration shall be the arbiter of what constitutes versus-trolling, so if you think your post might be perceived as an unfair attack on an entire city that will upset residents there, tread lightly or reconsider how you intend to express your opinion. No forumer shall successfully claim ignorance of our policy against versus trolling, and no forumer should believe he can get away with it.
The ban on versus activity applies to all posts and all threads, even ones that are not initially set up as city-versus-city.
If you see any troublesome posts please report them using the "report a post" icon -in the upper right corner of every post on the forum.![]()
In this day an age of WhatsApp and videoconferences, whether you're 15 miles away or 4000 miles away makes far less difference than it used to.
The population of Spain includes the Canary Islands, Ceuta, and Melilla. And that's in Africa last time I checked. So should we also subtract these when comparing Spain with other European countries? :shrug:
Again, the fact that the Canary Islands are closer to continental Spain is irrelevant. A WhatsApp call to the Canary Islands or to Réunion is not very different.
People here also tend to disregard (of be unaware of) how intertwined the overseas departments and Metropolitan France are from a human point of view. At the 2022 census, 227,800 people born in Metropolitan France lived in the 4 old overseas departments (1.9 million people), where they made up 11.9% of the population. In comparison, only 181,900 people born in the European part of Spain lived in the Canary Islands (2.2 million people) at the 2022 census, where they made up 8.3% of the population. And this despite the fact that the overseas departments are considerably more distant from Metropolitan France than the Canary Islands from continental Spain.
Also, at the 2022 census there lived in Metropolitan France 472,400 people who were born in these 4 old overseas departments, whereas there lived in the European part of Spain only 69,800 people who were born in the Canary Islands.
From a human point of view the overseas departments of France are more integrated with Metropolitan France than the Canary Islands with the European part of Spain, with more exchanges and migrations between Metropolitan France and the overseas departments than is the case for Spain and the Canary Islands, so it's absurd not to include the population of the overseas departments in the population of France while including the population of the Canary Islands in the population of Spain. Not to mention that by removing the overseas departments of France we're also removing nearly 230,000 Metropolitan Frenchmen from the French statistics. How absurd is that?
Shall we take a rest from France and her colonies? I want to discuss Poland.
I recently had this discussion on the US demographic thread about what would happen to the US urban hierarchy once the population decline kicked in. Some posts for context:
After those comments I updated my Polish tables and I found this "future US" I envisioned right there now. Poland and their main metro areas (using more broad definitions):
POLAND
2002: 38,230,080
2011: 38,511,824 --- +0.7%
2021: 38,036,118 --- -1.2%
Warsaw
2002: 2,745,602
2011: 2,884,076 --- +5.0%
2021: 3,238,202 -- +12.3%
Katowice
2002: 2,604,971
2011: 2,490,911 --- -4.4%
2021: 2,329,394 --- -6.5%
Gdansk
2002: 1,184,875
2011: 1,245,970 --- +5.2%
2021: 1,353,475 --- +8.6%
Krakow
2002: 1,098,764
2011: 1,131,298 --- +3.0%
2021: 1,236,313 --- +9.3%
Lodz
2002: 1,131,777
2011: 1,081,110 --- -4.5%
2021: 1,032,013 --- -4.5%
Wroclaw
2002: 860,924
2011: 882,678 --- +2.5%
2021: 993,182 -- +12.5%
Poznan
2002: 845,315
2011: 886,811 --- +4.9%
2021: 978,512 -- +10.3%
Lublin
2002: 565,911
2011: 569,160 --- +0.6%
2021: 566,953 --- -0.4%
Szczecin
2002: 475,029
2011: 481,478 --- +1.4%
2021: 479,159 --- -0.5%
Bydgoszcz
2002: 461,958
2011: 470,285 --- +1.8%
2021: 460,202 --- -2.1%
Bialystok
2002: 429,839
2011: 436,829 --- +1.6%
2021: 448,497 --- +2.7%
At first glance it seems the comparison US and Poland is a bit unusual but observe how disperse is their urban network and how Warsaw has such a small share on total population, comparable to New York. Just multiply those numbers for 9 to get the US equivalent.
Notice how Polish population started to fall but their main metro areas actually accelerated, three of them (Warsaw, Wroclaw, Poznan) at double-digit rates and other two (Gdansk and Krakow) almost there. The only exceptions were Katowice (a collection of mid-sized cities, Ruhr-style; it's hard to get more Rust Belt than this) and Lodz, another Rust Belt type.
I started to talk about Japan, our ultimate example of a mature declining society, but it's urban hierarchy is very different of the US. Poland, on the other hand, is remarkably similar and it's illustrating perfectly what I believe will happen to the US within 15-20 years.
