• City-versus-city activity is flat-out banned from being posted here in all its forms.

    City vs city trolling sets up a rather nasty and personal fight between forumers from one place and forumers from another place, potentially affecting hundreds of members any time it breaks out. Nothing good comes of versus-trolling, but long after the insults and mockery have been removed, bad feelings between individuals and between groups tend to linger, oftentimes popping up in unrelated threads for months afterwards.

    Thus, when it comes to 'versus' trolling, a line must be drawn--sharply. Anyone who crosses that line shall be disciplined, up to and including suspension and even summary banishment without warning. Forum moderation and administration shall be the arbiter of what constitutes versus-trolling, so if you think your post might be perceived as an unfair attack on an entire city that will upset residents there, tread lightly or reconsider how you intend to express your opinion. No forumer shall successfully claim ignorance of our policy against versus trolling, and no forumer should believe he can get away with it.

    The ban on versus activity applies to all posts and all threads, even ones that are not initially set up as city-versus-city.

    If you see any troublesome posts please report them using the "report a post" icon -
    report.gif
    in the upper right corner of every post on the forum.

Great Lakes Cities


Pennsylvania and Minnesota really dropped the ball by being the only Great Lakes states/provinces to not have a +1 million person metro on the Great Lakes coastline.
 
Great Lakes shoreline (statute miles):

Ontario 5,127
Michigan 3,288
Wisconsin 820
New York 473
Ohio 312
Minnesota 189
Illinois 63
Pennsylvania 51
Indiana 45
 
All of the UAs over 50,000 people that are either directly on one of the great lakes, or one of their connecting waterways.



Lake Michigan:

Chicago: 8,671,746
Milwaukee: 1,306,795
Green Bay: 224,156
Muskegon: 166,414
Racine: 134,877
Kenosha: 125,865
Holland: 107,034
Sheboygan: 74,369
Michigan City: 71,367
Benton Harbor: 61,888
Traverse City: 56,890



Lake Erie:

Detroit: 3,776,890
Cleveland: 1,712,178
Buffalo: 948,864
Toledo: 497,952
Windsor: 306,519
Lorain: 199,067
Erie: 187,820
Welland: 69,302
Sandusky: 61,743
Monroe: 57,260



Lake Ontario:

Toronto: 5,647,656
Hamilton: 729,560
Rochester: 704,327
Oshawa: 335,949
St. Catharines–Niagara: 242,460
Kingston: 127,943
Belleville: 75,052
Bowmanville: 56,742



Lake Superior:

Duluth: 119,411
Thunder Bay: 95,266
Sault Ste. Mare: 64,923



Lake Huron:

Port Huron: 82,226
Sarnia: 73,944
Bay City: 68,472
 
Steely, thanks for that list. It's nice to see the population distribution by Great Lake.

For Canada we'll have to wait for the 2026 census to see updated population centre/"urbanized area" numbers. Population estimates for municipality, region, CMA come out yearly, but as far as I'm aware the population centre numbers are only calculated every 5 years during Canada's census as the boundaries have to be updated.
 
Toronto, Hamilton, & Oshawa are really one urban area, but are separated due to Statcan's quirk of never combining established CMAs (or urban areas) even after they've grown into each other.
 
Toronto, Hamilton, & Oshawa are really one urban area, but are separated due to Statcan's quirk of never combining established CMAs (or urban areas) even after they've grown into each other.

^To be fair, he also listed Kenosha and Racine as separate from Chicago, even though they are contiguous.

***

If we counted separate UAs that were physically conjoined, we might have a 4th metro region for Lake Huron! Collingwood (pop. 25,786 in 2021) + Wasaga Beach (pop. 24,862) sprawl into each other and are over 50,000 now.
 
Toronto, Hamilton, & Oshawa are really one urban area, but are separated due to Statcan's quirk of never combining established CMAs (or urban areas) even after they've grown into each other.

The Greater Toronto Area (GTA) is more known in everyday speech anyway and includes Oshawa. Toronto-Hamilton is sort of borderline. It's been among Ontario's largest cities since the 19th century and has a TV station (one of the few independent ones left), a CFL team and a long-established university. A lot do commute into the GTA, but that's largely to neighboring Burlington.

Oshawa seems comparable to maybe Joliet or Aurora. Not sure what a US analogue to Hamilton is.
 
I'll just say, I've always thought it was strange that Michigan, arguably the Great Lakes state, doesn't really have any large/medium-sized cities on a Great Lake. The largest is...*checks notes*...Muskegon. That's not even a Duluth or Erie (PA) sized city. Detroit barely touches the bastard bitch lake, Lake St. Clair, but that's about it.

Strange.
 
I'll just say, I've always thought it was strange that Michigan, arguably the Great Lakes state, doesn't really have any large/medium-sized cities on a Great Lake. The largest is...*checks notes*...Muskegon. That's not even a Duluth or Erie (PA) sized city. Detroit barely touches the bastard bitch lake, Lake St. Clair, but that's about it.

Strange.

Detroit is already located at one of the most critical nexus points in the Great Lakes system. What would be the strategic advantage of another major city?
 
Detroit is already located at one of the most critical nexus points in the Great Lakes system. What would be the strategic advantage of another major city?

I meant historically. For example, Traverse City or Muskegon could've been a Rochester, Toledo, or Buffalo-sized city for ***insert weird Michigan fact here***. You don't think it's bizarre that Michigan, the Great Lakes state, never developed a mid/large-ish city on a Great Lake?
 
Toronto, Hamilton, & Oshawa are really one urban area, but are separated due to Statcan's quirk of never combining established CMAs (or urban areas) even after they've grown into each other.

I'm glad for that "quirk"
Hamilton really doesn't want to be seen as a Toronto suburb/exurb. It has its own identity as the former manufacturing powerhouse and still steelmaking capital of Canada. People like the uniqueness, distinctiveness, the slightly rougher edges/reputation of Hamilton.

That's hard for some Torontonians to grasp.
 
I meant historically. For example, Traverse City or Muskegon could've been a Rochester, Toledo, or Buffalo-sized city for ***insert weird Michigan fact here***. You don't think it's bizarre that Michigan, the Great Lakes state, never developed a mid/large-ish city on a Great Lake?

Detroit is located on a strait, not a tributary, so it kind of seems like splitting hairs to say there's no major Michigan city on the lakes. It's also located in just about the absolute most strategic location to reach the Atlantic Ocean from the state of Michigan by water. I don't see a good reason why there would be another major port city in Michigan?
 


Back
Top