Clearly this is NOT an echo chamber. There are plenty of divergent views, and sound arguments (as can be noted with PSPEID).
There are some basic truths we can probably agree upon:
1) unless there is a social/community benefit driving a development, development happens when it is economically beneficial...TO THE DEVELOPER.
2) ground level parking lots prevent street level social interaction
Agree as long as we also agree parking for passenger vehicles is also necessary to generate street level social interaction. AKA parking at street level can be move above grade or below grade but still needs to exist.
3) a lack of street level interaction creates a vacuum in which less desirable activity can happen
Definitely not in full agreement here. Less desirable activities find ways to be near places but not be seen from street level interactions.
4) crime and other socially negative activity has a negative impact on positive social activity
Strongly disagree see CLC, Burt and more recently TNS. All bringing positive social activity to the same general area that has had some of the most challenging things in Winnipeg happening, ie see St Regis one block from CLC.
5) this becomes a further disincentive for development as it will be perceived to be financially risky.
Again strongly disagree. Just to shortlist a couple things CLC, Hydro Place and TNS all happened downtown knowing all the social challenges happening in the area. The ongoing improvements and reuse of the Walker/Burt is another example.
6) Development has to be more attractive that NOT developing - ie leaving a lot empty.
First, there are near zero truly
empty lots in downtown, the Exchange and adjacent areas. Further, surface parking lots are a future development opportunity. Take the lot opposite the Police HQ on Graham. In the 80s it was a low rise building and being actively used. It got demolished to make way for a planned redevelopment. That ended up falling through. It has since been proposed to be developed a few times. Similar story for the surface lot at St Marys and Edmonton. Lakeview, who owns the lot, has made public proposals a few times about building a hotel on the site. As it has yet to happen those proposals may have been looking for investors to come forward with some money.
Further, when Hydro Place was in the proposal stage just about every surface parking lot in downtown submitted a plan on how their site could be home to Hydro Place. This shows when the right proposal happens owners of the surface lots are open to developing them.
Where do you start? Perhaps closing Graham was considered a strategy for creating social interaction. Unfortunately, with so little organic activity in the area, and kind of half baked execution, that won't do the trick...and it isn't really even a good start.
Some easy changes there, do something to encourage the food trucks to come back downtown and use Graham. Put out tables for people to sit and eat lunches from there. Put different outdoor friendly games for people to interact with. Improve the lighting, for example look at lighting that was done in the lane behind the Portage Ave Dollorama. I think there was more planned for that project but the Pandemic killed that.
There is only one way...create an economic environment that will make development of the lots attractive and will create an urban neighbourhood that is safe and socially attractive. Look no further than the renders for the UofM community. THAT is what downtown should be like!
That project is still very early on. While I have hopes in turns out the way it is being envisioned I think the Southland project at U of M is not going to meet expectations and ultimately will just be more apartment buildings near campus with minimum street level activity.