Canadian skylines of the past


screenshot-2025-03-03-at-8-33-36%E2%80%AFpm-png.634296


screenshot-2025-03-03-at-9-29-53%E2%80%AFpm-png.634305


screenshot-2025-03-03-at-9-29-46%E2%80%AFpm-png.634304


screenshot-2025-03-03-at-8-41-36%E2%80%AFpm-png.634298
 
Harbour Grace. It was very nearly our capital, but like most of the properly dense, historic regional towns in Newfoundland, it declined to almost nothing in favour of 1980s strip malls and bungalows in new communities along the Trans Canada Highway.

This is the same view - you can recognize the one surviving building on the right :haha:

494325841-1936553963554442-1535485120559695639-n.jpg


Screenshot-2025-05-18-112203.png
 
I know. It's sad.

We lost quite a few towns like Harbour Grace in favour of places like Clarenville.

Screenshot-2025-05-18-140550.png


And we still are. Deer Lake, Grand Falls-Windsor, Bishop's Falls, Gander, Clarenville... even fucking Whitborne... are still pulling people away from older coastal towns farther down peninsular trunk highways.

I think Bonavista is the only notable one that has reversed the trend.

Screenshot-2025-05-18-154032.png
 
:previous:

Holy shit!!!

That's horrible. :eek:

This belongs in the ugly Canada thread.

I think much of it was destroyed by fire (1944), and then time left it behind. Even though people see many photos of what is left historically in NL, there was much more destroyed as well.
 
Sin. 10 years earlier and they likely would've been rebuilt. More modest, but recovery would've included some form of reconstruction in that area, as opposed to just... oh sure they can drive and park in Bay Roberts.
 
Sin. 10 years earlier and they likely would've been rebuilt. More modest, but recovery would've included some form of reconstruction in that area, as opposed to just... oh sure they can drive and park in Bay Roberts.

In 1944, as you can see from the pic a few years earlier, people were starting to use automobile transportation. That part of the island was the first to have "roads", outside St. John's. You couldn't drive properly to Gander until the 1950s, and it wasn't all paved until the mid '60s. PS My ancestry goes back to that area, my 3rd gr grandmother was from Carbonear.


The three great fires of Harbour Grace:
"the three “great fires” fires of 1832, 1858 and 1944"
https://conceptionbaymuseum.com/2019/04/12/profile-toussaints-fire-1858/
 
^Good find.

I like the look of Georgian architecture, but it's hard to find it in large quantities anymore. North Americans had an "out with the old, in with the new" mentality where anything up to and including major landmarks inevitably met the wrecker's ball to be replaced with something else from the beginning of settlement up until about 1975. So even if most places in Eastern North America were settled before 1850, these buildings would have been at risk of demolition for over 125 years and very few of those buildings were grandiose by even late Victorian standards.

Isn't everything in that pic other than the Bank of Montreal pantheon long gone?
 
The Maritimes have a lot of classic Georgian architecture and Halifax is ground zero for gems from that era (Saint John is a bit newer but had a major fire in the 1870's; Charlottetown has some similar style buildings but is smaller and also newer). The provincial legislature in NS is Georgian for example, and the town clock is one of a few local landmarks done in the Palladian style. PEI's legislature is a bit later and done in a similar style. Because this style was so dominant it was more influential on later architecture in the region as well. Dalhousie's original building was Georgian. It is gone now but the newer campus from circa 1900 used a similar style.

Part of the reason for this is that the region was relatively developed by 1850 but then grew relatively little from 1850-1950 while just about everywhere else in North America boomed. The Georgian building and glass tower aesthetic in Halifax is more or less unique in North America or maybe the world. Unfortunately, Halifax is really bad with heritage preservation and it's not that hard to tear a building down even if it's from 1800.

They are some of the most visually appealing historical buildings, and are often nicer looking than later Victorians, IMO.
 
^Good find.

I like the look of Georgian architecture, but it's hard to find it in large quantities anymore. North Americans had an "out with the old, in with the new" mentality where anything up to and including major landmarks inevitably met the wrecker's ball to be replaced with something else from the beginning of settlement up until about 1975. So even if most places in Eastern North America were settled before 1850, these buildings would have been at risk of demolition for over 125 years and very few of those buildings were grandiose by even late Victorian standards.

Isn't everything in that pic other than the Bank of Montreal pantheon long gone?

I think maybe that church is still there in some shape or form. Hard to see from Google street view due to the pedestrianization of La Gauchietere in Chinatown (might be the steeple visible):
https://www.google.com/maps/place/L...try=ttu&g_ep=EgoyMDI1MDYwOS4wIKXMDSoASAFQAw==

Here it is. I don't know if it is the same church though (if so, the angle seems perpendicular to that of the photo, from my own knowledge of the streets of Montreal). https://www.google.com/maps/place/L...try=ttu&g_ep=EgoyMDI1MDYwOS4wIKXMDSoASAFQAw==
 
Earliest known photograph of Montreal (1851). I believe that this is St. Patrick's Basilica (finished 1847). It's still there!

first-photo-picture-montreal-1.jpg


1536px-Basilique_Saint_Patrick_Montreal_06.jpg
 


Back
Top