[Burnaby] The Amazing Brentwood | 15 Towers | 186m | 56 flrs | U/C & Proposed


How about they open some of the stores in the existing portion of the mall already? I'm looking at you, the suit place, the donut place and the nail salon place. Ridiculous that they've been "coming soon" for months and years. If you're not going to open, let somebody else who will move in.

i think the problem is nobody wants to move in. I'm sure Shape would be more than happy to take money from someone who wants to actually move in and open up in those empty spaces.

I doubt suitsupply has been paying their lease this entire time just for it to be an empty shell
 
The refurbishment is cancelled. There will be residential towers where the old mall is located.

Thanks for the clarification. From Dailyhive you posted, this was stated:

This includes building two towers reaching 55 storeys to 80 storeys at the core of the site — on the footprint of the existing old indoor mall structure, which would be entirely demolished for not only the two tall towers but also 12-storey base podium structures.

I am wondering if the 12-storey base podium(s) will include a couple of indoor retail mall space, knowing that the City requires 51% of retail spaces to be retained. Also understand that the base podium(s) will also include office spaces.

A purely outdoor mall experience does not work. They should rebuild the indoor mall since there is already a link to the current indoor food court and Rec Room/Cinema, etc.

With this uncertainty, it is no wonder new businesses are hesitant about opening up here.
 
Thanks for the clarification. From Dailyhive you posted, this was stated:

This includes building two towers reaching 55 storeys to 80 storeys at the core of the site — on the footprint of the existing old indoor mall structure, which would be entirely demolished for not only the two tall towers but also 12-storey base podium structures.

I am wondering if the 12-storey base podium(s) will include a couple of indoor retail mall space, knowing that the City requires 51% of retail spaces to be retained. Also understand that the base podium(s) will also include office spaces.

A purely outdoor mall experience does not work. They should rebuild the indoor mall since there is already a link to the current indoor food court and Rec Room/Cinema, etc.

With this uncertainty, it is no wonder new businesses are hesitant about opening up here.

I can't see any suggestion that the podium(s) might include any indoor mall space. The report to Council last year said "the commercial area is identified to extend northward along the Ridgelawn Drive extension, to serve residents of the Terraced Residential Zone, and areas beyond to the north and northeast of the site. The commercial uses within this area may include ground oriented retail, restaurants, office spaces, hotel and commercial residential rental."

In other words, it's one street with retail/restaurant in the base, aimed at serving the residents in the new towers. If there's office use, in the current and forseeable future it would most likely be medical offices, and maybe other services like a travel agent or insurance broker, to serve the residential population.

The report also says there's no intended addition of commercial space from the previous masterplan. Rather, it's a lot less. As you note, 49% of that space can now be converted to rental residential space. So that means a total commercial space (including the already completed Plaza retail) that's only half what they showed in the first masterplan. And some of that can be provided as hotel space.
 
Remember that the old mall is closing down this Spring.

They said it's happening in May.

The Interior Centre at The Amazing Brentwood is closing this May as the 28-acre Master Plan transformation continues.

The Amendment to The Amazing Brentwood Master Plan is still under review with the City of Burnaby and is aligned with the City’s Official Community Plan and ensures that we remain flexible to evolving market demands, municipal mandates and lifestyle trends.

In anticipation for its approval, the existing Interior Centre will be closing this May as we prepare for the site’s next phase featuring world-class SHAPE homes, green spaces, walkable boulevards and pedestrian street front shops, creating a new retail experience at the centre of The Amazing Brentwood Master Plan.

https://theamazingbrentwood.com/interior-centre-closure/

Closure Areas
Entrances to the Interior Centre will be closed along with parts of the surface parking lots. This includes:

Entrances

Level 1: Former CIBC Entrance
Level 1: Entrance by Brentwood Dental
Level 2: London Drugs Entrance
Parking

Lower East Lot (Previous Lower Sears)
Upper North Lot (By London Drugs)
Upper East Lot (Previous Sears Rooftop)

All the back roads and parking will be closed off.
 
I agree an outdoor mall does not work in Vancouver.

