I went to the ALTO open house on Wednesday, Jan. 21, 2026, and I’ve taken some time to think about High-Speed Rail (HSR) and what ALTO is planning. Here are my impressions and musings:
The possible routes being considered are already fairly laid down – but displayed as ‘fuzzy’ to reduce the possibility of ‘gouging’ from property sales (Although I think that the Feds have a clause in the Major Projects legislation to prevent that.) Other route options have already been dismissed (for unknown reasons) and additional alternatives are not being accepted. There is definitely fine-tuning to be done in specific areas, but what we see is what we will be getting.
I had the feeling that the southern route between Toronto and Ottawa was the preferred one – mostly because there was potential for adding another stop later. (Not a spoken comment, but having additional population clusters is being viewed as a ‘plus’ – even though there is no stated intention of serving them.) The northern route would be slightly faster, but it would pass through more remote areas – so less future potential – and longer ‘help’ timing if something went wrong, I was told. I suspect that ALTO will have land rights around the track, so the southern routing gives it more potential revenue from future development. [I imagine that this will be similar to Federally owned airport land. The land can be developed by the airport authority – or ALTO, in this case – to generate income.]
Station locations are pretty much set for Montreal (Gare Centrale) and Toronto (Union Station) – but they are going through the show anyway. For Ottawa, there is a strong leaning towards Ottawa Station, on Tremblay. The specific tunnel routing into those larger stations remains to be finalized. [In Ottawa, a mostly segregated surface route already exists, and the RoW is likely wide enough to add additional tracks. This would be the least expensive option.]
There has not been much thought of anything but moving passengers. That is, any luggage will need to fit into the limited space provided within the cars – just like in Europe – so get used to limits on bag size. This is likely tied to not considering connections to airports, where more people would be hauling larger pieces of luggage. This also extends to having very limited space for bicycles and larger items. And, despite aiming to be a sub-hourly service, the idea of Just In Time (JIT) supply has not occurred to them. (i.e., If I need a part from Toronto fast, can someone there put it onto a train and I’ll pick it up at the station here? Such a service would be an additional revenue stream – just ask the airlines – and it could take trucks off the road – GHG-emission reduction – while improving delivery speed.) There is no current plan to have a ‘baggage car’ so that extra luggage, bikes, bulky items, and parcels could be transported. Nor is there any consideration of an overnight freight train. [Anecdote: An Amtrack train I took had a baggage car. Luggage was dropped at the ‘Baggage Desk’ upon arrival. It was put into the baggage car by staff, and unloaded at the destination. As a passenger, I was unencumbered getting to/from my seat – which made boarding and alighting much faster – and my bag was waiting on the platform among a line of bags. It was a service that made me happier, and made the station dwell time shorter.]
Some I talked to were not keen on the Laval node – specifically that all trains to and from Montreal would need to pass through Laval Station. But it seems that that configuration is, for some reason, already decided.
Stations in Toronto and Montreal will be dead-end stations. This means that all of the HS trains will need to be ‘Push-Me-Pull-You’ trains, with a cab at each end. This will limit train length to fixed proportions – and means no freight car option. We will likely be getting short (8/9-car sets, about 200 metres in length). With the described frequency, long trains will not be needed.
The prices will need to be low enough that they draw in customers who would otherwise drive or take a bus. The flight cost between Montreal and Ottawa is so out-of-line, that it in a different league. The VIA Rail price might enter into the discussion, and pulling customers from VIA Rail will likely reduce VIA Rail service to bare minimum milk-runs. Typical prices and travel times for mid-day of mid-next-week are: VIA Rail = $62, 2h4; TourExpress bus = $35, 2h; drive = $15, 2h; Air Canada Jazz = $808, 0h52 + airport time. So, I expect that a Montreal to Ottawa ticket will run about $45-50. This likely means that the trains will be outfitted as higher density vehicles, similar to the OUIGO, in France to minimize the cost per passenger. There will be no way that the train will be price competitive with driving (unless there are high parking fees at the destination), especially if there is more than one person in the car. Marketing to drivers will need to be on speed and being productive.
Speed will be important, but seems to be a secondary issue, as far as I can tell. It seems as if it is perfectly acceptable to travel from, say, Ottawa Station to a station in Laval; then turn and follow a tunnel to Gare Centrale, in downtown Montreal. So, 10-15 minutes slowly leaving Ottawa; 6 minutes accelerating to speed + 30 minutes at speed to Laval + 6 minutes decelerating + 10 minutes at Laval Station + 10-15 minutes of slower travel in the tunnel to Gare Centrale; for a trip time of about 60 minutes. The time that is being advertised, but it could be faster. The same will be true when the southern route is officially selected, between Toronto and Ottawa. The straighter, northern, route would be faster, but it seems to be being downplayed as “more challenging to build because it runs across Canadian Shield – which is rock and swamps – in more remote areas.”
Second, fairly close, stations in a metropolitan are not unheard of. The trains heading to Roma Termini, from the north, stop at Roma Tiburtina, too, and it is only about 5 kilometres before Roma Termini. Laval is about 13 kilometres from Gare Centrale. {meaning that there will likely be a tunnel that is almost 13 kilometres in length. (So about $1.3B, based on 2 X 13-km bores of 7.5-m @ $50M/km of tunnel.)