Sorry to reply to a 4 year old post
Bayshore may be the same distance from the core but it has freeway access from Barrhaven and points south via 416, Kanata and Arnprior via 417 and Carleton place via the 7. Bayshore is also still inside the Greenbelt and I feel like that makes a big difference. Not to mention the Island Park Bridge connecting the west end to Aylmer, QC. I would argue that Bayshore has a higher population within a short drive.
It doesn't really matter how close to the core we are because if you are downtown you already have other options that have better stores. Totally agree the stores are not the best or unique. You can find them at other malls that have even better stores too.
While Orleans does have a large and growing population there aren't any other large communities nearby. We only have Rockland and Gloucester. Gloucester people can just go to St. Laurent. Russell people can use the 417 to get to St. Laurent and downtown just as quickly. We tend to work downtown and spend our money there. This was before e-commerce took over which probably meant spending even less money at the mall in the last few years. Work from home might help Orleans businesses somewhat however the mayor and premier have decided that we must be coerced to continue to spend money downtown instead of within our own communities.
Orleans is solidly affluent middle class but the west end is obviously wealthier. Thinking of Kanata tech industry, Westboro, etc.