Truenorth00
New member
At some point we're going to have start discussing getting new LRVs that are actual long trains and built for our climate.
At some point we're going to have start discussing getting new LRVs that are actual long trains and built for our climate.
Hopefully if we build Stage 3, we'll be looking for new trains.
This is the weakness of PPPs. The consortium assumes some risks but needs to make money too. So, there is reluctance to dump barrels of money to fix the design of the trains. So, will the flaws of the train design be fully resolved? I doubt it. The possibility of replacing the trains with a compatible model is unlikely if it increases overall costs. Going to high floor trains or a light metro is out of the question, because of the cost of the new trains and retrofitting the entire line and the years of service interruptions.
As I recall, the rolling stock industry was consulted fairly early in the process and they were unanimous in their recommendation that the city should use light metro vehicles. The city insisted on using trams that were not suited for this use. I am not sure a PPP is to blame.
As I recall, the rolling stock industry was consulted fairly early in the process and they were unanimous in their recommendation that the city should use light metro vehicles. The city insisted on using trams that were not suited for this use. I am not sure a PPP is to blame.
Yes. I attended some of the public consultations. Distinctly remember several suggesting that Ottawa use light metros given the passenger volumes and frequencies being considered. The idea to use light rail was because Ottawa wanted a hybrid operation with street running in the suburbs. But that idea died after the VIA bus crash. Then they went fully segregated and grade separated across the system. But kept the Light Rail requirement since design was already underway. Would also add that the previous LRT plan probably added some anchoring bias.
Back then so much of the public genuinely questioned if Ottawa even needed rail transport.
The idea died before the VIA bus crash. The decision to fully grade-separate Stage 2 (and beyond) was made months before the crash happened, and ironically, the decision was made entirely because of concerns about the would-be capacity of a system with grade crossings which was obviously raised beforehand. The 2013 TMP, which included an at-grade Carling tram anyway, was approved in the months following the VIA crash. The timeline just doesn't add up.
It never had anything to do with the VIA crash, it wouldn't make sense even if it did, and I hope some day we'll stop seeing people cite that as a cause because it was not at all related.
Rhetorical question, but did we pick LRT because that is what Calgary and Edmonton have and they are easily to most comparable cities? Ignoring the fact that their systems launched what.. 30 years prior?
I thought our system could be turned to automated/driverless fairly easily, no?
They have also been accepted by Metrolinx. But remember, Ottawa has been the testing ground for the new trains for, what, five-and-a-half years now. Apart from the Wheel Bearing Assembly, all of the other big issues (that we know of) have been corrected. If the bogie gets a redesign (Now that others are using the vehicle, there might be more pressure on Alstom to do the redesign.) the Citadis Spirit should be quite a good light rail vehicle.With all these problems and some with no clear solutions, I find it odd that Quebec City is getting the same trains for their tramway.
They have also been accepted by Metrolinx. But remember, Ottawa has been the testing ground for the new trains for, what, five-and-a-half years now. Apart from the Wheel Bearing Assembly, all of the other big issues (that we know of) have been corrected. If the bogie gets a redesign (Now that others are using the vehicle, there might be more pressure on Alstom to do the redesign.) the Citadis Spirit should be quite a good light rail vehicle.