As area plans go, the Broadway Plan surely is ambitious: nearly 140 projects in the development pipeline, representing tens of thousands of units. It is not a secret that Vancouver suffers from a profound shortage of housing, and more homes are a good thing.
But the Broadway Plan area is full of renters, many of whom live in low-rise apartment buildings with relatively affordable rents thanks to long tenures.
An area resident may be forgiven for thinking: yes, we need housing. But why does all of it have to be built here?
The answer is a simple one. Under mayor Ken Sim, with only a few exceptions, like the area around certain Skytrain stations, it’s only legal to build a new apartment building on top of an older one. And there are lots of apartment buildings in the Broadway Corridor.
To be fair to Sim, this has been the status quo in Vancouver for a long time. But he’s defended that status quo.
Former OneCity councillor Christine Boyle tabled a motion to allow rental and non-market housing in Shaughnessy—which, despite its reputation, has some of the lowest land values in the city, per square foot. Sim rejected it out of hand, despite Shaughnessy declining in population while the rest of Vancouver increased—and despite the opportunity the motion offered to let more people live in a leafy, healthy neighbourhood near jobs, transit and greenspace.
More ambitious housing policy, like legalizing small apartments everywhere in Vancouver, would likely also be rejected by the mayor and his ABC party.