FYI - Heritage and UDAC veto'd the balconies on this one - not the owner.
And the owner argued (successfully) that the exterior walls (other than the main floor) don't need to be masonry because the precedent was set with those truly ugly buildings across the street.
The more accurate before and after shot for this development should be the lot as it currently is compared to what it will be.
Anyways - Labroco - you of all posters on this forum should not be poo-poo'ing owners that actually want to develop their underused properties in the Exchange.
wonder if the concept of co-op parking garages would work where couple land owners and area developers buy shares and build a couple for the area to keep prices from going crazy and tap into co-op grants and such
Please don't give them any ideas on how to build more bloody parking downtown lol.
FYI - Heritage and UDAC veto'd the balconies on this one - not the owner.
And the owner argued (successfully) that the exterior walls (other than the main floor) don't need to be masonry because the precedent was set with those truly ugly buildings across the street.
The more accurate before and after shot for this development should be the lot as it currently is compared to what it will be.
Anyways - Labroco - you of all posters on this forum should not be poo-poo'ing owners that actually want to develop their underused properties in the Exchange.
They may have used metal panel, but it is layered with different transparencies....it has a full glass front wall....the massing is unique...the ground floor is transparent and active....it has an excellent ground floor experience all the way around with retail spaces on the sidewalk and covered pedestrian spaces.
What really perplexes me is the inconsistency. How does that project on McMillan get rejected, but this gets approved when it's inside a national historic site?
^ not sure you guys know exactly what you are talking about - but this particular building has to go thru UDAC, Heritage and Variances. It literally has to jump through all the hoops and all the checks and balances possible.
Yes, but it didn't have to go to a "public hearing", I think because it's within the downtown zoning bylaw boundaries. Planning, Property, and Development processed and approved the application through an internal review. The McMillan project was reviewed by Planning, Property, and Development and they recommended it be approved, but the final say came down to the councilors at the City Centre Community Committee (who ended up voting against it). So the inconsistency is public hearing vs. no public hearing.
Its lazy architecture...no two ways about it.....its indefensible....it doesn't have to be a showpiece....but the exchange district deserves to have architects spend more than three minutes considering their designs.....it looks like a draftsman designed it.
even beyond its lazy design, it is repellant at the ground floor...it has parking at grade...that is unacceptable....
i agree...all anyone can ask for is a reasonable building....this isn't that....it can be simple and clean, but it still needs to be considered.....it's disappointing that someone would take such a prominent site and care so little....its not about cost at all...its about effort....even using metal panel, you could do something of interest....there was just no effort.
It's disappointing that they gave HAF money to projects that care so little about the public realm....I'm pretty sure UDAC hates it too, but they have no teeth to stop it.
Exactly this, internal review vs public hearing with council input.
Variances are public?
Also, I think anyone who has ever dealt with UDAC or Heritage reviews - would probably rather go through any other process available. They aren't a walk in the park.