Winnipeg Construction XI


Owners of parking lots will build something when there is something profitable to build. If i build a building and no one rents space i go bankrupt. Thats not good for anyone.

There is some truth to that, but in my experience there are properties that sit - unavailable (i.e. not for sale) that owners have no intention or willingness to develop. But there are developers out there that want properties and will develop them if they can acquire them.

Recent examples of this would be the Maws Garage, 138 Portage. These are developers that want to make something work where others haven't been able to have success.

But, you need 2 willing parties for these kinds of deals. I am fairly confident in saying Winnipeg has more unwilling parties than willing ones when it comes to selling underused properties to developers who want to build.
 
However, the sea of parking lots around Calvary Temple is particularly puzzling and distressing. When the strip of commercial buildings on Notre Dame was demolished a few years ago to create more *new* parking, many were surprised to learn that this area was technically outside of the downtown zoning bylaw area. I'm sure C.T. does want a better Winnipeg overall. But the effect of this action is a stark, empty streetscape on the edge of the Exchange. These huge parking lots are empty 6 days of the week, and do nothing to improve the social fabric. I can't believe all that new parking was really needed to make their church viable, as they seemed to get on well for years before with the many other nearby surface lots.

This is being very disingenuous. Yes, a single story building on Notre Dame was demolished and a new parking lot was created, but that is heavily ignoring the fact the new parking lot was to replace an existing parking lot that was needed to build a new electrical substation. That same substation was needed to support the continued growth of both downtown and the Exchange.

Would it have been preferable to you to have the multi floor building on King gutted and made it a substation as was originally purposed? Or perhaps we you would rather have had all development in downtown and the Exchange stopped as the electrical grid was maxed out.

Hard truth is that development needs things like utilities and while they aren't sexy they are essential. The overall change to the area where Calvary Temple is minimal and overall neutral and maybe a long term positive. Surface parking lots are essentially free spaces on the bingo card. When the right proposal comes along with the right amount of money to make something happen there it will happen. Until then its best to let the parking lot be for the greater good of downtown and the Exchange. Losing a shop selling industrial equipment in the Exchange is not a really significant loss for the area.
 
There is some truth to that, but in my experience there are properties that sit - unavailable (i.e. not for sale) that owners have no intention or willingness to develop. But there are developers out there that want properties and will develop them if they can acquire them.

It seems fairly simple. If you own a basic single family home in Winnipeg with an assessed value of $300,000 and you see the functional value as $1 million if someone offers you $100,000 you aren't going to sell. Now if that same person offers you $10 million you might be a lot more interested to sell and if that offer became $100 million it is almost certain you would sell.

It is the same for vacant commercial lots. Everything is for sale for the right price and the right terms.

Take Calvary Temple and they surface lots. If someone came along and said in trade for all the surface lots they would build a multi-level parking structure there that would maintain the same number of parking spots and Calvary Temple would have full control, use and ownership of the structure plus there would be a significant payment with the deal the properties would likely change hands. The reality is that land is not valuable enough to anyone else right now for them to make an acceptable proposal. Hard truth is when Hydro came wanting to develop one of those same surface lots they put forward a proposal that saw one of the lots get developed.
 
The church I'm a member of has no parking lot. A very small one for accessible parking. We park elsewhere, such as on the street. That's how it is. Why does Calvary need uber sized parking lot? Just because.
 
I would disagree with the idea that owners of parking lots are the reason down town is blighted. As I have mentioned previously, development occurs when there is a likelihood of long term profit on capital invested.

I keep coming back to the St Regis / CV site sitting dormant with no current prospect for development. An existing structure was demolished and no parking is allowed on the site. It is not developable currently in these conditions. With government intervention it could be developed similar to the site across from City Hall, North Portage or The Bay. I view them as all worthy projects but not viable privately…

As for safety, there is no way development is happening on Waterfront with the current social issues. That is not the fault of the building or parking lot owners.

This forum does not function well in a vacuum or echo chamber. Comments from parties like ours add views which enriches dialogue and creates thoughtful perspectives. Most downtown building owners are parking lot owners as well. They own them because they are needed to rent out their buildings. The largest parking lot owners in the city are The Richardsons, The Province of Manitoba, GreatWest Life and Calvery Temple. They all want a better Winnipeg, as do I.

Yeah, Canada Life and Calvary own massive, self-serving surface lots but I don't think fingers can be pointed at the Richardsons or the Province.

The Richardsons only have one large surface lot left and they recently just gifted it to the GATE project, so that lot will be developed once that project gets going.

