OC Transpo


Andy Hayden and Durrell should have built the damn bus tunnel in the early 90s when they had a chance. We were at a point where an expensive bus tunnel could not provide enough capacity long term (based on a trajectory that did not see Covid coming).

The problem isn't the conversion to rail, but the City deciding to cut bus service instead of reallocating resources saved from rail expansion. Let's just hope that when Stage 2 West opens, we have a Mayor who will do the right thing and maintain, and even improve bus service with the savings.

Ultimately, rail is more attractive than buses. We see more interest from developers building TOD, more people who live on the train line will be willing to give up their cars. Rail gives us the flexibility and capacity to carry thousands in and out of major events. Rail was the right choice in the long run (though heavy automated rail would have been better than this weird automated trams that need drivers deal, but I digress).
 
The problem isn't the conversion to rail, but the City deciding to cut bus service instead of reallocating resources saved from rail expansion. Let's just hope that when Stage 2 West opens, we have a Mayor who will do the right thing and maintain, and even improve bus service with the savings.

You imagine there is a pile of money from rail "savings"? Being spent on cars or something? There is basically no savings. The rise in interest rates means phase 2 will be even more expensive than forecast. We can raise taxes or cut service further. There is no other magical solution. Sure we can tweak but straightening routes. Making people walk more but end of the day we are in for more cuts or we need to pony up more tax dollars. Fares are at their upper limit already where they start to lose riders.
 
Reading this today.

https://www.ctvnews.ca/ottawa/article/city-of-ottawa-posts-job-for-new-transit-services-gm/

So Ottawa is just starting to look for Renee Amilcars replacement?

I have a feeling that isn't completely the case but this article makes it sound like they posted the job opening yesterday.

An executive search is now underway for a new general manager of Transit Services, as the current GM, Renée Amilcar, formally leaves her role on Friday.

“The goal is to find an experienced leader with extensive public transit experience who will ensure the continued delivery of safe and reliable transit services to residents, while advancing major city-wide transformational transit projects,” City Manager Wendy Stephanson said in a memo, sent Monday.


Either god awful planning or at the very least messaging. Hey I don't have lots of plans this week. Think Renee can onboard me in 3 days through a zoom meeting?

https://keynotesearch.com/opportuni...it-services-the-city-of-ottawa-ville-dottawa/

Love to know when this page went live.

I'd also love to think Ottawa is actively headhunting/recruiting somebody.
 
You imagine there is a pile of money from rail "savings"? Being spent on cars or something? There is basically no savings. The rise in interest rates means phase 2 will be even more expensive than forecast. We can raise taxes or cut service further. There is no other magical solution. Sure we can tweak but straightening routes. Making people walk more but end of the day we are in for more cuts or we need to pony up more tax dollars. Fares are at their upper limit already where they start to lose riders.

We already had the buses and drivers. Instead of moving things around, they sent a bunch of pink slips (a year before Line 1 opened thinking it was opening in a few months) and got rid of a bunch of buses. At one point, we had 1,100 buses, now we're down to 754. When the City reviewed routes for the post-rail era, they made cuts to routes that didn't benefit from the train at all. They tried to force everyone on the train even if not necessary.

Obviously adding a train adds to the overall operational and maintenance costs, but that doesn't mean you cut your existing robust bus network. The initial idea was to take those resources, that experience and move them elsewhere to improve the overall service. Instead they just made cuts, resulting in a worse service and the loss of riders. It's a vicious circle; cut service-ridership goes down because service cucks-cut service-ridership goes down...
 
We already had the buses and drivers. Instead of moving things around, they sent a bunch of pink slips (a year before Line 1 opened thinking it was opening in a few months) and got rid of a bunch of buses. At one point, we had 1,100 buses, now we're down to 754. When the City reviewed routes for the post-rail era, they made cuts to routes that didn't benefit from the train at all. They tried to force everyone on the train even if not necessary.

Obviously adding a train adds to the overall operational and maintenance costs, but that doesn't mean you cut your existing robust bus network. The initial idea was to take those resources, that experience and move them elsewhere to improve the overall service. Instead they just made cuts, resulting in a worse service and the loss of riders. It's a vicious circle; cut service-ridership goes down because service cucks-cut service-ridership goes down...

This is just not true. The cuts didn't decrease revenue by more than they saved. That's not true of almost any transit system and certainly not ours. Even if you shut down the whole system for the morning commute that might not be true.

