1186-1194 Wellington St West | 61m | 16f | U/C


I preferred version 2, in particular the orange/brass window frames that added some much needed warmth and colour. Overall, still quite a nice building.
 
Minto’s Hintonburg highrise proposal set to go to Ontario Land Tribunal

Simon Hopkins, OBJ
July 24, 2023


The ongoing dispute over a proposed highrise at the corner of Wellington Street West and Parkdale Avenue will continue this summer.

Housing developer Minto Communities wants to build the mixed-use project at 1186, 1188 and 1194 Wellington St. W. on the southwest corner of the intersection.

Its 2021 application was amended and finalized in August 2022 with a plan for a 16-storey apartment building featuring more than 200 units as well as about 13,000 square feet of ground-floor retail space. The 0.6-acre property is currently occupied by a Rexall drug store and the old Elmdale Theatre.

The height limit for the property is six storeys, and Minto sought a zoning bylaw amendment to accommodate the project. The company’s proposal to the city outlined a traffic flow strategy and argued that the development would be a net benefit to the area.

City council ultimately rejected the proposal last year. Minto appealed the city’s decision to the Ontario Land Tribunal, an independent body that is the province’s final arbiter of development disputes.

The tribunal has had three preliminary meetings on the issue, and a hearing on the dispute has been scheduled for Aug. 14 at 10 a.m. It’s unclear when the tribunal will announce its ruling.

In addition to Minto and the city, representatives from the Hintonburg Community Association and Suncor Energy will also take part in the hearing. The community association plans to argue against the development alongside Suncor, which owns a Petro-Canada gas station across the street.

Kitchissippi Coun. Jeff Leiper, who lives near the site, said the community’s reaction to the project has been largely negative.

“The majority of what I’m hearing is opposition to the building,” he said, adding nearby residents are concerned about the height of the proposed tower and the increased traffic the development would generate.

“I think there is significant discomfort that if this building is allowed to move ahead, it will see significant increase in (building) height in many more places,” said Leiper, who also chairs council’s planning and housing committee.

The site’s proximity to light rail, bus routes and Highway 417 makes it an appealing location for many residents, but nearby streets aren’t designed to handle the volume of traffic that comes with such large-scale projects, he added.

Petra Thoms, who owns the World of Maps across the street, said she’s worried the development will increase congestion in the neighbourhood and make it harder for customers to find parking near her store.

Thoms said she’d like to see the building set back farther from the sidewalk to provide more room for trees and walking space.

“We need more affordable places, but they’re not building that,” she added.

But Amandine Pajor, who owns the Amandine Patisserie French pastry and coffee shop just down the street, said she thinks the development would boost traffic in her store.

“It would be a good thing for me and my business,” she said.

Minto Communities, Suncor and the Hintonburg Community Association did not respond to requests for comment.

https://obj.ca/minto-highrise-plan-to-go-to-tribunal/
 
Minto’s Hintonburg highrise proposal set to go to Ontario Land Tribunal

Simon Hopkins, OBJ
July 24, 2023


The ongoing dispute over a proposed highrise at the corner of Wellington Street West and Parkdale Avenue will continue this summer.

Housing developer Minto Communities wants to build the mixed-use project at 1186, 1188 and 1194 Wellington St. W. on the southwest corner of the intersection.

Its 2021 application was amended and finalized in August 2022 with a plan for a 16-storey apartment building featuring more than 200 units as well as about 13,000 square feet of ground-floor retail space. The 0.6-acre property is currently occupied by a Rexall drug store and the old Elmdale Theatre.

The height limit for the property is six storeys, and Minto sought a zoning bylaw amendment to accommodate the project. The company’s proposal to the city outlined a traffic flow strategy and argued that the development would be a net benefit to the area.

City council ultimately rejected the proposal last year. Minto appealed the city’s decision to the Ontario Land Tribunal, an independent body that is the province’s final arbiter of development disputes.

The tribunal has had three preliminary meetings on the issue, and a hearing on the dispute has been scheduled for Aug. 14 at 10 a.m. It’s unclear when the tribunal will announce its ruling.