It's not just French Guiana. Réunion, Mayotte and New Caledonia are important for France's Indo-Pacific strategy, which is our equivalent to your 'pivot to Asia'. India has become a major ally of France (Rafale sales, Macron-Modi relationship, various economic agreements, etc), and the presence of France in the Indian Ocean via Réunion and Mayotte plays a great role there. These territories also host French intelligence surveillance stations (the equivalent of your Echelon system), which allow France to cover the entire planet, unlike our European neighbors (the UK had to join the US Echelon because they don't have their own unlike France). They also host French military bases, with French Navy ships permanently stationed in Réunion and New Caledonia.These relics from the former French and Spanish empires are not important parts of their current economy or national strategies. The exception might by the EU space activity in French Guyana.
By contrast, Alaska and Hawaii are fully integrated into U.S. culture because they are critical for keeping the Pacific Ocean safe for commercial shipping.
Regarding this specifically: the French overseas departments had a GDP of 66 bn US dollars in 2024 (and the overseas departments + territories a GDP of ca. 85-90 bn US dollars). The Canary Islands had a GDP of 69 bn US dollars. That's almost the same as Alaska, whose GDP was 71.5 bn US dollars in 2024. So is Alaska unimportant, and are the US ready to cede Alaska? :shrug:not important parts of their current economy
That old trope! They are not "very poor". In 2024 the nominal GDP per capita of the 5 French overseas departments was 28,900 USD, whereas the nominal GDP per capita of the Canary Islands was 30,700 USD. Guadeloupe, Martinique and Réunion have a higher GDP per capita than the Canary Islands (Martinique had 34,600 USD of GDP per capita in 2024, vs only 30,700 for the Canary Islands). Only French Guiana and Mayotte have a lower GDP per capita than the Canary Islands.They're very poor, with no job prospects for the bulk of the population. They live on Paris handouts.
I think we all know your obsession with race now. No need to come at it again and again. It would be like a French forumer telling you that your fellow Black compatriots from Salvador de Bahia are not really Brazilian.Canary Islanders are virtually 100% European; Martinique and Guadeloupe is almost 100% Afro-American, Mayotte is 100% Muslim and apparently is still under Islamic Law.
So no, the average Martinican doesn't look at all like the average French European; Canary Islanders are all Spanish Europeans.
As per figures in my post on the previous page, there are more Metropolitan Frenchmen living in the French overseas departments than European Spaniards living in the Canary Islands. So your theory is wrong. Since 2000 the French overseas departments have also been those with the highest GDP and job growth in France. It's normal, they are catching up with Metropolitan France, like the Canary Islands are catching up with the rest of Spain (thanks to EU funds).it's actually the opposite: Europeans move there for better quality of life or even job opportunities as it's one of the fastest growing regions in Spain.
Isn't French Guyana to France as Hawaii and Alaska are to the US; i.e., integral part of France? Which is a transcontinental country like the US, Russia, Turkey, etc.
This argument makes no sense. It only reinforces how distinct French overseas departments are from Metropolitan France. They're very poor, with no job prospects for the bulk of the population. They live on Paris handouts.
Canary Islanders are virtually 100% European; Martinique and Guadeloupe is almost 100% Afro-American, Mayotte is 100% Muslim and apparently is still under Islamic Law.
So no, the average Martinican doesn't look at all like the average French European; Canary Islanders are all Spanish Europeans. That's why they enjoy the same standards of living people in continental Spain and they don't need to emigrate there: it's actually the opposite: Europeans move there for better quality of life or even job opportunities as it's one of the fastest growing regions in Spain.
Politically, Martinique is France and Canary Islands are Spain. Those are facts. But we don't need to make such absurd claims that Martinique is "more French" than Canary Islands are Spanish.
That old trope! They are not "very poor". In 2024 the nominal GDP per capita of the 5 French overseas departments was 28,900 USD, whereas the nominal GDP per capita of the Canary Islands was 30,700 USD. Guadeloupe, Martinique and Réunion have a higher GDP per capita than the Canary Islands (Martinique had 34,600 USD of GDP per capita in 2024, vs only 30,700 for the Canary Islands). Only French Guiana and Mayotte have a lower GDP per capita than the Canary Islands.
And let's not even compare with Brazilian states. The 5 French overseas departments have a GDP per capita that is higher than all Brazilian states, including your home state of Sao Paulo. Just comparing on Google Street View the streets of any city in Réunion and any city in Brazil, even in the richer Brazilian states, is enough to tell which place is the richest. One place has European standards (despite being in the Indian Ocean), and the other has Latin American standards.