The Province really only has one massive eyesore of a lot in the Workers Compensation Board lot behind its building on Broadway. I recall reading that the former NDP government floated the idea of selling that lot for development but the WCB's union freaked out so the plan died.
 
This is being very disingenuous. Yes, a single story building on Notre Dame was demolished and a new parking lot was created, but that is heavily ignoring the fact the new parking lot was to replace an existing parking lot that was needed to build a new electrical substation. That same substation was needed to support the continued growth of both downtown and the Exchange.

Would it have been preferable to you to have the multi floor building on King gutted and made it a substation as was originally purposed? Or perhaps we you would rather have had all development in downtown and the Exchange stopped as the electrical grid was maxed out.

Hard truth is that development needs things like utilities and while they aren't sexy they are essential. The overall change to the area where Calvary Temple is minimal and overall neutral and maybe a long term positive. Surface parking lots are essentially free spaces on the bingo card. When the right proposal comes along with the right amount of money to make something happen there it will happen. Until then its best to let the parking lot be for the greater good of downtown and the Exchange. Losing a shop selling industrial equipment in the Exchange is not a really significant loss for the area.

No, not disingenuous, but yes, I should have mentioned this was part of scheme hatched with Hydro. What's disingenuous is calling this "a single story building'. It was, in fact, an amalgamation of four commercial buildings (including a two story building) along Notre Dame (see Bellamy's FP article below). See photos here: https://winnipegarchitecture.ca/places/312-318-notre-dame-avenue/

This was a strip of storefronts that provided a continuous pedestrian oriented streetscape along Notre Dame at the very entrance to the Exchange. Now, there is a windswept underused parking lot. A bad trade off, IMHO.

I'm all in favour of Hydro building a new substation to serve the Exchange and downtown, but more care could have been exercised in siting the station and demolishing buildings. I agree with you that their first idea to gut an historical building for this was terrible.

https://www.winnipegfreepress.com/business/2015/04/13/the-sneaky-parking-lot-plot
 
I would disagree with the idea that owners of parking lots are the reason down town is blighted. As I have mentioned previously, development occurs when there is a likelihood of long term profit on capital invested.

I keep coming back to the St Regis / CV site sitting dormant with no current prospect for development. An existing structure was demolished and no parking is allowed on the site. It is not developable currently in these conditions. With government intervention it could be developed similar to the site across from City Hall, North Portage or The Bay. I view them as all worthy projects but not viable privately…

As for safety, there is no way development is happening on Waterfront with the current social issues. That is not the fault of the building or parking lot owners.

This forum does not function well in a vacuum or echo chamber. Comments from parties like ours add views which enriches dialogue and creates thoughtful perspectives. Most downtown building owners are parking lot owners as well. They own them because they are needed to rent out their buildings. The largest parking lot owners in the city are The Richardsons, The Province of Manitoba, GreatWest Life and Calvery Temple. They all want a better Winnipeg, as do I.

I think most of us on this forum appreciate your perspective. There are just a few voices on here that complain a lot / are frustrated with the slow pace of change. I agree that we do not want this forum to become an eco chamber.
 
I would disagree with the idea that owners of parking lots are the reason down town is blighted. As I have mentioned previously, development occurs when there is a likelihood of long term profit on capital invested.

Well, first of all I can't agree with words like "blighted". Downtown Winnipeg isn't Gary, Indiana or East St. Louis, Illinois, and sensational adjectives really don't help the discussion.

There seems to be a general consensus among most urban designers that an excessive number of surface parking lots create "dead zones" disrupts streetscapes, and inhibits pedestrian activity, which in turn inhibit economic development.

Can one separate lot ownership from the effects of their lots? I suppose it depends on the owner. I don't doubt there are a number of lot owners who need their lots but would like to see an opportunity for development, but I'm also just as sure there are lot owners who simply don't give a rat's ass about the downtown, as long as the cheques keep coming in from their property



I keep coming back to the St Regis / CV site sitting dormant with no current prospect for development. An existing structure was demolished and no parking is allowed on the site. It is not developable currently in these conditions. With government intervention it could be developed similar to the site across from City Hall, North Portage or The Bay. I view them as all worthy projects but not viable privately…

I think we'd have to go back and look at the history of this site and it's proposed development. Please correct me if I'm wrong, but from what I remember, the St. Regis lot was sold and it's building demolished because a supposed developer promised building a huge apartment complex. After the St. Regis was torn down, the proposal changed to a 4-storey parkade. After that was rejected by CV, the "developer' disappeared, or gave back the property of whatever, and we have yet another empty lot. Not knowing the developer or their financial statements I can't speak to the integrity of their original proposal, but from the outside it certainly looks similar to several other "big" developments that started with developer promises and went no-where.