Hmm, people seem to say this all the time but aren't all of our "traditional" shopping streets just "outdoor malls"? Alberni/Robson, Robson/Denman, Yaletown, Main/Kingsway/Broadway, that sort of thing. They seem to all be doing fine. And judging by malls like Capilano Mall, International Village (Tinseltown), Lougheed Mall, and basically any mall other than Metrotown or Park Royal I'm actually not entirely sure if indoor malls work in Vancouver anymore.
 
Hmm, people seem to say this all the time but aren't all of our "traditional" shopping streets just "outdoor malls"? Alberni/Robson, Robson/Denman, Yaletown, Main/Kingsway/Broadway, that sort of thing. They seem to all be doing fine. And judging by malls like Capilano Mall, International Village (Tinseltown), Lougheed Mall, and basically any mall other than Metrotown or Park Royal I'm actually not entirely sure if indoor malls work in Vancouver anymore.

I mean any mall has numerous things working for and against it. Being indoors/outdoors is just part of the equation so that's why it's too simplistic to make a blanket statement about indoor vs outdoor malls. I mean it's up to the landlord and tenants to figure out what it does to foot traffic, PSF sales etc.

And if the impetus of these outdoor malls is to unlock ten sixty storey residential towers then that is just as important.
 
McArthur Glen seems to work well for an outdoor mall. It depends on the neighbourhood and mix of tenants the landlord can attract.
I think the bigger issue at Brentwood will be continuity of the retail facades under the towers to give it a primarily retail feel.
I think that'll mean reducing the frontage of the residential lobbies or even moving them up a level.
I think they have the benefit of not having a parking entrance for each tower.
They should avoid having a lot of smaller retail units like at Burrard Place, for example, which are not appealing to mainstream tenants.

All the back roads and parking will be closed off.

No more free parking.
 
Hmm, people seem to say this all the time but aren't all of our "traditional" shopping streets just "outdoor malls"? Alberni/Robson, Robson/Denman, Yaletown, Main/Kingsway/Broadway, that sort of thing. They seem to all be doing fine. And judging by malls like Capilano Mall, International Village (Tinseltown), Lougheed Mall, and basically any mall other than Metrotown or Park Royal I'm actually not entirely sure if indoor malls work in Vancouver anymore.

You can add Pacific Center to that list of indoor malls, and you find that 2 out of those 3 are the highest performing (i.e. top revenue earning per square footage) malls not just in BC or Western Canada but in all of Canada, and not just outside Ontario.

That wouldn't be the case if "indoor malls don't work in Vancouver anymore.".

On the flip side, on the one hand the "outdoor malls" or shopping streets you listed above there all have high turnover rate among the stores that front or populate them - which means they struggle for steady regular revenue even in hgh foot-traffic area.

On the other hand they're all located in Vancouver.
None in the 'burbs'

We can see from Amazing Brentwood mall's come-down how much their viability as a shopping model decreased when you locate them outside the high-density center of the metro region.

Essentially if you're an outdoor mall or outdoor shopping experience-type center in BC, you need to be located in an area that has a guaranteed flow of foot-traffic (read : spenders) flowing through - typically, in a commercial or business and employment center of the province as all those malls currently are - where office workers and business people are going to pass through anyway.
And you also need to be resilient enough to withstand the months of low foot-traffic when (non-employee/worker) shoppers won't be inclined to spend most of their leisure time or shopping trips in the rain holding umbrellas looking for deals or doing their weekly shopping runs.
 
You can add Pacific Center to that list of indoor malls, and you find that 2 out of those 3 are the highest performing (i.e. top revenue earning per square footage) malls not just in BC or Western Canada but in all of Canada, and not just outside Ontario.

That wouldn't be the case if "indoor malls don't work in Vancouver anymore.".

On the flip side, on the one hand the "outdoor malls" or shopping streets you listed above there all have high turnover rate among the stores that front or populate them - which means they struggle for steady regular revenue even in hgh foot-traffic area.

