muertecaza
Active member
Rundown of the latest on the west light rail extension:
https://archive.is/nClHo#selection-917.23-921.50
https://archive.is/nClHo#selection-917.23-921.50
Rundown of the latest on the west light rail extension:
https://archive.is/nClHo#selection-917.23-921.50
https://www.abc15.com/news/local-ne...l-roadblocks-before-crucial-city-council-vote
Welp, city council voted to kill the capitol extension.
I'm thinking the 400 businesses who signed in opposed to the Indian School route is going to be a problem.
Businesses on Van Buren are opposed to the north on 7th Ave route.
Can we find a stretch of road where the inhabitants support?
Must be mentioned that they did so when faced with continued opposition from non-Phoenix state legislators.
On the one hand, it's frustrating. A lot of wasted time and resources, including potentially losing $200m in already approved federal funding. And a missed opportunity for what could have been a kickstart to improving the decrepit Capitol Mall. On the other hand, from a pure people-moving perspective, a route on Indian School is likely going to be more utilized. If we ever get there, I think it could be successful.
It's so unfortunate that this became an all-or-nothing vote on a bundle that combined the state capitol and going farther west via I-10. The residents of the nation's largest state capital city should absolutely have access to their state capitol building via light rail, but a freeway alignment makes no sense for service to Maryvale. The best option would have been to proceed with a short spur to the state capitol while simultaneously cancelling I-10 and accelerating Indian School, but no one seemed open to that idea.
So - city council now wants to study an Indian School corridor? They do realize they have to bring the rail from somewhere to Indian School - then across I-17 (for which there is already a crazy bridge over a bridge project scheduled to reduce congestion) - and then there's the nutty 3-way intersection at Grand Ave. I'm sure this will be cheaper than just going down I-10. (and will go up really fast too!)
All the attention seems to be paid to the "east valley" lawmakers who got the immediate Capitol area exempted but my connections in Valley Metro and MAG tell me the much bigger issue was the combination of pre-existing law that required a legislative committee to approve every single LR stop west of 7th Ave in the 'Capitol Mall Commission' that has been the law for years. And apparently it would have been a war figuring out every stop. Plus, I guess there was big pushback from other entities along the Adams and Washington path so they were seeing nothing but roadblocks.
All the attention seems to be paid to the "east valley" lawmakers who got the immediate Capitol area exempted but my connections in Valley Metro and MAG tell me the much bigger issue was the combination of pre-existing law that required a legislative committee to approve every single LR stop west of 7th Ave in the 'Capitol Mall Commission' that has been the law for years. And apparently it would have been a war figuring out every stop. Plus, I guess there was big pushback from other entities along the Adams and Washington path so they were seeing nothing but roadblocks.
As usual, you're quoting anonymous "someone I know" sources instead of citing verifiable evidence. The only "pre-existing law" I know of is the enabling legislation for proposition 479 passed in 2023. That law, which Governor Hobbs had to sign to get 479 on the ballot, disallowed light rail stations within certain boundaries around the capitol building and required approval of the Joint Legislative Budget Committee for any stations within the Capitol Mall. Is that what you're talking about, or are you referring to some other law that came before that? If the latter, please provide a link.
All right well let me google that for you.
In 2019, the State passed a law with that requirement. Took me 2 mins.
If the state makes the Capitol Mall a non starter than they should just build in the I-10 corridor from Central Avenue. Maybe use the 3rd/5th Ave couplet.
Who's in opposition to the I-10 alignment? I've never seen public positions.
I think the I-10 portion of the LR is perhaps the easiest pathway because it doesn't involved hundreds of constituents opposing the path.
I used to think the same but then I realized after taking light rail in San Jose that has a similar setup, that slight inconvenience is made up for with speed, especially if the bus connections are still there.
55 MPH with no stoplights is hard to argue with at the end of the day.