I assume rentals (aside from being maintenance heavy) are a better bet financially in the long run although condos probably make cash back quicker, less risky for renters too.
If Mack's building won't happen anytime soon I'm guessing Mitsui won't either unless there is a special reason to build it.
Rental buildings are considered less risky and are preferred by developers and investors for two main reasons:
- Defect liability: the developer is responsible for construction defects for 10 years. This has created an entire cottage industry of lawyers who go to HOAs 7-9 years after a condo building is built and convince them to sue the developer. This typically happens even if the condos were very well built - they just find a bunch of random things to throw at the developer, and they end up settling in court. For this reason, developers have to hold back cash for 10 years or buy expensive insurance against these claims.
- Market timing: if you build a rental building and it opens during a bad market period, fine, you just rent it out at whatever rate you can, push rental rates up when the market recovers, then sell the building. But if you open a condo building during a bad market period you get crushed since you only have one shot to sell the units. And you can't just hold on to the units in hopes of better future pricing since you have a loan, property taxes, insurance, maintenance, etc. that you need to cover.