On the other hand they're all located in Vancouver.
None in the 'burbs'

We can see from Amazing Brentwood mall's come-down how much their viability as a shopping model decreased when you locate them outside the high-density center of the metro region.

Essentially if you're an outdoor mall or outdoor shopping experience-type center in BC, you need to be located in an area that has a guaranteed flow of foot-traffic (read : spenders) flowing through - typically, in a commercial or business and employment center of the province as all those malls currently are - where office workers and business people are going to pass through anyway.
And you also need to be resilient enough to withstand the months of low foot-traffic when (non-employee/worker) shoppers won't be inclined to spend most of their leisure time or shopping trips in the rain holding umbrellas looking for deals or doing their weekly shopping runs.

I mean, we have dead and dying indoor malls in the Lower Mainland and it doesn't seem like we have dead or dying "outdoor mall" commercial streets. Two or three successful indoor malls does not save the other indoor malls from their seemingly inevitable death spiral. And turnover is a good thing I don't know why you think it isn't. It means commercial activity is actively adapting to the needs of the local consumer. That's a healthy continuous renewal. It's when businesses are closing without replacements or old stores sit and decay with little traffic that you can say a commercial area isn't working.

If you want some examples of suburban "outdoor malls" that are doing great with no nearby "indoor mall": Burnaby Heights, Fraser Highway in Langley, Lower Lonsdale, Central Lonsdale, Columbia Street in New West (unless you consider New West Station an "indoor mall") all come to mind. Notably these are all areas that densified before we became a car dominated culture. Brentwood is trying to replicate that model: Densify in a transit and pedestrian oriented way and try to capture the pedestrian traffic that comes about as a result.
 
I mean, we have dead and dying indoor malls in the Lower Mainland and it doesn't seem like we have dead or dying "outdoor mall" commercial streets. Two or three successful indoor malls does not save the other indoor malls from their seemingly inevitable death spiral. And turnover is a good thing I don't know why you think it isn't. It means commercial activity is actively adapting to the needs of the local consumer. That's a healthy continuous renewal. It's when businesses are closing without replacements or old stores sit and decay with little traffic that you can say a commercial area isn't working.

How could you ever tell if an "outdoor mall" or commercial streetor exterior shopping experience area were "dying" in the same way that you can if with indoor mall is? (like,....say,..... the owners trying to sell up or redevelop. Or a high vacancy rate in the tenant stores)?

"outdoor malls" typically don't have singular or commercial owners or ownership groups to speak of - since they're invariably located on public streets, nor are they graded by the same metrics for success or viability that indoor malls are (revenue generated per square meter....because you can actually calculate and accurately measure those two variables....or foot-traffic generated).
And the only close to reasonable (and yet still probably largely unreliable) statistic you can go by, is the level of turnover in the nearby stores that front that outdoor shopping area.

And in virtually every example you had given earlier they have HIGH turnover rate.
It's not easy to maintain a retail presence in, or adjacent to these "outdoor shopping" areas or malls, unless you have a high-profit margin product you're dealing in that can sustain your periods of lulls in sales activity and slow or low foot-traffic periods.
Hence the "high street" concept for outdoor shopping experience.

And just how viable are those for most areas in which you'd want to have a "mall" in the traditional sense of the word?

And it's not just two or three successul indoor malls that I pointed out as the examples.
They are two or three of the most successful in all of Canada.

Besides which, if the "indoor mall" concept were a dying concept on a death spiral then why would the likes of Oakridge and Richmond Center double down on what you think is a dying concept?
Shopping habits have changed thanks to the proliferation of online shopping and the likes of Amazon and delivery shopping, but that hasn't completely negated people's innate desire to socially connect or still go out to places that induce social interaction the way the malls have traditionally done.

Do they need to adapt to modern habits and technology?
Aboslutely?
Every business model does.
Adapt or die.

That's a mantra that's not only true in evolution but in business as well.

Those malls you pointed out previously were dying because their owners were slow or reluctant to adapt to a changing market and changing habits and predilictions of modern shoppers.
No shock or surprise there.