As for safety, there is no way development is happening on Waterfront with the current social issues. That is not the fault of the building or parking lot owners.

I don't see vast parking lots along Waterfront drive, so i'm not sure how this relates to the discussion. I agree that there are social issues that desperately need to be addressed.

This forum does not function well in a vacuum or echo chamber. Comments from parties like ours add views which enriches dialogue and creates thoughtful perspectives. Most downtown building owners are parking lot owners as well. They own them because they are needed to rent out their buildings. The largest parking lot owners in the city are The Richardsons, The Province of Manitoba, GreatWest Life and Calvery Temple. They all want a better Winnipeg, as do I.

So who's asking for an echo chamber? You're previous statement was extremely broad, vague and, IMO, a bit defensive. I'm glad you provided this more comprehensive answer, as you make a number of good points. I think it's important to get a variety of perspectives, but I think we have to realize all we tend to be heroes in our own narratives. I'm glad we can disagree and keep it civil.
 
Let's be totally upfront here, the Government felt pressured to do something about the perception of issues downtown. They viewed St Regis as being one of the hot spots the issues were originating from. When they had an opportunity to close the beverage room they jumped on it. Then they fell victim to a scam and demolished the property.

As less than idea as the property was those rooms would likely be welcome today to help with the issues around accessible for affordable housing.
 
Clearly this is NOT an echo chamber. There are plenty of divergent views, and sound arguments (as can be noted with PSPEID).
There are some basic truths we can probably agree upon:
1) unless there is a social/community benefit driving a development, development happens when it is economically beneficial...TO THE DEVELOPER.
2) ground level parking lots prevent street level social interaction
3) a lack of street level interaction creates a vacuum in which less desirable activity can happen
4) crime and other socially negative activity has a negative impact on positive social activity
5) this becomes a further disincentive for development as it will be perceived to be financially risky.
6) Development has to be more attractive that NOT developing - ie leaving a lot empty.

If you give a mouse a cookie...

Where do you start? Perhaps closing Graham was considered a strategy for creating social interaction. Unfortunately, with so little organic activity in the area, and kind of half baked execution, that won't do the trick...and it isn't really even a good start.
There is only one way...create an economic environment that will make development of the lots attractive and will create an urban neighbourhood that is safe and socially attractive. Look no further than the renders for the UofM community. THAT is what downtown should be like! Waterfront has that vibe. The area around Assiniboine Ave has that vibe. OV certainly has that vibe. And Railside will have that vibe. Now focus on the blocks from Graham to York (including St Regis) and Donald to Fort. And reimagine as a downtown neighbourhood.
 
While I would agree with you on the majority of it, IMO, the south side of Waterfront is doing well and always bustling with activity. Waterfront between Pacific and McDermott has never been busier, although it could still do better (Looking at you, empty CRU's underneath The Bend) The redevelopment of the Alexander Docks will make that even better.

Waterfront North has a lot of promise and interest, but like you said, until societal changes are made, that place will stay frozen in time.
 
Bonivital Pool Renewal Completed

Bonivital Pool Renewal
Location: 1215 Archibald Street
Developer: The City of Winnipeg
Architect: LM Architectural Group
Status: Completed - Fall 2025
Documents: Award of Contract
Media: Supporting pool enhancements at Bonivital- Our Communities
Description: The Bonivital Pool renovation in Winnipeg that straddles the wards of St. Boniface & St. Vital includes a comprehensive upgrade to modernize the facility and enhance accessibility. The scope of work involves:
  • Accessibility Improvements: Addition of universal changerooms and barrier-free access to ensure compliance with modern accessibility standards.
  • New Features: Installation of a new sauna and steam room to enhance user experience.
  • Mechanical and Electrical Upgrades: Updates to HVAC systems, electrical systems, and other mechanical components to improve energy efficiency and functionality.
  • Interior and Structural Enhancements: Renovations to the pool area, including new tiling, decking, and interior finishes, along with structural improvements to extend the facilitys lifespan.
  • Sustainability Focus: Incorporation of energy-efficient systems and materials to align with environmental goals.
  • Safety and Code Compliance: Upgrades to meet current building codes, including fire safety and water treatment systems.
The project, valued at approximately $6,9 million, aims to address aging infrastructure (originally built in 1976) while improving community access and user comfort. The renovation began in summer 2024 and is expected to be completed by fall 2025
54569907282_776da3b930_c.jpg

