Yes, while also competing with the same district for shoppers and diners.
The stadium might work, the housing sounds good, and the offices might be ok eventually, but the collective volume and spread of retail would be a challenge.
Gates Phase 1 is 887 residential units, 380,000 sf of office, and 180,000 sf of retail and restaurants. I don't see what the other Phases have, but maybe 1,000 more housing units, a similar amount of office, and a smattering of additional retail? Along with the other density along Broadway and Alameda, the walkable folks would mean there's always some activity...but the retail and restaurants will need many times that many customers, mostly by rail or car. That can work, though it's hard to do.
First, there's a lot of retail space to fill, even with a substantial inflow of people by car and train. Second, the energy would be diffused among different areas, making it hard to establish critical mass in any "quadrant" and making each quadrant compete with the others. The driving public shows limited willingness to walk a few blocks, and they're most of the necessary clientele.
The similar places that work tend to cluster their retail into limited areas. They're often in great natural settings like on waterfronts...like Gates minus Santa Fe Drive. Otherwise the upstairs uses tend to do better than the street-level businesses. Developers know this but they're chronically over-optimistic about retail. It seems like the majority of mixed-use districts--as well as downtown-style complexes--fail as retail centers in the end.
The stadium might work, the housing sounds good, and the offices might be ok eventually, but the collective volume and spread of retail would be a challenge.
Gates Phase 1 is 887 residential units, 380,000 sf of office, and 180,000 sf of retail and restaurants. I don't see what the other Phases have, but maybe 1,000 more housing units, a similar amount of office, and a smattering of additional retail? Along with the other density along Broadway and Alameda, the walkable folks would mean there's always some activity...but the retail and restaurants will need many times that many customers, mostly by rail or car. That can work, though it's hard to do.
First, there's a lot of retail space to fill, even with a substantial inflow of people by car and train. Second, the energy would be diffused among different areas, making it hard to establish critical mass in any "quadrant" and making each quadrant compete with the others. The driving public shows limited willingness to walk a few blocks, and they're most of the necessary clientele.
The similar places that work tend to cluster their retail into limited areas. They're often in great natural settings like on waterfronts...like Gates minus Santa Fe Drive. Otherwise the upstairs uses tend to do better than the street-level businesses. Developers know this but they're chronically over-optimistic about retail. It seems like the majority of mixed-use districts--as well as downtown-style complexes--fail as retail centers in the end.