And obviously the pandemic and lockdowns and ensuing shift to remote-work/work-from-home only helped accelerate some of that slide to extinction for some of those malls.

If you want some examples of suburban "outdoor malls" that are doing great with no nearby "indoor mall": Burnaby Heights, Fraser Highway in Langley, Lower Lonsdale, Central Lonsdale, Columbia Street in New West (unless you consider New West Station an "indoor mall") all come to mind. Notably these are all areas that densified before we became a car dominated culture. Brentwood is trying to replicate that model: Densify in a transit and pedestrian oriented way and try to capture the pedestrian traffic that comes about as a result.


Again....

"doing great" by what metric,....exactly?

"great" seems to be doing a hell of a lot of work in your assessment.

Do you have any numbers at all that can back up that sentiment and opinion?
Because at this point that's all that that is.

And anecdotal opinion.

And by the way, as has been pointed out several times both on this very thread and in the forum in general, is that trying to create that "outdoor mall"/shopping experience that relies in the "pedestrian traffic that comes about as a result" (....of densification of transit and pedestrain-orientated development)... as you intimate,....BUT,.....in an area that has explicitly been poorly designed and planned for pedestrian foot-traffic and movement (i.e. Brentwood) - is in essence, a strategy doomed to failure.
Or at least, not the high-flying success you were once selling.

Hence the seeming inability of the Amazing Brentwood mall or plaza at its current location to capture what the initial concept was trying to sell.

A lot of people have pointed out that the developers were trying to replicate or recreate ( and indeed this WAS part of their initial marketing pitch),... a "Yaletown of the suburbs" residential and commercial developmentexperience,.....but without the requisite actual Yaletown surrounding density, infrastructure or
resident income level.

It's no wonder therefore their expectations have been pared down considerably since those initial plans.
 
^^ It's the same thing for free parking versus pay parking. How much does that affect sales, turnover of traffic etc.

Unless you have all the sales data most of these observations are just anecdotal. It's the same kind of people who buy retail based on supposed foot traffic but then notice everyone is commuting through the area and never stop.

I think it's way too early to discount Brentwood as a community with only a fraction of the future development to come to the area. Will they ever need luxury retail? Will Surrey ever need luxury retail? Who knows. Unless there's a huge population of rich people moving into the area then I doubt it.
 
Its a shame :( The city planners really messed this one up. I sometimes wonder who gets voted on to make these decisions. I agree an outdoor mall does not work in Vancouver.

If Brentwood mall eventually fails, then we know why. It will also serve as a warning to Metrotown.

Brentwood Mall - Not amazing anymore without a large indoor portion.
 
^^ It's the same thing for free parking versus pay parking. How much does that affect sales, turnover of traffic etc.

Unless you have all the sales data most of these observations are just anecdotal. It's the same kind of people who buy retail based on supposed foot traffic but then notice everyone is commuting through the area and never stop.

I think it's way too early to discount Brentwood as a community with only a fraction of the future development to come to the area. Will they ever need luxury retail? Will Surrey ever need luxury retail? Who knows. Unless there's a huge population of rich people moving into the area then I doubt it.

Anyway my original contention was with the idea that outdoor malls "do not work" in Vancouver, when they clearly do. And anyone who thinks the outdoor portion of Brentwood isn't working clearly hasn't been there. The outdoor plaza is bustling and the restaurants and businesses certainly don't seem empty to me. It's certainly working better than Capilano Mall, and Brentwood isn't even half built out yet.
 
I cant imagine living in the parts of these towers facing each other. Your view out the window will be directly into the apartments right next to you and vice versa. Not to mention being in the permanent shadow of the south tower.

Yeah, it wouldn't be great for sure. On related note, Tower 1 recently had the SW corner 2-storey penthouse available for rent. It looked like a really nice unit and the price wasn't completely outrageous for what it was, but I wasn't sure if the tower currently under construction will reach the same height and block the north-facing view?

Another consideration was the lack of green park space in and around Brentwood, which is why Metrotown still has and edge over it IMHO. But the unit was very special and still has me thinking about it. :rolleyes:
 


Back
Top