In addition to Minto and the city, representatives from the Hintonburg Community Association and Suncor Energy will also take part in the hearing. The community association plans to argue against the development alongside Suncor, which owns a Petro-Canada gas station across the street.

Kitchissippi Coun. Jeff Leiper, who lives near the site, said the community’s reaction to the project has been largely negative.

“The majority of what I’m hearing is opposition to the building,” he said, adding nearby residents are concerned about the height of the proposed tower and the increased traffic the development would generate.

“I think there is significant discomfort that if this building is allowed to move ahead, it will see significant increase in (building) height in many more places,” said Leiper, who also chairs council’s planning and housing committee.

The site’s proximity to light rail, bus routes and Highway 417 makes it an appealing location for many residents, but nearby streets aren’t designed to handle the volume of traffic that comes with such large-scale projects, he added.

Petra Thoms, who owns the World of Maps across the street, said she’s worried the development will increase congestion in the neighbourhood and make it harder for customers to find parking near her store.

Thoms said she’d like to see the building set back farther from the sidewalk to provide more room for trees and walking space.

“We need more affordable places, but they’re not building that,” she added.

But Amandine Pajor, who owns the Amandine Patisserie French pastry and coffee shop just down the street, said she thinks the development would boost traffic in her store.

“It would be a good thing for me and my business,” she said.

Minto Communities, Suncor and the Hintonburg Community Association did not respond to requests for comment.

https://obj.ca/minto-highrise-plan-to-go-to-tribunal/

Exactly the same response to every development in this city, in every neighbourhood, from the distant suburbs to the very core. If the building is over 6 stories, the neighbourhood comments could just be copy-pasted.
 
The Ford Government is quick to pressure municipalities to expedite their approval processes, but LPAT is pretty damn slow as well, maybe slower than municipalities.
 
There has been lots of drilling going on in the Rexall parking lot. At first I thought there were drilling boreholes but they've been there for a week now so I'm not sure it's even related to the project.
 
Province loves dumping on municipalities for their slow development application processes, but man does LPAT also take forever.
 
From Leiper's Newsletter. I'm usually in agreement with him, but not on this one. Sure it's a little taller than what is ideal on a traditional main street, but this is a gateway site. The building across the street meets zoning, but it's a giant blockbuster with no real interest. The massing of this one, the unique design and the respect for the old theatre elevates it beyond most projects of its size.

Minto Parkdale/Wellington appeal
It's a bit complicated, but I wanted to pass on that I've prevailed upon the City's legal team to file a request for review to the Ontario Land Tribunal's decision in favour of Minto at 1186 Wellington. There's no consideration for reversing the OLT's decision, but I was dismayed at the paucity of details in the written order. From my and others' perspective, the decision simply re-iterated the arguments for and against the re-zoning and there's no discernible rationale as to why it found in favour of Minto. Win or lose, politicians and staff need to understand what the OLT is thinking when it looks at an appeal; its guidance is critical to establishing the lens through which we look at development review applications. My hope is that the review's outcome will be a more comprehensive rationale for the tribunal's decision. There is, I understand, jurisprudence that speaks specifically to the requirement to do more than "outline the evidence and argument and then state the tribunal's conclusion". Work on finalizing the site plan will continue while the Tribunal reviews the decision. In the meantime, indication from Minto is that they'll be undertaking work over the next several months to get ready to build. Preparations including demolition could occur through spring and summer prior to the beginning of excavation in 2025. The overall build would likely be completed if that schedule holds in summer of 2028.

1732540166147-png.614694


1732540175875-png.614695
 
It's a nice touch they are keeping the rounded corner on Hamilton st.

Always a fan of angled/rounded setbacks at main st corners.
 
According to Leiper (from a guy on Discord), demo's coming up in April and excavation in mid-summer.
 
I'm just scratching my head at the OLT for taking this long. This was rejected under Watson.

OPA and zoning on this went to Planning Committee in May 2022! PC's decision to defer indefinitely even though City staff recommended approval was grounds for immediate appeal to the OLT. A 2.5 year delay on 214 much-needed housing units.
 


Back
Top