Even without Covid our new system required tax increases. We lost a lot of captive riders with WFH and that means we need to cut more or increase taxes or probably both. We aren't going to improve service our way out of the downturn. Being dishonest about that just muddies the debate. Now there is certainly an argument we could make busses free fast and frequent and increase taxes but this isn't a New York Democratic primary. You can't fleece the rich and pay for things and can't get elected with only the far left vote.
 
I never said the decreased revenues are worse than the money saved from cuts. I just said cuts result in reduced ridership. We'll never know how many riders we lost by cutting O-Train service to 10 minutes outside rush, and cutting service to 10 minutes AND halving trains on weekends (essentially cutting capacity by 4), but surely that discourages people from taking transit.

It's called PUBLIC transit for a reason. It's supposed to be subsidized. It will not and should not be profitable. But public transit benefits everyone, whether we use it or not. Every person on transit is one less car on the road. Why is it we have no problem subsidizing driving (no users fees for roads and highways, not even a charge for license plates now) but we nickel and dime transit?
 
I never said the decreased revenues are worse than the money saved from cuts. I just said cuts result in reduced ridership. We'll never know how many riders we lost by cutting O-Train service to 10 minutes outside rush, and cutting service to 10 minutes AND halving trains on weekends (essentially cutting capacity by 4), but surely that discourages people from taking transit.

It's called PUBLIC transit for a reason. It's supposed to be subsidized. It will not and should not be profitable. But public transit benefits everyone, whether we use it or not. Every person on transit is one less car on the road. Why is it we have no problem subsidizing driving (no users fees for roads and highways, not even a charge for license plates now) but we nickel and dime transit?

Yes we won't know but it's pretty small though not the cut I would make it was easier as cutting a bus will greatly annoy a few voters in many councilors ridings wheras waiting an extra few minutes will annoy lots of voters a very small amount.

Yes I understand you want to subsidize it more and sure less cars on the road helps everyone which was part of the consensus to expand transit. The question is how much to spend. In Ottawa voters have spoken that they prefer a less tax increase focused plan to OCTRanspo's budget. Most of them live in their cars in places that only car based transport is feasible. There isn't a magic solution that is going to change that. There are tough decisions we could take that might make things better but barring rescue by a federal government talking about nation building. Perhaps phase 3 and more LRT lines that would eventually lower our costs enough to be sustainable. This city is not raising transit taxes substantially to provide 15 instead of 30 minute bus service. Most taxpayers who take that bus wouldn't agree to it. Sure those that don't pay taxes vote too but not as much and we have high ownership rates in the city.
 
I’m thinking that the debate between a purely bus-based transit system (i.e., what Ottawa had with the Transitway) vs. a transit system with very few rail-based ‘trunk’ lines is never going to end.

Each has its benefits, and drawbacks, based on the point of view looking at it. For example, a purely bus-based system can get quite expensive to run, and can overload the available transit lanes, as happened in Ottawa. It does, however, provide the best service for riders, since it can be a fast, one-seat, ride from origin to destination. A train provides a fixed route that can move a lot of people relatively cheaply – assuming the line is used for near-capacity loads. Light loads simply means that a very large, expensive vehicle is doing the job of a bus. Having fewer rail lines, or poorly placed lines, means that the supporting bus system needs to feed as many people to the train as possible, so that it is running nearer capacity. This can add to the system cost if most of the people riding the train need to be buses to and from that train. In such a case, both the cost of buses and the cost of the train must be paid. This is, and will always be, the problem with Ottawa’s conversion.

The biggest thing about a train line is that it has to have lots of walk-ups, so that the number of buses can be reduced. Ottawa chose to convert its Transitway and an old freight-line to create its transit rail lines. But both, the old rail line and the Transitway, in particular, were built to avoid a lot of people. There are a few nodes, but a good portion of the runs are in corridors away from people – and in places that can’t easily be densified. Thus, a large number of people using transit in Ottawa are going to be bussed to one of the train nodes (to maximize train ridership, and thus, its efficiency), and, possibly, bused again from the train to their final destination.

All-in-all, Ottawa did not do a great job designing the rail lines of its transit system. Because of that, From a transit riders stance, it might have been better off sticking with its Transitways and adding below-grade capacity where needed. From the $7B saved by not converting to rail, a lot of tunneling could have been done for buses.
 
Reading this today.

https://www.ctvnews.ca/ottawa/article/city-of-ottawa-posts-job-for-new-transit-services-gm/

So Ottawa is just starting to look for Renee Amilcars replacement?

I have a feeling that isn't completely the case but this article makes it sound like they posted the job opening yesterday.

