Four decades, three bilateral agreements, two withdrawals, and today? Singapore Airlines no longer flies to Canada at all.
Here's the full story of how SIA spent 40 years fighting for the Great White North - and still lost.
For four decades, Singapore Airlines’ attempts to establish a foothold in Canada have been marked by political brinkmanship, broken promises, PR wars, veiled threats, last-minute deals signed in the small hours of the morning, and not one but two complete withdrawals from the market.
Along the way there have been full-page newspaper advertisements accusing Canada of cowardice, allegations of stolen passengers, a multi-million dollar flight simulator contract caught in the crossfire, and an air services agreement so one-sided that industry insiders dubbed it “a pig in a poke”.
Here’s the full story of Singapore Airlines’ turbulent relationship with the Great White North, a saga spanning 40 years, three bilateral agreements, and countless rounds of negotiations.
It all dates back to 1983
To fully appreciate the story of SIA’s Canada flights, you have to go back to 1983, long before the carrier actually flew there.
Singapore had been trying to get Canada to negotiate an air services agreement for years before Ottawa finally came to the table in late 1983. The first round of talks was held in Ottawa in September that year, followed by a second round in Singapore from 24th to 27th January 1984.
The outcome of that four-day meeting seemed promising.
On paper, the bilateral agreement initialled by the two countries in January 1984 offered something for everyone: Singapore Airlines, Air Canada, and Canadian Pacific would all be permitted to operate direct services between Singapore and Canada, with unlimited traffic rights, including fifth freedom approvals for the necessary stopovers.
Air Canada could fly to Singapore via a transatlantic route, Canadian Pacific via the Pacific, and Singapore Airlines could go in either direction.
But the devil was in the details – and those details would prove devilish indeed.
“A pig in a poke” – not the best agreement for Singapore
Canada at the time operated under a “divided world” aviation policy dating back more than a decade, which carved up international routes between its two major carriers. Air Canada got most of the Atlantic routes; Canadian Pacific, as its name suggests, got the Pacific side.
Singapore, strategically located at one of the few places where Air Canada and Canadian Pacific’s territories effectively overlapped, agreed to match SIA’s traffic rights to the services offered by the two Canadian airlines, in the apparent belief that Canada’s divided world policy would soon be scrapped, or at least redrafted.
This would prove to be a costly mistake.
The 1984 agreement meant Singapore Airlines was placed under a web of restrictions. On the North Atlantic, SIA could fly to Toronto, but only if it operated via Montreal’s Mirabel Airport, a condition the airline considered economically unviable.
The airline was also barred from operating in the Atlantic direction via Greece, Italy or the Netherlands – those were Canadian Pacific territory, not Air Canada routes – while the British Government refused SIA “fifth freedom” traffic rights between London and Toronto.
On the Pacific, SIA could in theory serve Vancouver via Tokyo or Hong Kong, seen as the most lucrative intermediate stopover points, but was barred from doing so until Canadian Pacific began its own Singapore service – and Canadian Pacific showed little urgency to do so.
Meanwhile, the idea that the restrictive policy would be relaxed any time soon failed to materialise.
As industry sources would later put it, Singapore had bought “a pig in a poke”.