Broadway Subway - Millennium Line Extension to Arbutus | U/C


Perfect @sshat response from someone named after a luxury car brand. :rolleyes:

I’m just annoyed to see people complaining about shit that inevitably coming with any development. Same goes for Pattullo Bridge etc. and regarding Lexus - at least I own one.
 
I’m just annoyed to see people complaining about shit that inevitably coming with any development. Same goes for Pattullo Bridge etc. and regarding Lexus - at least I own one.

"Invariably?" Where in the ~10 year project plan of this extension did the closure of Broadway for 4 months come up? Nowhere until late-2025.
 
"Invariably?" Where in the ~10 year project plan of this extension did the closure of Broadway for 4 months come up? Nowhere until late-2025.

It’s 10 years precisely because of all bureaucracy, laws and regulations that make it much longer to completer. Is it good or bad, I don’t really care.
 
"Invariably?" Where in the ~10 year project plan of this extension did the closure of Broadway for 4 months come up? Nowhere until late-2025.

To be fair it's probably always been in the plan as the fastest and cheapest way to rebuild the street. It's just that the public wasn't notified until it was close to happening. If the public was told from the start, there would be people complaining how it's "the end of the world that their commute is going to take a few minutes longer".

Short term pain, long term gainz.
 
To be fair it's probably always been in the plan as the fastest and cheapest way to rebuild the street. It's just that the public wasn't notified until it was close to happening. If the public was told from the start, there would be people complaining how it's "the end of the world that their commute is going to take a few minutes longer".

Short term pain, long term gainz.

It probably wasn't even the main option initially. When the budget and schedule had slack on them there was probably a plan to keep the roadway open, but to keep things in line with budget and the already revised schedule, this was probably the fall back option. Will be interesting to see what happens at the other stations.

Large projects like this are dynamic, and with time and cost pressures typically value engineering options like this occur.
 
There does appear to be sufficient time in their original schedule for the less disruptive 18 month removal process.
 
Also i'm not sure why they keep saying 4 months.

Broadway and main is one of the many stations. How are they planning to do the same thing everywhere else?

Broadway (meaning full accessibility to the whole street) will close for almost 2 years. I don't see how could be any different. Assuming an average of 4 months for every station.
Unless they give up and use the 1-lane closure for the next stations and then we are looking at 3-4 years of partial closure. But it's unlikely.
 
I think next time we just suck it up and skip the road decks. All they've done is cost the subway (and everybody else) time and money.

That'll be a tough sell for the rest of Broadway, effectively would shut down the road for years if/when UBC extension happens.
 
That'll be a tough sell for the rest of Broadway, effectively would shut down the road for years if/when UBC extension happens.

Maybe. I'd argue that a lot of Greektown's revenue already comes from foot traffic, and 10th is already (more or less) an arterial... and UBC definitely doesn't need to keep the station box/es open for the duration.
 
Also i'm not sure why they keep saying 4 months.

Broadway and main is one of the many stations. How are they planning to do the same thing everywhere else?

Broadway (meaning full accessibility to the whole street) will close for almost 2 years. I don't see how could be any different. Assuming an average of 4 months for every station.
Unless they give up and use the 1-lane closure for the next stations and then we are looking at 3-4 years of partial closure. But it's unlikely.

4 months is how long it's supposed to take each station where they rebuild the street like this, and they're doing the stations sequentially.
Which means the entire stretch is going to take a little more than a year (it's 5 stations on Broadway in total (people seem to forget that Arbutus also has to undergo the same rebuilding))

So we're looking at rolling 4 month closures running all the way up until late Spring of next year.
A year from now they should be at Granville station before they start the final stretch at Arbutus 4 months later to be done completely by early to mid-summer.
Just in time before the line is scheduled to open in the Fall.

I'm suspecting they gave themselves some elbow room with those 4 month estimates and it will take less time than that (like 3 rather than 4 months).
So it wouldn't surprise me if they're done by Spring next year instead.

I actually think they should have bitten the bullet and done them 2 stations at a time.
Bear the pain of it all and be done with everything before the end of the year.

Granted, they most likely deemed that such a strategy might have been (even) more costly to Broadway businesses on a broader scale.
 
Wasn't the alternative to use 'Cut and Cover' .....which everyone seems to think (agree?) was a terrible idea for the Canada Line construction?

Either that or make the station boxes much deeper underground. They're at pretty much the optimum depth underground to use tunnel boring between stations, but that requires going underneath Broadway directly to not affect building foundations. If they bored deeper and did underground station construction, it would be a lot more expensive.

Maybe. I'd argue that a lot of Greektown's revenue already comes from foot traffic, and 10th is already (more or less) an arterial... and UBC definitely doesn't need to keep the station box/es open for the duration.

I think we end up seeing a similar methodology applied up to Alma station and then cut and cover out to UBC. But we'll see whenever that business case comes out what they're thinking construction methodology wise.
 
4 months is how long it's supposed to take each station where they rebuild the street like this, and they're doing the stations sequentially.
Which means the entire stretch is going to take a little more than a year (it's 5 stations on Broadway in total (people seem to forget that Arbutus also has to undergo the same rebuilding))

So we're looking at rolling 4 month closures running all the way up until late Spring of next year.
A year from now they should be at Granville station before they start the final stretch at Arbutus 4 months later to be done completely by early to mid-summer.
Just in time before the line is scheduled to open in the Fall.

I'm suspecting they gave themselves some elbow room with those 4 month estimates and it will take less time than that (like 3 rather than 4 months).
So it wouldn't surprise me if they're done by Spring next year instead.

I actually think they should have bitten the bullet and done them 2 stations at a time.
Bear the pain of it all and be done with everything before the end of the year.

Granted, they most likely deemed that such a strategy might have been (even) more costly to Broadway businesses on a broader scale.

It's 4 months of total road closure and then 4 months of one lane in each way while they finish the other two lanes.

To complete this process as quickly as possible, vehicle traffic will be temporarily detoured around the block where work is taking place. After approximately four months, vehicle traffic will return to this section of Broadway with one lane in each direction for another four months as reconstruction is finished.

https://news.gov.bc.ca/releases/2025TT0110-001048
 
Wasn't the alternative to use 'Cut and Cover' .....which everyone seems to think (agree?) was a terrible idea for the Canada Line construction?

Yes, cut and cover is cheaper and faster. This version was sold as "minimal interruption", which I think has not proven out to be very accurate.
 


Back
Top