An executive search is now underway for a new general manager of Transit Services, as the current GM, Renée Amilcar, formally leaves her role on Friday.


I don't think there's anything untoward about that timeline.
 
The transit way system served virtually 100% of the population. Rail may reach 10%. Even with a great deal of TOD, you may reach 15% . The remaining 85% are beyond walking distance and are dependent on an infrequent and often unreliable bus or access to a Park n Ride which still requires car dependency. WFH has done a number on OC but our response to this has been poor, not trying to attract new classes of riders. The trend in the private sector is to return to the office, but service has worsened so much that we cannot cash in on these trends. As Richard has pointed out, our rail lines are not ideally located. Often TOD opportunities are limited whereas this was much less of a concern when they were Transit ways with buses exiting into neighbourhoods.

We have greatly overbuilt Line 2 with 400 seat trains that will barely reach the south end population even in the long term. I was a big supporter of the 2006 plan, with smaller electric trains and modest stations that reached most of Riverside South and Barrhaven. We built a very expensive system that can never recover its operating costs. The same will apply to Phase 2 Line 1 and even worse with Phase 3.

And while we are spending billions on rail, we have invested nothing on improving the bus network , not just frequency, but deferring all proposed bus priority measures to move the 85% faster and to deal with an ever increasing decentralized city. I warned about this years ago but little has been done. Instead, Ottawa has become a much more car dependent city. Where are the visionaries? There appear to be none left.
.
We can tell how bad things have become when the New Ways to Bus produced no modifications unlike what happened in the 2011 optimization. The city is now ignoring it's transit customers. Totally unresponsive which is what I saw at public meetings.
 
Last edited:
The transit way system served virtually 100% of the population. Rail may reach 10%. Even with a great deal of TOD, you may reach 15% .

Where are you getting these figures? Are you including buses that spent any part of their route on the transitway?

I’m not sure that this is an overly productive debate, as it is quite revisionist. The transitway did not serve the urban parts of the city well, and the one-seat commute was not scaleable as the city grew. It also did basically nothing to develop sustainable urban neighbourhoods. If we had built a bus tunnel back then, we’d almost certainly be converting it to rail now.

In my opinion, the mistake Ottawa made with rail was trying to replicate a suburban commuter system serving every far-flung area of the city, rather than building an actual urban transit system. Transitways would have worked great for the suburbs, but the inner urban area had to be rail.
 
I happened to speak to an OC employee by chance at a public event. He did not have much positive to say about the current situation. He said that Ottawa was the envy of North America during the Transit way days and that rail has been a big downgrade because of the additional transfers and overall slower service. He said he could speak for hours about the degradation of the service. Of course, much of this is because of city council budget decisions but also not making sure the end result of rail did not at least maintain service and speed. Ottawa is definitely no longer a leader in transit. How sad!

I think the transitway system worked well for people going downtown in the morning from the suburbs. They would get from their little suburban street all the way downtown with a minimum of stops.

For anyone trying to board downtown with hundreds of people jostling for the 3-4 busses that would pull up every minute without any sort of schedule it was a pretty abysmal situation.

For anyone using the actual 90-something routes it was similarly unpleasant, standing in a bleak suburban field while people jostled for their bus.

Overall, I think the transitway was one of the dumbest ideas in the history of public transportation. The fact that it has been imitated (the way Ottawa did it) by exactly zero cities in the 50 years since Ottawa "invented" it is a pretty clear damnation.

The fact that Jimbo botched the LRT (wrong technology, wrong design) does not make the transitway good.
 
To
I think the transitway system worked well for people going downtown in the morning from the suburbs. They would get from their little suburban street all the way downtown with a minimum of stops.

For anyone trying to board downtown with hundreds of people jostling for the 3-4 busses that would pull up every minute without any sort of schedule it was a pretty abysmal situation.

For anyone using the actual 90-something routes it was similarly unpleasant, standing in a bleak suburban field while people jostled for their bus.

Overall, I think the transitway was one of the dumbest ideas in the history of public transportation. The fact that it has been imitated (the way Ottawa did it) by exactly zero cities in the 50 years since Ottawa "invented" it is a pretty clear damnation.

The fact that Jimbo botched the LRT (wrong technology, wrong design) does not make the transitway good.
I can't disagree more. It's success was demonstrated by the downtown bus jam. It was also it's failing. We didn't build the downtown portion. Part of that can be laid on anti-transit Ontario premier Mike Harris who caused a 10 year halt to transit funding province wide.