1769036570367-e-1770854400-v-beta-t-Jn-Kv-Q1k03gp-Wvi-T5tcm-Fx-FYL6h-b-Xd-H2cx-M4hazq3LM.jpg


1769036570432-e-1770854400-v-beta-t-tvdus-U9Cm-ORP0E6Z7LSt7Glon7u-I2O575NGyjn2m-X-8.jpg


1769036570322-e-1770854400-v-beta-t-a-Ty9b3f-R4X4PL6r-B92Mzo-QJF4st26M9LPDqdq-Eu-Y3t-Q.jpg


1769036570612-e-1770854400-v-beta-t-XD4Ao0BMkyl-ONMt-Ol-ZTpt-P233AOur1e-U-p-XCf3HK5y-U.jpg


1769036570674-e-1770854400-v-beta-t-rz-Cat-Wkat0q-Rdsb-Y6PKak-NU-PX7Kcss-OMgq-D0r-X10B4.jpg


1769036570594-e-1770854400-v-beta-t-n-As-ZCUYv0y-F6o-Fc-NTQEDy9WXYPW-LHd4Kx52k-E4fck.jpg


Bonivital-Pool-Webspread-rgb2-2048x774.jpg


Bonivital-Pool-Webspread-rgb3-2048x774.jpg


Bonivital-Pool-Webspread-rgb4-2048x774.jpg
 
Clearly this is NOT an echo chamber. There are plenty of divergent views, and sound arguments (as can be noted with PSPEID).
There are some basic truths we can probably agree upon:
1) unless there is a social/community benefit driving a development, development happens when it is economically beneficial...TO THE DEVELOPER.
2) ground level parking lots prevent street level social interaction

Agree as long as we also agree parking for passenger vehicles is also necessary to generate street level social interaction. AKA parking at street level can be move above grade or below grade but still needs to exist.

3) a lack of street level interaction creates a vacuum in which less desirable activity can happen

Definitely not in full agreement here. Less desirable activities find ways to be near places but not be seen from street level interactions.

4) crime and other socially negative activity has a negative impact on positive social activity

Strongly disagree see CLC, Burt and more recently TNS. All bringing positive social activity to the same general area that has had some of the most challenging things in Winnipeg happening, ie see St Regis one block from CLC.

5) this becomes a further disincentive for development as it will be perceived to be financially risky.

Again strongly disagree. Just to shortlist a couple things CLC, Hydro Place and TNS all happened downtown knowing all the social challenges happening in the area. The ongoing improvements and reuse of the Walker/Burt is another example.

6) Development has to be more attractive that NOT developing - ie leaving a lot empty.

First, there are near zero truly empty lots in downtown, the Exchange and adjacent areas. Further, surface parking lots are a future development opportunity. Take the lot opposite the Police HQ on Graham. In the 80s it was a low rise building and being actively used. It got demolished to make way for a planned redevelopment. That ended up falling through. It has since been proposed to be developed a few times. Similar story for the surface lot at St Marys and Edmonton. Lakeview, who owns the lot, has made public proposals a few times about building a hotel on the site. As it has yet to happen those proposals may have been looking for investors to come forward with some money.

Further, when Hydro Place was in the proposal stage just about every surface parking lot in downtown submitted a plan on how their site could be home to Hydro Place. This shows when the right proposal happens owners of the surface lots are open to developing them.

Where do you start? Perhaps closing Graham was considered a strategy for creating social interaction. Unfortunately, with so little organic activity in the area, and kind of half baked execution, that won't do the trick...and it isn't really even a good start.

Some easy changes there, do something to encourage the food trucks to come back downtown and use Graham. Put out tables for people to sit and eat lunches from there. Put different outdoor friendly games for people to interact with. Improve the lighting, for example look at lighting that was done in the lane behind the Portage Ave Dollorama. I think there was more planned for that project but the Pandemic killed that.


There is only one way...create an economic environment that will make development of the lots attractive and will create an urban neighbourhood that is safe and socially attractive. Look no further than the renders for the UofM community. THAT is what downtown should be like!

That project is still very early on. While I have hopes in turns out the way it is being envisioned I think the Southland project at U of M is not going to meet expectations and ultimately will just be more apartment buildings near campus with minimum street level activity.
 


Back
Top