Winnipeg | Downtown Developments & Discussions


Things are looking up for sure but I’d hesitate to say that 2 projects that would bring roughly 750 permanent residents to DT would provide the area with the critical mass. However, if u add the Forks development and the new projects in the Exchange then we’re talking.

What Winnipeg really needs is to decide what is going to be the cities high street with the bars, restaurants, and community events where they have the balls to make the street pedestrian only. When my friends/family visit me and we go to Quebec City I know right away to head to Rue Saint Jean or the Grande Allée if I desire to have fun. In Winnipeg it’s one block of Osborne and maybe a couple blocks in the East Exchange. Maybe the Forks could be that true third space if they can establish a continuous connection with Main Street and Waterfront Drive. I know the City is capable of finding this équilibrium and I hope it’s sooner rather than later.

Man it’s been more than a year since I moved from Winnipeg where did the time go…

Check the list of downtown developments I wrote on page 628 of "Winnipeg Construction X." I counted 20 projects that are either under-construction or in predevelopment for a total of 2800 units. That would be about another 6000 people downtown, a significant increase over the current population of about 18,000.
 
Check the list of downtown developments I wrote on page 628 of "Winnipeg Construction X." I counted 20 projects that are either under-construction or in predevelopment for a total of 2800 units. That would be about another 6000 people downtown, a significant increase over the current population of about 18,000.

Yes I should have referenced all these projects and not just the two.

I was encouraged that we saw some younger people addressing the "perception vs reality" question about downtown. IMO this is huge and something that will have to be repeated frequently.

On a personal note, I like the hosts' comment about living in "south Winnipeg" (boring!), and calling St. Mary Ave. "baby Toronto". :tup:
 
appears to something going in in the former Marcello's space in the hydro building. for lease signs are down and the space is cleared down the studs with a big dumpster out front.
 
I noticed the little corner store called handy mart on the Garry street bike lane that closed a couple years ago is reopening....as a corner store....not sure if the name will change.

IMG-6088.jpg
 
P & M work starting above ground:

https://winnipeg.ctvnews.ca/construction-to-reopen-portage-and-main-begins-this-week-1.7133119

Supervised consumption site chosen:

https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/manitoba/winnipeg-supervised-consumption-site-disraeli-1.7400687

Good to see the P & m work beginning, despite the upcoming traffic issues. Sooner it gets started, the sooner it's gets completed.

The location of the supervised consumption site looks good. If you're going to have one of these it seems to make sense to tie it geographically into the area it's needed most, and link it with other social services. Apparently they help reduce mortality rates without increasing area crime, though there have been conflicting studies.

From The Lancet Oct 22, 2022:

The North American opioid crisis: how effective are supervised consumption sites?
Scientific evaluations of supervised consumption sites (SCSs) have yielded a large, consistent body of peer-reviewed research showing the effectiveness of these services in reducing various drug-related harms and generating other health and community bene- fits.1,2 We were therefore surprised to see the Commission led by Keith Humphreys and colleagues portray SCSs as a controversial intervention while exclusively citing non-peer- reviewed documents,3 and we would like to highlight a number of other inaccuracies.
First, the report misrepresents the evidence concerning SCSs as method- ologically weak.3 Although randomised controlled trials (RCTs) are consider- ed the gold standard for intervention research, RCTs of SCSs have been deemed unethical.1 Recommendations regarding SCSs must therefore rely on the best available evidence from alternative study designs, including quasi-experimental and observational studies.
Second, despite the claim of no evidence that accessing SCSs “lowers an individual’s risk of fatal overdose over time”,3 frequent SCS use was independently associated with reduced risk of all-cause mortality in a prospective cohort study of people
who inject drugs in Vancouver, BC, Canada.4 The Commissioners also ignore multiple high-quality studies showing that SCSs are indeed associated with reduced community overdose rates.1,2 Of note, a seminal paper showed that following the establishment of Insite in Vancouver in 2003 (North America’s first SCS), the overdose mortality rate within 500 m of the facility significantly declined by 35%, compared with 9% in the rest of the city.5
Third, although the report correctly notes that opponents of SCSs often argue that these services promote crime and drug use, the authors overlook existing evidence suggesting an absence of such adverse effects. Indeed, quasi-experimental studies from various settings, including Canada, Australia, Spain, and the USA have documented either no increases or reductions in crime and public disorder outcomes after SCS implementation.1,2,6,7
More real-world evidence to guide the scale-up and optimisation of SCSs in the context of ongoing overdose crises is needed. However, the Commission’s characterisation of SCSs does not rest on a solid empirical foundation, suffers from errors and omissions of evidence, and should be disregarded.
 
^ Perfect location for a SCS. Support where it's needed, close to other resources, and no NIMBYs in the area to complain. Some people have a problem with SCSs ideologically but studies show that they are effective in reducing harm and they don't encourage greater drug use.
 
^ Perfect location for a SCS. Support where it's needed, close to other resources, and no NIMBYs in the area to complain. Some people have a problem with SCSs ideologically but studies show that they are effective in reducing harm and they don't encourage greater drug use.

It’s directly across the street from the waterfront drive residential neighbourhood so I’d hardly say it’s “perfect”. The lots that we were just discussing in another thread and hoping to be developed into residential, at Duncan street and George, are a stone’s throw away. I would say this safe injection site will actually just make developing waterfront north less appealing to developers.
 
It’s directly across the street from the waterfront drive residential neighbourhood so I’d hardly say it’s “perfect”. The lots that we were just discussing in another thread and hoping to be developed into residential, at Duncan street and George, are a stone’s throw away. I would say this safe injection site will actually just make developing waterfront north less appealing to developers.

I'm not sure one could call it "directly across the street from the waterfront drive residential neighbourhood"? There are a couple of streets between 200 Disraeli and Waterfront Drive, and the Disraeli freeway is a pretty substantial barrier itself. I'm no developer, but if people have been building on Waterfront Drive, doesn't that mean they're not as worried about the neighbourhood on that side of Disraeli?
 
200 Disraeli is already over run with people using he facility. Not sure this will change that much. May in fact improve the situation.
 
Ya, I realize it’s already bad around there, so I guess it will be a “wait and see” to determine whether this has a positive/negative/no impact on the area.
 
CBC news article mentions there's a high school across the street. Again like this area is already overrun with locals and tent cities. Not sure this will move the needle on anything really.
 
It’s directly across the street from the waterfront drive residential neighbourhood so I’d hardly say it’s “perfect”. The lots that we were just discussing in another thread and hoping to be developed into residential, at Duncan street and George, are a stone’s throw away. I would say this safe injection site will actually just make developing waterfront north less appealing to developers.
I took a walk down Hastings Street in Vancouver last week. SCSs don't appear to be preventing development, and the drug problem is WAY worse there. It's not ideal, but all walks of life seem to be co-existing together. It reminds me to stop clutching my pearls so much over Winnipeg's inferior issues.
 
I took a walk down Hastings Street in Vancouver last week. SCSs don't appear to be preventing development, and the drug problem is WAY worse there. It's not ideal, but all walks of life seem to be co-existing together. It reminds me to stop clutching my pearls so much over Winnipeg's inferior issues.

I'd love to hear about your experience on Hastings and in the area generally. Is it as bad as it's made out to be?
 


Back
Top