The success of Transitway is the only reason why we built a subway.

In my Sunday discussion with the OC staffer, Route 95 came up and how fast it operated. Rail cannot compete with Route 95 and never will.

We can comment about overcrowded buses but speed of service is more important for most people. Who wants to wait 25 minutes for a bus at a rail station? That is not pleasant in the heat, the cold or pouring rain. Commuters have spoken by their mass exodus from transit. It is more than the choice of trains. It is overall bad service being delivered. We also forget the overcrowded trains before the pandemic. That was not comfortable either.

As far as how the Transitways served the city, many crosstown bus routes made use of them to speed up service and reduce transfers. Rail is much more downtown centric and is much worse at getting people to those more suburban locations.

As far as Ottawa not being a role model for other cities, many cities in North America have implemented BRT based on Ottawa's success. Winnipeg is just one example. Maybe not to the same level but that is mainly because of the lack of corridors. Ottawa has the corridors because of the Greber plan that abandoned freight corridors and created Parkway routes.

The public now knows that our rail based transit network is considerably slower than what we had with the Transitways. Rail had a role to play to grow the system but we made some bad decisions that were not going to guarantee faster service. We have made decisions that bake in slower service and it will be a challenge to overcome this.

For the 85 to 90 % who do not live near rail stations, how can we be excited by what we have built? It is not really a useable system for the majority unless you have no alternatives.

We have gone from the 1971 Beacon Hill bullet that got you downtown in 25 minutes before Transitways to 1 hour + with rail and lousy bus connections. This is really good progress.
 
Last edited:
For anyone trying to board downtown with hundreds of people jostling for the 3-4 busses that would pull up every minute without any sort of schedule it was a pretty abysmal situation.

This is the biggest single reason I refuse to have Transitway nostalgia! Ugh.

Overall, I think the transitway was one of the dumbest ideas in the history of public transportation. The fact that it has been imitated (the way Ottawa did it) by exactly zero cities in the 50 years since Ottawa "invented" it is a pretty clear damnation.

Watch Winnipeg.
 
I think the biggest mistake with the O-Train was the implementation and phasing. Stage 1 did not completely address the shortcomings of the Transitway and replaced aspects that were working well. Had Stage 1 been a Hurdman to Lincoln Fields light metro it would have been a totally different story. Especially if the terminus stations were properly built with airport-style bus gates that offered comfortable, orderly and efficient transfers, we could have maintained the suburban Transitway routes from those two points and everyone would have been happy for a few decades.

That said, I am optimistic the western extension will change things for the better.
 
I'd like to see some definitions here.

Until quite recently, virtually every neighbourhood had commuter buses running into downtown. Without a downtown tunnel, this was not sustainable. We all know this. But even a bus tunnel would have extended the life of the Transitways by decades.

The locations of rail stations are remote to most neighbourhoods, minimizing walk up possibilities. And bus connections from rail are generally unreliable
 
Until quite recently, virtually every neighbourhood had commuter buses running into downtown. Without a downtown tunnel, this was not sustainable. We all know this. But even a bus tunnel would have extended the life of the Transitways by decades.

The locations of rail stations are remote to most neighbourhoods, minimizing walk up possibilities. And bus connections from rail are generally unreliable

This still doesn't explain how you arrived at your 100% figure for transitway and 15% for rail. Or how the one-seat downtown model could continue to work as the city expanded and exponentially more buses pouring into the core from far-flung suburbs. Unless you are talking about a multi-level tunnel, its capacity wouldn't have been that much greater than the old transitway.

And that is without even talking about how much more expensive it is to run single routes further and further out from the core.
 
5th
I think the biggest mistake with the O-Train was the implementation and phasing. Stage 1 did not completely address the shortcomings of the Transitway and replaced aspects that were working well. Had Stage 1 been a Hurdman to Lincoln Fields light metro it would have been a totally different story. Especially if the terminus stations were properly built with airport-style bus gates that offered comfortable, orderly and efficient transfers, we could have maintained the suburban Transitway routes from those two points and everyone would have been happy for a few decades.

That said, I am optimistic the western extension will change things for the better.

We better see an improvement with better coverage after Phase 2 but I remain concerned with the overall speed of the trains with no resolution of go slow orders and ongoing excessive dwell times at stations.

As a southender, I remain upset with our choices of oversized regional trains not designed for frequent stopping, the fragility of single track operations and how we discarded interlining into downtown. The unpredictability of two transfer trips does not encourage ridership. I always believed that the arguments against interlining were bogus.
 


Back
Top