Edmonton Construction Part 14 (October 2023)


The rec center comment was expressed because it is a small piece of the question- what are the priorities of this city administration? Overspending on certain items while basic infrastructure is not addressed? Good questions to ask the candidates in the upcoming civic election an election I think is very important.
 
Does it?

Yup, our civic buildings better look good considering they are being funded with tax dollars.

Private industry usually builds as cheap as possible, which leads to VE and even just generally poor designs. I couldn't imagine how bad things would be if we didnt have the Edmonton Design Committee.
 
Does it?

Yup, our civic buildings better look good considering they are being funded with tax dollars.

Private industry usually builds as cheap as possible, which leads to VE and even just generally poor designs. I couldn't imagine how bad things would be if we didnt have the Edmonton Design Committee.

Do they now? That's a pretty broad brush no?:sly:

Rents are low in this town, prices the same and costs relatively high.

It's a tough game to make things work and move projects forward.

I'd argue that most major infill in Central Edmonton is good, but reflective of a restrictive revenue generation environment.
 
^ I have travelled extensively across many countries...I have to agree that in general, our privately owned buildings in Edmonton lack when it comes to architecture/design. There seems to be a huge time gap between what gets built these days and the quality of design / attractiveness in what we see around town vs. newly built/designed office buildings or residential in other cities.

I am not an expert in real estate, but these are my own observations.

I get it - trades get paid too much money compared to other countries. But for a metro of 1.6 or 1.7 million, it's kind of disappointing.
 
I am not an expert in real-estate either but it seems like most developers don't really care about Edmonton or have strong feelings to make their projects special. It's just the same 4 walls and a roof. Slap something together with the goal of making the most money with the least effort.
 
Is Edmonton 'affordable' or 'cheap'?

If you can generate $1000/sqft for condos or $5 rents, you can do A LOT.

Explain Winnipeg then, rents even cheaper than Edmonton, yet I'd say their private industry has generally built better-designed buildings.

I think having a School of Architecture helps, something we lack here.
 
screenshot-2025-09-11-at-9-17-13%E2%80%AFam-png.680346
 
I am not an expert in real-estate either but it seems like most developers don't really care about Edmonton or have strong feelings to make their projects special. It's just the same 4 walls and a roof. Slap something together with the goal of making the most money with the least effort.

x2

Is Edmonton 'affordable' or 'cheap'?

If you can generate $1000/sqft for condos or $5 rents, you can do A LOT.

I mean, cheap product makes for a cheap city. Is Edmonton some Canadian anomaly as the only place with sky high construction costs paired with rock bottom real estate prices? In which case bad luck Edmonton can't seem to ever catch a break.
 
^ It appears to be like an anomaly given that we have such a huge population growth. Somehow, real estate prices in Edmonton have not kept up with the rest of the country (or the world for that matter).
 
^ It appears to be like an anomaly given that we have such a huge population growth. Somehow, real estate prices in Edmonton have not kept up with the rest of the country (or the world for that matter).

Or Winnipeg, for that matter. How is that city is outpacing Edmonton on the pricing side? Winnipeg used to reside a decade or two behind Edmonton. Is Edmonton now looking jealously at Regina? :shrug:
 
Why in the world are you guys lamenting the low cost of housing here compared to the rest of the country? Edmonton is one of the few places where the market has remained sane. Yeah, you're not going to be getting a lot of speculative investment but you're also not going to see it crater overnight, either. This is a good thing.
 
Why in the world are you guys lamenting the low cost of housing here compared to the rest of the country? Edmonton is one of the few places where the market has remained sane. Yeah, you're not going to be getting a lot of speculative investment but you're also not going to see it crater overnight, either. This is a good thing.

For a lot of people though, their primary residence is all or nearly all of their investment pool meant to carry them through retirement. If it's not at least providing a necessary rate of return (i.e.net capital appreciation), then their nest egg ends up being insufficient to carry them through retirement.
 
For a lot of people though, their primary residence is all or nearly all of their investment pool meant to carry them through retirement. If it's not at least providing a necessary rate of return (i.e.net capital appreciation), then their nest egg ends up being insufficient to carry them through retirement.

Sounds like a them problem as people are able to save more of their income and make different investments. High cost of housing means less of your income can be used towards savings.
 
Why in the world are you guys lamenting the low cost of housing here compared to the rest of the country? Edmonton is one of the few places where the market has remained sane. Yeah, you're not going to be getting a lot of speculative investment but you're also not going to see it crater overnight, either. This is a good thing.

It is being said that this is the reason most of the product built in this city has to be cheap and ugly. I don't lament low housing costs in Edmonton, I am lamenting the apparent consequence. (for the record, i don't buy that being the whole picture, I believe it has more to do with what Rocket252 shared above)
 
Sounds like a them problem as people are able to save more of their income and make different investments. High cost of housing means less of your income can be used towards savings.

+1 Importantly, it can be re-invested into something that can increase productivity in the economy. Financing is generally really hard in Canada because so much wealth is locked up in and paying for real estate.
 


Back
Top