Truenorth00
New member
Some good points but in Canada Finance is where we challenge the other departments on spending. Sure maybe it should be like Treasury in the US that just does accounting but politically it's good to have at least one strong voice arguing we shouldn't spend. We need to get over our risk aversion in a lot of areas for sure. But look how that works out when you rush out something like an arrival app that was literally a rounding error and which being delayed a single day was probably worth more than the $50 million cost.
First off, we have the policy challenge function. That's what Treasury Board does. They make sure that your procurement or policy proposal meets your intent, the government's intent and is funded. Finance is mostly concerned with management of the financial sector and basic financial management of the different. Once again, so many people educated by CNN and Fox on how the USG works don't understand our own government.
Next, risk aversion and efficiency are diametrically opposed. If you aren't willing to risk something like Arrive Can in the middle of an unprecedented crisis, government will never be able to get anything done. No politician will ever say that out loud. But they all know it. All this talk of running the government like a business and nobody ever talks about how businesses take a ton more risk, because they are largely focused on the reward.