I think we all know your obsession with race now. No need to come at it again and again. It would be like a French forumer telling you that your fellow Black compatriots from Salvador de Bahia are not really Brazilian.
Afro-American is an ethnic group distinct to the United States. There are virtually no Afro-Americans in the French Caribbean lol. However, France also does not track racial statistics so where are you getting these ethnicity estimates?
He doesn't know. He just projects his own biases (or fears?) regarding Brazil's races (I'm referring to SSC conversations that you guys probably don't know about).Afro-American is an ethnic group distinct to the United States. There are virtually no Afro-Americans in the French Caribbean lol. However, France also does not track racial statistics so where are you getting these ethnicity estimates?
You've just described the Canary Islands. Congratulation. Madeira and Azores also. So, I assume we can now subtract them from Spanish and Portuguese figures, because they are just "artificial" territories in your opinion?This whole GDP is basically Paris dumping money on them. There is no real economy on overseas departments except maybe for Réunion and still heavily dependent on France.
There is no real economy in those places. Zero. They cannot even be compared with the poorest Brazilians states, let alone with an economic juggernaut like São Paulo.
35% of people in those places are public servants and the rest of economy is entirely dependent on their wages, pensions, unemployment insurances. Directly and indirectly, 80%-90% of GDP comes from Paris. Unemployment is endemic.
Martinique has been part of France since 1635, several decades before the Portuguese arrived in Rio Grande do Sul. Napoleon's wife, Joséphine de Beauharnais, was from Martinique. It played a much bigger role in French history than you imagine.Martinique is part of France since 1947. 99% of French never set the foot there.
People born in Metropolitan France make up 11.9% of the population in Guadeloupe and 11.2% in Martinique (2022 census). On top of that there are White Guadeloupeans and White Martiniquans (who descend from planteur families). And there are also the children of Metropolitan Frenchmen born locally in Guadeloupe and Martinique. So all together, far more than 5%. I think 15% White would be closer to the mark.but Whites, including transient Metropolitan public servants don't surpasse 5% of population.
Martinique has been part of France since 1635, several decades before the Portuguese arrived in Rio Grande do Sul. Napoleon's wife, Joséphine de Beauharnais, was from Martinique. It played a much bigger role in French history than you imagine.
People born in Metropolitan France make up 11.9% of the population in Guadeloupe and 11.2% in Martinique (2022 census). On top of that there are White Guadeloupeans and White Martiniquans (who descend from planteur families). And there are also the children of Metropolitan Frenchmen born locally in Guadeloupe and Martinique. So all together, far more than 5%. I think 15% White would be closer to the mark.
Martinique is in America. Bad Bunny told you that, right?
It doesn't matter. Afro-American has a specific meaning that refers to a certain category of Black people in the United States. It doesn't refer to all Black people in the United States, or all Black people in the American continent(s).
LOL, the Canaries are not remotely comparable to Guyana.
The Canaries are an island of European people, near Europe. Guyana is a West Indian pan-national African-South Asian-Native identity. No one from Guyana says they're French. Go to Little Guyana in NYC, the largest expat population outside of Guyana, and ask if Guyana is France. It's a region that had three different political outcomes, due to three different colonial holdings, but it's a Guyanese identity, not French, British or Dutch.
Technically there's Spanish Guyana too, but I think Venezuela has culturally fused that region into the larger Latin American identity. But the rest is clearly West Indian.
No. Puerto Rico is declining much more. As of 2025 population estimates, Puerto Rico has now the same population it had in 1980, due to very big population decline in the past 20 years. In comparison, Martinique currently has 9.5% more inhabitants than in 1980, and Guadeloupe has 21% more inhabitants than in 1980. Their population decline has been more moderate than in Puerto Rico. The last census (2023) even showed an increase of population for Guadeloupe compared to 2022.Both are facing a very fast demographic collapse very similar to the ones of Puerto Rico and more recently, Cuba.
This is the unemployment rate in 2024 (last year available) in Guadeloupe, Martinique, Canary Islands, and Sicily according to Eurostat.Unemployment rate: 16.6% and 13.9% respectively
I would have imagined more. Social benefits in France include child benefits, and housing benefits (which are very numerous, people with lower income like students get like 200 or 300 euros per month to help pay their rent). Most French people receive social benefits in one form or another. That's the Socialist nanny state from cradle to grave.60% of Guadeloupe's population receive at least one direct social benefit.
Indeed, because Guyana has been an independent country since 1966.LOL, the Canaries are not remotely comparable to Guyana.
I'd type African and decided to Afro-American that seemed more precise. African-American is quite new on the US vocabulary and I hear it's losing favour more recently. The US doesn't own the term or the English language in any case.